I am not Malala: Teachers release novel against Nobel Peace winner

[war&peace]

Majority case publishers demand to add extra drama or other flavours which generate excitement for book, so they can sell large quantity of it.

So basically you are saying it is all drama.....that is what I have been saying that this is all fake and drama...nothing substantial in it.

 

[jamahir]

And if you claim yourself to be a Muslim then subscribing to anyone other ism is simply kufr

bhai jaan, go teach kufr to lal masjid and fsa and ikhwaan and qaeda first.

and I would recommend you consult any mufti

ghanta jaaonga main kisi mufti ke pass.

and revert to Islam

oh, man, i hate this word "revert"... you, sir, are a "naya musalmaan", a tableeghi type... i am a old-style comfortable muslim, the type which produced nasser and gaddafi and faiz, and the type which founded the "communist party of india" in 1921.

Does that change the story of my people?

story??

i am unable to decide why a lady, who has been shot by taliban for talking about progress, is being so hated in this thread by people who claim to support progress.

 

[Dubious]

General Practice is you dictate your Typist & then send to editor where he correct Grammatical & other errors, some time add some flavours if necessary (with permission) & then send to publication.

Yes that is...But I never support that....And nor should such a person be favoured!

Writing is a skill but in todays world every tom dick and harry is hiring someone to write their BS!

In Malala case , Malala tells the story to co author (named in the book) & she write it & correct & add flavours for worth reading.

And the flavour is wrong, misleading and really disgusting (against our country and religion)....She had a say in it but didnt....

Majority case publishers demand to add extra drama or other flavours which generate excitement for book, so they can sell large quantity of it.

And hence why I refuse to pay for such shit!

If sales is what she wanted then she also deserves to be responsible for the hatred thrown at her...With every action you need to be responsible not just get money then cry no one loves me ...I mean who wouldnt have wanted to read the original story?

i am unable to decide why a lady, who has been shot by taliban for talking about progress, is being so hated in this thread by people who claim to support progress.

its not her past....It is what she is doing now that is under question....Where are the schools she promised? Where is she spending her fund? Heck even her school teacher asked why she hasnt spent on her village as she promised when she received from 1 of the donors that she will 1st educate her village, fix the school and all sorts of stories for which she got more fund...

 

[Umair Nawaz]

@FaujHistorian read this thread, and try to remember what i told u before abt malala.

Its good to support someone, but one must not get close minded and get carried away by the flow of the situation, All Mighty has given us mind to analyse on our own.

 

[war&peace]

oh, man, i hate this word "revert"... you, sir, are a "naya musalmaan", a tableeghi type... i am a old-style comfortable muslim, the type which produced nasser and gaddafi, and the type which founded the "communist party of india" in 1921.

There are no types of Muslims or Islam, there are sects but no types and if you subscribe those "isms" then you simply commit kufr and you need to retake shahada and revert to Islam. You can consult any scholar, shia or sunni etc. In Islam we don't discriminate on the basis if you were a born Muslim or reverted later. Actually all the companions of Holy Prophet (Peace be upon him) were reverts (new Muslims) and they are the best Muslims and role models for us.

 

[jamahir]

There are no types of Muslims or Islam, there are sects but no types and if you subscribe those "isms" then you simply commit kufr and you need to retake shahada and revert to Islam. You can consult any scholar, shia or sunni etc.

@fakhre mirpur , we have a new maulvi saheb, a companion to luffy and co.

 

[livingdead]

So basically you are saying it is all drama.....that is what I have been saying that this is all fake and drama...nothing substantial in it.

she is not the only one who does it... thats the way such publishing works.. dont blame her.
biography generate public interest, if people already know you they will buy to know more.
Its not bought for literary merit, not going to get booker award or any other literature award.

do you think these men/women wrote books?

 

[Zarvan]

I am Not Malala, I am a Muslim, I am Pakistani is an account of Pakistanis who take pride in their country.

The All Pakistan Private Schools Federation (APPSF) launched a rebuttal to Malala Yousafzai’s novel ‘I am Malala’ by releasing a book titled ‘I am not Malala, I am a Muslim, I am a Pakistani’ at the National Press Club in Islamabad.

“The book is written with the aim to reveal the truth and counter anti-Islamic propaganda and expose the nefarious designs of anti-Islam forces,” said the author of the book, Mirza Kashif Ali, President All Pakistan Private Schools Federation (APPSF).

“I am Not Malala, I am a Muslim, I am Pakistani” was introduced in a ceremony chaired by Ali at National Press Club in Islamabad.

“I am Malala” describes Malala’s life under the Taliban’s brutal rule in the Swat valley in the mid-2000s and hints at her ambition to enter Pakistani politics.

Some private schools banned it from their premises last year due to what they called its “anti-Pakistan and anti-Islam content”.

APPSF which comprises of a total of 173,000 private schools termed the Nobel Peace Prize winner’s book ‘controversial’, banning it in all private schools and colleges as a result.

According to the organisation, the book contains offensive text regarding Islam, Quranic teachings, Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), Pakistan’s ideology, Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Pakistan Army, thus cannot be added in the curriculum.

