What's new

Zarb-i-Azb alone won't save Pakistan

Men in Green

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 2, 2014
Messages
1,413
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
374d1c8971f0f612f836144a5b6e3d67.jpg


If maintaining ties with militants has brought us to this point, what would severing them do? How much worse could it get?

That's what I found myself asking, as body after body of the deceased arrived at various hospitals across Lahore last Sunday night; a mounting by the hour, a seemingly unending aftermath of the devastating attack near the Wagah border.

Like most Pakistanis across the country, conscious through paralysis, unwilling to see yet unable to move, with equal parts disbelief and anger, I sat in front of the TV, watching the utter chaos and carnage.

… 24 dead, they shouted! Then, 37.

… 42 … 55 … when would it stop?

60.

Family members, otherwise hurriedly walking around, could be seen cautiously slowing their pace on approaching a dead body; allowing the dread to fill up their hearts completely before lifting the white sheet; as if postponing the lifelong impact of their grief, for just one more moment.



Also read: Wagah: Dramatic turn of events changes a family’s fate



The Wagah border, among the dwindling recreational venues for Pakistanis, is a place where many flock to tend to a case of tapering patriotism.

Armed with flags and cheers for their country, all strata of our society unite here to pay homage to their own separate versions of an unyielding patriotism.

Sixty people enraptured by the intense Beating Retreat ceremony are now dead in the biggest attack yet by militants since the military operation, Zarb-i-Azb, was launched in North Waziristan five months ago.



Also read: An attack that was waiting to happen



Sixty people with an all new surge of pride and commitment for their country, walked out of the parade avenue and right into the mouth of the blast.

It is especially painful to realise how swiftly the shouts of ‘Pakistan Zindabad’, the sounds of foot stamps, high kicks and marching soldiers morphed into the wailing of ambulance sirens, the sobs of a husband and the cries of a mother – a time of elation marred by terror; a sight all too familiar.

Despite this, Pakistan’s descent into darkness furthered as it typically does: when TV channels aired self-congratulatory messages for reporting the tragedy first; when multiple militant outfits clamoured to take responsibility; when our leaders made empty condemnations, just like all the other attacks.

In this state of complete ferment, do we dare ask:

Which attack on our people is going to be the one that determines the cost of our outlook on militancy?

The Wagah attack has highlighted the state's incapacity to rid Pakistan of this seemingly incurable disease.

The sheer scale and the apparent ease with which the attack was carried out leaves many of us pondering about the breach at the site of the attack.

News reports point to a denser police presence elsewhere in the city due to Muharram processions that could have made Wagah a relatively ‘easier’ target.

But since the GHQ attack in 2009 (and subsequent military base attacks), should we really wonder if there are any ‘difficult’ targets left in Pakistan anymore?



Editorial: Militancy: is the state prepared?



It appears then that we have also been wrongfully addressing the question of whether or not we were ready for a fallout of Zarb-i-Azb.

Instead, we should have been addressing the critical question of whether or not Zarb-i-Azb would work without a coherent anti-militancy narrative.

Until there is an unambiguous state narrative on militancy – right up until that day, you, me, all of us...

We’re fair game.

Zarb-i-Azb alone won't save Pakistan - Blogs - DAWN.COM
 
.
I agree with you.

This needs a political process too. But our insincere rulers have given that option up and now thinking army will do the job while they will set up their businesses in London or Dubai.
 
.
this wont stop until you hang the arrested terrorists. . . and also throw out Afghans , Tajik and Uzbik out of Pakistan ... and if any tribal peoples have sympathy for them .. they should also get lost from Pakistan
 
.
this wont stop until you hang the arrested terrorists. . . and also throw out Afghans , Tajik and Uzbik out of Pakistan ... and if any tribal peoples have sympathy for them .. they should also get lost from Pakistan

+1

If tribal terrorism doesn't end in 3 years, qabaylis should be told to get lost and offered a dignified exit from Karachi and other economic centers. In their own independent state, they can make love to Taliban all they want.
 
.
+1

If tribal terrorism doesn't end in 3 years, qabaylis should be told to get lost and offered a dignified exit from Karachi and other economic centers. In their own independent state, they can make love to Taliban all they want.

tribal peoples are so much bound to stone age .. their tribal culture is one fcuked up culture which damage Pakistan society ..they are one's who bring Ak culture , Smuggling , no go areas , and also give safe heaven to all terrorist , just because they have same language or same culture ...
even in Karachi visit Safora goth and banaras and than visit Gulshan and nazimabad , you get the difference , their life style is no less than animals, they have no concern with education , cleaning , and law and order ...
 
