Yakub Memon's hanging

[doppelganger]

Indian Muslims cannot live with Indian Hindus = Pakistan

West Pakistani Muslims cannot live with East Pakistani Muslims = Bangladesh

Pakistani Punjabi Muslims cannot live with Pakistani Muhajir Muslims and Sindhi Muslims = ?

Pakistani Punjabi and Sindhi Muslims cannot live with Pakistani Baloch Muslims = ?

Pakistani Punjabi and Sindhi Muslims cannot live with Pakistani Pashtun Muslims = ?

Pakistani Indic Muslims cannot live with Pakistani Iranic Muslims = ?

All Pakistani Muslims cannot live with Pakistani Ahmediyas, Chrisitans, Hindus, and Sikhs = ?

I feel Jinnah died too early to be honest, may God rest his soul. His hypothesis was not tested to logical conclusion.

 

[Burhan Wani]

But I think Jinnah forgot to mention a basic question...."Pakistan was created for whom"??Shia??Sunni??Ahmedi.....I mean,one can surely see that Pakistan is not for "Muslims"..Its for a particular group.

Pakistan was created for Muslims of sub continent. The freedom struggle consists of all muslim sects not for specific.

 

[Agent Smith]

They hang the person who financially support in the killing of 250+ peoples. But never hang any of the extremist involved in the riots of 1992 and 2002.

what proof do you have of their 'involvement'? our SC has acquitted him of all charges, unlike pakistan in India judiciary id the most powerful and respectable institution. even governments are afraid of it.

 

[jaunty]

The entire Pakistanis nation atleast 99.99% say that Jinnah did the right thing..So you are trying to say that the entire nation is a terrorist?

You need to improve your comprehension skills.

 

[SP!TF!R3]

Pakistan was created for Muslims of sub continent. The freedom struggle consists of all muslim sects not for specific.

But surely..you'd agree..Not only most Muslims in sub continent lives outside Pakistan,The one lives in Pakistan,some of them wants to get out,as THAT NATION surely doesn't want them..Its just like Nigro Issues in USA before 1962-1963..They had voting rights on paper,but had no means to vote,which lead to host of problem..same goes for these sects as well.Pakistan was "On Paper" created for "Muslims",but here,in this very forum,People really wants to "Kill" some sects..And in real,They're getting "Slaughtered" by the same fellow "Muslims"..

 

[doppelganger]

Postscript to my post above that seeks to test Jinnah's hypothesis (I wonder how I forgot it, though to be honest and fair, when there are so many bigger challenges, one tends to miss some, important as they may be):

Pakistani Sunni Muslims (80%) cannot live with Pakistani Shia Muslims (20%) = ?

 

[HariPrasad]

Yakub Memon is right person

naturally who soever (Muslim in particular) Kill Hindu is always a right person. He killed Kufrs as the directive of the Allah so naturally he is a right and a great person. You can take inspiration from him and register yourself as a suicide Bomber so that you can also do some great work of eliminating some kufra in your life and follow the footstep of your role model yakub.

 

[Burhan Wani]

But surely..you'd agree..Not only most Muslims in sub continent lives outside Pakistan,The one lives in Pakistan,some of them wants to get out,as THAT NATION surely doesn't want them..Its just like Nigro Issues in USA before 1962-1963..They had voting rights on paper,but had no means to vote,which lead to host of problem..same goes for these sects as well.Pakistan was "On Paper" created for "Muslims",but here,in this very forum,People really wants to "Kill" some sects..And in real,They're getting "Slaughtered" by the same fellow "Muslims"..

Actually there are some anti Pakistani elements try to portrait Pakistan a country with sectarian violence.
Ground realities are very different our people lives with muslim brotherhood not based on sects.

Postscript to my post above that seeks to test Jinnah's hypothesis (I wonder how I forgot it, though to be honest and fair, when there are so many bigger challenges, one tends to miss some, important as they may be):

Pakistani Sunni Muslims (80%) cannot live with Pakistani Shia Muslims (20%) = ?

There is no such division.
Both shia and sunni muslims love each other from sore of their heart.
Yes we have some ties but it is our internal matter.
You have to focus in your so called democracy, where mass murderers promoted to high ranks and innocent lives in misery and hanged to death.

 

[JOEY TRIBIANI]

I hope you do understand the difference between terrorist attack and communial violence. The convicts of 2002 riots are getting punished as per law.

Communal violence . wahh . thats what u use as a shield . do you know how many Muslims died in 2002 riots ?

 

[JOEY TRIBIANI]

what proof do you have of their 'involvement'? our SC has acquitted him of all charges, unlike pakistan in India judiciary id the most powerful and respectable institution. even governments are afraid of it.

Dnt you know about a video in which he him self admitted ?

 

[qamar1990]

Jinnah saved India and we would like to thank him for that.

yes he saved india by cutting in half and making his own country...

 

[SarthakGanguly]

yes he saved india by cutting in half and making his own country...

Seriously he saved Indians. Or what remained of it. The cowards would have been butchered en masse by now otherwise.

 

[qamar1990]

Seriously he saved Indians. Or what remained of it. The cowards would have been butchered en masse by now otherwise.

yeah, if india n pakistan was one, most likely muslims would be running everything.

 

[doppelganger]

There is no such division.
Both shia and sunni muslims love each other from sore of their heart.

Yes I agree wholeheartedly.

If I was a Shia Muslim, my heart would be sore too hearing about my imambaras bombed during prayer and my pilgrim buses stopped, people taken out and lined, and then shot in cold blood.

Not once but again and again, systematically.

Would make no difference or offer no solace to my sore heart that we Shias have done so much for the nation or that some of us have risen to high ranks in the army and the civilian society.

Fact is we are just another minority in Pakistan, probably considered one step above the Ahmediyas/Qadiyanis in terms of the "true" Muslim pecking order, and there is a systematic genocide happening against us.

 

[Bhasad Singh Mundi]

yeah, if india n pakistan was one, most likely muslims would be running everything.

like the way they are running things in pakistan