Earlier in a statement, Adeeb Javadani, the central president of All Pakistan Private Schools Management Association (APPSMA) said that the book, the book was meant for the Western audience and did not receive much appreciation in Pakistan – a fact that had already decided its fate.

Further, APPSF announced its decision to take the matter to court on November 13, in order to ban the book across the country.

“Malala is a darling of the west and Shiv Sena, the same people who created al Qaeda and the Islamic State (IS), have created Malala,” Ali said.

The book, “I am not Malala”, aims to tell the readers that Malala, by comparing the Army with militants, the young literati is actually bashing the Army under the garb of female education.

Further, while the book praised Aitizaz Hasan, the young student who sacrificed his life to save his schoolmates by tackling a suicide bomber, it also questions her indifference towards Israeli aggression or the ongoing brutality in Gaza, which she did not mention in her book for while she spoke against the atrocities of Boko Haram in Nigeria, thus concluding that Malala is loyal to the Jews and the west.

“She has formed strong nexus with Salman Rushdie and Bangladeshi writer Tasleema Nasreen, and also believes in their ideology,” he alleged. “Malala says that she does not fear the Taliban any longer but will she return to Pakistan if she has no fears?” he questioned. “She will never do so because she will lose support of her masters and the easy money flowing in,” he further alleged.

The rebuttal of Malal’s book also portrays her father, Ziauddin Yousafzai as a ‘double agent’, electricity thief and a traitor based on his demand to hand over Shakil Afridi, the man who allegedly ran a fake vaccination campaign with CIA’s help to gather information in order to assist the US trace Osama bin Laden.

However, Ali stressed that the organisation went on a countrywide strike in order to show solidarity with Malala when she was attacked.

“We are not against her but the ideology being imposed on us by such traitors and billions of dollars of Malala Fund are being used for this to introduce secular curriculum.”

This article originally appeared on The Nation

I am not Malala: Teachers release novel against Nobel Peace winner - The Express Tribune

Malala and his father are nothing but western stooges. Real heroes are APS martyrs and Gazis who were attacked and killed still returned to same school and defied the Taliban. Malala book is co authored by famous enemy of Islam and Pakistan. @Akheilos

 

[Haroon Syed]

We really don't want your recognition. Keep it yourself and bugger off.

& Malala does not need any sort of recognition from you. Sitting in US and teaching patriotism lesson to others ? Even APS kids has been taken to UK for treatment. How did they survive ? Please keep your chutiya logic to yourself. Everyone is sell out and you are only patriotic here.

 

[jamahir]

its not her past....It is what she is doing now that is under question....Where are the schools she promised? Where is she spending her fund? Heck even her school teacher asked why she hasnt spent on her village as she promised when she received from 1 of the donors that she will 1st educate her village, fix the school and all sorts of stories for which she got more fund...

you are right to have those questions, but let us be practical for a moment and think of her safety... it is one thing for musharraf to return and live in a protected compound and another for malala to have the same level of security.

oh, she can provide any funds she has without returning, at least for some time, but we don't know how those funds are arranged... she obviously knows that she being at public forums and she having received the nobel, will be questioned by many pakistanis on her lack of visible work that she promised for pakistan, but does anyone really know of her compulsions??

okay, you being a pakistani student in usa may be member of a pakistani youth association there... you can communicate with a similar association in britain where malala lives... together, you should write to her and post the conversation on pdf... i think this is a reasonable and practical approach.

 

[yasir18]

Well, I'm an Indian but I respect Malala for her appreciable work for education of pakistani girls.
And those people, who are protesting her should be immediately jailed in any country.

You are not the only Indian who respect her. In fact many Indians respect her for the services she is providing to them (by praising traitors and maligning Pak Army).

 

[Cherokee]

expat Pakistanis are far more idiots than resident ones . Brought up on baby food of conspiracy supplements everything seems conspiracy to them . Shin Bet/FBI/KGB/RAW/annunakis/Martians/Red ones/Grey ones/Tall ones/Short ones etc etc etc are conspiring against Pakistan so that it does not become center of multiverse otherwise Pakistan is land of milk and honey and snow and bunnies and rainbows !! .

You are not the only Indian who respect her. In fact many Indians respect her for the services she is providing to them (by praising traitors and maligning Pak Army).

Welcome another mom's basement living tin foil wearing socio-economic expert to the thread !! .

 

[yasir18]

expat Pakistanis are far more idiots than resident ones . Brought up on baby food of conspiracy supplements everything seems conspiracy to them . Shin Bet/FBI/KGB/RAW/annunakis/Martians/Red ones/Grey ones/Tall ones/Short ones etc etc etc are conspiring against Pakistan so that it does not become center of multiverse otherwise Pakistan is land of milk and honey and snow and bunnies and rainbows !! .



Welcome another mom's basement living tin foil wearing socio-economic expert to the thread !! .

Looks like it hit you really hard. I wasn't expecting that.

 

[Cherokee]

Looks like it hit you really hard. I wasn't expecting that.

try better next time to get a response from me ,

 

[Guynextdoor2]

when groups indulge in such 'literature', it is usually called 'propaganda'.