.
this wont stop until you hang the arrested terrorists. . . and also throw out Afghans , Tajik and Uzbik out of Pakistan ... and if any tribal peoples have sympathy for them .. they should also get lost from Pakistan
how hanging a person willing to die with a suicide vest will ever help? try to change their ideology.
 
.
tribal peoples are so much bound to stone age .. their tribal culture is one fcuked up culture which damage Pakistan society ..they are one's who bring Ak culture , Smuggling , no go areas , and also give safe heaven to all terrorist , just because they have same language or same culture ...
even in Karachi visit Safora goth and banaras and than visit Gulshan and nazimabad , you get the difference , their life style is no less than animals, they have no concern with education , cleaning , and law and order ...

In Islamabad, visit Tarnol. It's like touring a safari park. Pure untermenschen people. Incapable of forming a state or being normal humans in the 21st century. They sell their sons as suicide bombers from 5 to 13 lakhs.
 
.
In Islamabad, visit Tarnol. It's like touring a safari park. Pure untermenschen people. Incapable of forming a state or being normal humans in the 21st century. They sell their sons as suicide bombers from 5 to 13 lakhs.

i never been to Islamabad , but what these tribal people has done to Karachi is enough to make a impression on me
 
.
how hanging a person willing to die with a suicide vest will ever help? try to change their ideology.

When the state shows great determination and never ending desire to keep following the due process and punish those who oppose it with force effectvely, that WILL demoralise the terrorists over a period. Quick fixes only shows the weakness of the state.

Public prosecution and punishment as per law is a the most effective declaration of the writ of the state.
 
.
In Islamabad, visit Tarnol. It's like touring a safari park. Pure untermenschen people. Incapable of forming a state or being normal humans in the 21st century. They sell their sons as suicide bombers from 5 to 13 lakhs.
offering a son for religious cause or jihad is acceptable. but selling a son for money????
 
.
tribal peoples are so much bound to stone age .. their tribal culture is one fcuked up culture which damage Pakistan society ..they are one's who bring Ak culture , Smuggling , no go areas , and also give safe heaven to all terrorist , just because they have same language or same culture ...
even in Karachi visit Safora goth and banaras and than visit Gulshan and nazimabad , you get the difference , their life style is no less than animals, they have no concern with education , cleaning , and law and order ...

Leaders failed to educate and invest in them. They have given up so much for Pakistan - Instead of giving them something in return, leaders of Pakistan have only used them. Not only them baloch too and list goes on. By Leaders I mean Army men - because they have been in power since 1947, indirectly or directly.

They have miserably failed in what they are paid to do on many occasions – & that is to protect the people of Pakistan.

How to fix this – can work on long term and short terms goals. Firstly hang some incompetent/corrupt/Powerful men in the army – following that with some Politician’s (can include their entire family) will be lesson for others.

Next get some correct leadership in the Army and Parliament – Following by less corruption – building institutions, judiciary etc (Get some competent people) – education – etc. All this will have positive effect on this and I am sure there are other things but you get the vibe.
 
.
When the state shows great determination and never ending desire to keep following the due process and punish those who oppose it with force effectvely, that WILL demoralise the terrorists over a period. Quick fixes only shows the weakness of the state.

Public prosecution and punishment as per law is a the most effective declaration of the writ of the state.
in a corrupt nations all you will see is tariq pe tariq.
 
. .
Leaders failed to educate and invest in them. They have given up so much for Pakistan - Instead of giving them something in return, leaders of Pakistan have only used them. Not only them baloch too and list goes on. By Leaders I mean Army men - because they have been in power since 1947, indirectly or directly.

They have miserably failed in what they are paid to do on many occasions – & that is to protect the people of Pakistan.

How to fix this – can work on long term and short terms u goals. Firstly hang some incompetent/corrupt/Powerful men in the army – following that with some Politician’s (can include their entire family) will be lesson for others.

Next get some correct leadership in the Army and Parliament – Following by less corruption – building institutions, judiciary etc (Get some competent people) – education – etc. All this will have positive effect on this and I am sure there are other things but you get the vibe.

its not about giving them anything .. you make school in Fata they will destroy them within a month , you make parks there they are going to Fcuk them ... you make hospitals there they are going to make it dirty as hell ... same goes with balouch .. that is why i am against tribal culture that tribal culture is all about forcing peoples to live like animals .. no education for low peoples , and tribal leaders are man made gods ,what ever they judge is equal to judgement of God .. you invest millions of $$$ in fata today and within few years you will your investment in vein .
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom