What's new

Woman confesses to killing 16-year-old sister in Karachi over 'compromising pictures

Ocean

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 30, 2016
Messages
2,487
Reaction score
-1
Country
Argentina
Location
Pakistan
Woman confesses to killing 16-year-old sister in Karachi over 'compromising pictures

Woman confesses to killing 16-year-old sister in Karachi over 'compromising pictures'
Dawn.com | Imtiaz AliUpdated December 10, 2017
278

6
5a2d0c0a18ff7.png

SSP Korangi Nauman Siddiqui addresses a press conference in Karachi.─DawnNews

Police on Sunday confirmed that an alleged incident of robbery reported in Karachi's Malir area earlier this week was actually an act of murder where a 20-year-old young woman killed her younger sister, Aleena, with the help of her fiance.

On December 6, it was reported that a 16-year-old girl was stabbed to death and her sister, Alveena, was wounded when they allegedly resisted a robbery attempt in their home.

However, addressing a press conference on Sunday, Senior Superintendent Police (SSP) Korangi Nauman Siddiqui said that Alveena had confessed to slitting the throat of her little sister after allegedly being blackmailed by Aleena and her friends for several days.

"It is an unfortunate incident," the SSP said as he opened his press conference in which he detailed the events that led to the teenage girl's murder.

According to the SSP, the deceased teenage girl and her friend, Ahsan, had been blackmailing Alveena with compromising photographs.

The SSP said that Alveena and her fiance of one and a half years, Mazhar, had at first considered killing Ahsan but decided against it.

They had then approached Kashif, another suspect who was questioned by police, for help in killing the younger sister but he had refused.

Kashif confessed to being approached by Alveena and Mazhar for the murder, the SSP said.

After he refused, the two then took it upon themselves to carry out the crime.

Siddiqui said that on December 5, Mazhar and Alveena had tried one last time to convince the 16-year-old to tell Ahsan to delete the pictures. When she refused, Mazhar held her down and Alveena slit her throat with a knife, the official said.

"She (Alveena) has confessed to it," Siddiqui said.

He said that after the murder, the accused had attempted to destroy the evidence, including mobile phones.

According to the SSP, the police had been suspicious of Alveena's involvement in the murder from the beginning but refrained from arresting her to first recover the evidence.

The police recovered six mobile phones, Rs76,000 in cash and a knife ─ the murder weapon ─ from Mazhar's house.

"Whatever the motive, they have carried out a brutal act of murder," Siddiqui said.

Responding to a question by a journalist, Siddiqui said that action should be carried out against Ahsan as well for blackmailing Alveena. The SSP was critical of the "negative use of mobile phones" and urged parents to be careful in providing the devices to their children.

The SSP credited the station house officer of Saudabad, the district superintendent police and superintendent police for solving the murder.

Alveena's confession
Addressing the press after SSP Nauman, Alveena confessed that she had killed her sister.

"She (Aleena) was torturing me mentally," the accused said. "They were threatening to upload the video on social media."

Alveena claimed that she had begged the blackmailers repeatedly to delete a compromising video of her but Aleena and her friend Ahsan had refused.

"Ahsan should not be released. He made me kill my sister," Alveena said. "I had no choice. Ahsan should be given the strictest punishment."

"He made my sister make the video of me and then used it to blackmail me."

 
. .
What a loving Family... Family reunion...will be quite...interesting...
"Where is your sister?"
"Mhh...Mhh...Mhhh..."

Sister recorded personal vidoe of elder sister and then was asked by her bf to use same video to threaten her sister. I dont feel much sympathies with the girl who got murdered.
Well... So will you do the same for your sister/brother if she/he had a "special" vid of you...?
 
.
What a loving Family... Family reunion...will be quite...interesting...
"Where is your sister?"
"Mhh...Mhh...Mhhh..."


Well... So will you do the same for your sister/brother if she/he had a "special" vid of you...?
i could barely kill a cockroach

What a loving Family... Family reunion...will be quite...interesting...
"Where is your sister?"
"Mhh...Mhh...Mhhh..."


Well... So will you do the same for your sister/brother if she/he had a "special" vid of you...?
But isaid dont feel sympathy cause its brutal u record ur own sisters video using mobile and then share with ur bf and that bf and that sister then threaten elder sister they would leak her video online. I mean how much devoid of humanity was her younger sister. Not justifying murder but noone goes to such extremes of killing a sibling unless they are too desperate.

The woman might have felt desperate about her person getting exposed to public and went to such extreme, but if there is still more to the story then idont know
 
. . .
Sister recorded personal vidoe of elder sister and then was asked by her bf to use same video to threaten her sister. I dont feel much sympathies with the girl who got murdered.
Sister blackmailing sister is very strange to me. I dont think this killing is justified by any means. Killers always defend their killing with excuses and justifications but i guess there is much more in this story if we hear the point of views from boht side but sadly one has been killed brutally so she cannot present her views
 
.
One sided version, don't conclude anything from it.
Yes i mentioned in my prev post if there is more to the story then we dont know

Sister blackmailing sister is very strange to me. I dont think this killing is justified by any means. Killers always defend their killing with excuses and justifications but i guess there is much more in this story if we hear the point of views from boht side but sadly one has been killed brutally so she cannot present her views
Yes killing is not justified, thats undebatable totally. But i was just surprised at the personal vidoe recodring.

From the news it could be said that only four people could tell the reason behind murdered sisters motive of blackmailing, the murdered girl herself, the murderer, the fiance of elder sister and the guy Ahsan who was using younger sister to blackmail elder sister. What was the connection between ahsan and elder sister who committed murder is not disclosed and also why he got her younger sister to blackmail her and what did they want in return.

I think the younger sister did blackmail her though cause the ssp said parents shud keep check on kids on how they sue their mobiles. But they did not share why ahsan was after elder sister
 
.
Woman confesses to killing 16-year-old sister in Karachi over 'compromising pictures

Woman confesses to killing 16-year-old sister in Karachi over 'compromising pictures'
Dawn.com | Imtiaz AliUpdated December 10, 2017
278

6
5a2d0c0a18ff7.png

SSP Korangi Nauman Siddiqui addresses a press conference in Karachi.─DawnNews

Police on Sunday confirmed that an alleged incident of robbery reported in Karachi's Malir area earlier this week was actually an act of murder where a 20-year-old young woman killed her younger sister, Aleena, with the help of her fiance.

On December 6, it was reported that a 16-year-old girl was stabbed to death and her sister, Alveena, was wounded when they allegedly resisted a robbery attempt in their home.

However, addressing a press conference on Sunday, Senior Superintendent Police (SSP) Korangi Nauman Siddiqui said that Alveena had confessed to slitting the throat of her little sister after allegedly being blackmailed by Aleena and her friends for several days.

"It is an unfortunate incident," the SSP said as he opened his press conference in which he detailed the events that led to the teenage girl's murder.

According to the SSP, the deceased teenage girl and her friend, Ahsan, had been blackmailing Alveena with compromising photographs.

The SSP said that Alveena and her fiance of one and a half years, Mazhar, had at first considered killing Ahsan but decided against it.

They had then approached Kashif, another suspect who was questioned by police, for help in killing the younger sister but he had refused.

Kashif confessed to being approached by Alveena and Mazhar for the murder, the SSP said.

After he refused, the two then took it upon themselves to carry out the crime.

Siddiqui said that on December 5, Mazhar and Alveena had tried one last time to convince the 16-year-old to tell Ahsan to delete the pictures. When she refused, Mazhar held her down and Alveena slit her throat with a knife, the official said.

"She (Alveena) has confessed to it," Siddiqui said.

He said that after the murder, the accused had attempted to destroy the evidence, including mobile phones.

According to the SSP, the police had been suspicious of Alveena's involvement in the murder from the beginning but refrained from arresting her to first recover the evidence.

The police recovered six mobile phones, Rs76,000 in cash and a knife ─ the murder weapon ─ from Mazhar's house.

"Whatever the motive, they have carried out a brutal act of murder," Siddiqui said.

Responding to a question by a journalist, Siddiqui said that action should be carried out against Ahsan as well for blackmailing Alveena. The SSP was critical of the "negative use of mobile phones" and urged parents to be careful in providing the devices to their children.

The SSP credited the station house officer of Saudabad, the district superintendent police and superintendent police for solving the murder.

Alveena's confession
Addressing the press after SSP Nauman, Alveena confessed that she had killed her sister.

"She (Aleena) was torturing me mentally," the accused said. "They were threatening to upload the video on social media."

Alveena claimed that she had begged the blackmailers repeatedly to delete a compromising video of her but Aleena and her friend Ahsan had refused.

"Ahsan should not be released. He made me kill my sister," Alveena said. "I had no choice. Ahsan should be given the strictest punishment."

"He made my sister make the video of me and then used it to blackmail me."
another version of same story
KARACHI: The Saudabad murder case took a chilling turn as the murdered victim's sister, Alveena, appeared on media to confess that she and her fiance killed the 18-year-old Alina. According to her, she killed Alina because she would abet two men who would rape, film and blackmail her.

"I met them thrice at our house and they made love to me, sexually assaulting me in every way possible," she said. "They did the same with my sister but with her consent. With me, they did it by force."

On December 5, Alina had been killed in her house in Saudabad. Two suspects committed the crime and took away cash and gold from the house. According to the police, Alveena killed her 18-year-old sister with the help of her fiance, Mazhar. She let him inside the house through the back door and killed Alina by slitting her throat. Then, in an attempt to make the incident look like a robbery, she made Mazhar run away with the cash and gold.

On Sunday, Korangi SSP Nauman Siddiqi revealed during a press conference that Alina had actually been killed by her sister, Alveena. According to him, the police were suspicious of Alveena since day one. He said that Rs80,000 and six mobile phones were recovered from the possession of Alveena and Mazhar, both of whom were now in police custody. After his press briefing, he allowed Alveena, Mazhar and Ahsan, who is one of the men Alveena says blackmailed her, to address the media.

Speaking to the media, Alveena shared how two men, Ahsan and Abbas, would blackmail her while her murdered sister would assist them. According to her, the two men are brothers and were their neighbors when they lived in Shadman before shifting to Saudabad.

Alveena said that the men raped and filmed her and then blackmailed her. "Ahsan made an inappropriate video of me," she said. "Alina had it and I had asked her to delete it. I told my fiance about everything and he also tried to convince Alina to delete the videos but to no avail. She would blackmail me in connivance with Ahsan and Abbas. I even begged her but she didn't listen. I killed her for not stopping with the blackmailing. I decided to take away the cash and phone so that murder suspicion doesn't arise."

According to Alveena, Alina wanted her to befriend Abbas and the blackmailing had been going on for months. "They used to say that they have inappropriate videos and pictures of me. Every other day, they would blackmail me over the pictures and call me for further meetings."

Alveena said that each time she asked Alina to delete the videos, she would tell Ahsan and Abbas. "They used to say that to get the material deleted, I would have to meet them," she said. "Upon meeting, they would subject me to sexual assault in the presence of my sister and would take more pictures and videos. My sister would assist them."

One day, Alveena said, I again asked them to delete the videos. "They asked me to come to Aga Khan University Hospital," she said. "I even begged Ahsan, Abbas and Alina at their feet but they continued with the blackmail."

When asked how they got in touch with Ahsan and Abbas, Alveena said that they were her neighbors when the family lived in Shadman before shifting to Saudabad. "Before getting involved with them, Alina used to speak to another man on the phone," she said. "I used to consider Ahsan and Abbas my brothers and asked them to convince Alina to stop talking to that man. When I used to stop her, she used to fight with me."

She said that she first thought of committing suicide but couldn't muster the courage. "I was tired of the blackmailing and had become a mental patient," she said. "When I used to tell our parents, they would beat me up and my sister would tell Ahsan, after which he would threaten me. He used to say that no one can hold me accountable as I have contacts in the police and SIU. I would again get silenced and suffer the blackmailing. What else could I do?"

According to her, Ahsan and Abbas would tell her that they would show her videos to her fiance, which would make him call off the engagement. "They further said they'll show the videos to my father and he would throw me out of the house," she said.

Fiance breaks into tears

Addressing the media after Alveena, Mazhar broke into tears. All he could say was that Alveena was tortured and that Ahsan and Abbas had her inappropriate videos and pictures. "We were under pressure and were scared," he said.

Ahsan blames Alveena

Meanwhile, Ahsan pinned all the blame on Alveena. Speaking to the media after Mazhar, he said that Alveena was pursuing him and used to meet him out of her own will. "When I refused to meet her, she would threaten me that she'd kill herself and I'd be blamed for her death. If you check her arms, you'd find marks of cuts that she used to inflict on herself just to meet me.

https://www.samaa.tv/pakistan/2017/12/saudabad-murder-case-raped-filmed/
 
.
Yes i mentioned in my prev post if there is more to the story then we dont know


Yes killing is not justified, thats undebatable totally. But i was just surprised at the personal vidoe recodring.

From the news it could be said that only four people could tell the reason behind murdered sisters motive of blackmailing, the murdered girl herself, the murderer, the fiance of elder sister and the guy Ahsan who was using younger sister to blackmail elder sister. What was the connection between ahsan and elder sister who committed murder is not disclosed and also why he got her younger sister to blackmail her and what did they want in return.

I think the younger sister did blackmail her though cause the ssp said parents shud keep check on kids on how they sue their mobiles. But they did not share why ahsan was after elder sister

Elder sister should have involve her parent or police instead of going for butchering her younger sister.
 
. .
@Maarkhoor @Proudpakistaniguy just read the link shared by jon snow.

Man thats gut wrenchingly sick looks like whole household was crazy , alveens says when she told parents they would beat her up. I dont know but ahsans accusation does not sound very convincing , if alveena wanted him n killed alina for ahsan, then she would have killed her sister alone , why would her her fiance be involved in the mess.

If this version is true then alveena should not be punished for long and severely
 
. . .
Elder sister should have involve her parent or police instead of going for butchering her younger sister.
Just see the link shared by jon snow she said she used to tell them but thye would beat her up, they were form lower middle background too, her father is a street vendor and mom works in industrial sector so these people may not be educated and did not pay heed to childrens problems

This is sick to the core , where is our society heading
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom