What's new

Why Japan is critical of China's activities in East China Sea?

TaiShang

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
27,848
Reaction score
70
Country
China
Location
Taiwan, Province Of China
Japan demands China halt oil exploration in part of East China Sea

By Tim KellyJuly 21, 2015 12:27


TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan called on China on Tuesday to halt construction of oil-and-gas exploration platforms in the East China Sea close to waters claimed by both nations, concerned that Chinese drills could tap reservoirs that extend into Japanese territory.

Japan's Defense Ministry added the demand to its annual defense review after hawkish members of the ruling party complained that its original draft was too soft on China, a ministry official said.

China resumed exploration in the East China Sea two years ago, the report said. In 2012, Japan's government had angered Beijing and purchased a disputed island chain there. Before then, Beijing had curtailed activities under an agreement with Japan to jointly develop undersea resources in disputed areas.

"We have confirmed that China has started construction of new ocean (exploration) platforms and we repeat our opposition to unilateral development by China and call for a halt," the ministry said.

The platforms are being erected on the Chinese side of a median line delineating the exclusive economic zones of the two countries, the Japanese ministry official said.

Tokyo worries that the platforms will tap into gas fields that overlap the median line and could also be used as radar stations or bases for drones or other aircraft to monitor air and sea activity near the disputed chain of islets, known as the Senkaku in Japan and Diaoyu in China.

China's defense and foreign ministries did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the Japanese report.

The report didn't disclose details of the location or number of offshore platforms being erected by China.

The 500-page report, approved by Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's government, also commented on the disputed South China Sea where Japan and other countries have criticized Chinese land reclamation projects as a threat to regional security.

For the first time, the report included satellite images of Chinese man-made islands in the South China Sea.

"China has rapidly moved ahead with land reclamation on seven reefs in the Spratly Islands and on some is building infrastructure including runways and harbors. Beginning with the U.S., this is a concern for the international community," it said.

China claims most of the 3.5 million sq km (1.35 million sq mile) South China Sea, with the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan also staking claims.

Japan has no claims in the area but fears Chinese military bases there would bolster Beijing's influence over a region through which $5 trillion in trade passes every year, much of it to and from Japan.

China has said its construction work in the South China Sea would be used for defense as well as to provide civilian services that would benefit other countries.

Japan and the Philippines have conducted two joint naval exercises in and around the South China Sea. In June, Abe and Philippine President Benigno Aquino said they would begin talks that could give Japan access to Philippine bases.

Japan has also said it may begin air patrols in the South China Sea. China said it would see that as interference.
 
.
11_03_032_R_%E8%87%AA%E8%A1%9B%E9%9A%8A%E8%A8%98%E5%BF%B5%E6%97%A5_%E8%A6%B3%E9%96%B2%E5%BC%8F%28Parade_of_Self-Defense_Force%29_72.jpg
 
. .
Then I'm sure there will be no disagreement when Japan starts to develop Chunxiao. :)
 
. .
Then I'm sure there will be no disagreement when Japan starts to develop Chunxiao. :)

Then you will have to try and see it for yourselves, my friend. I, for once, am not sure in what way China would react. Maybe it would just agree with it but maybe it would not.
 
.
Then I'm sure there will be no disagreement when Japan starts to develop Chunxiao. :)

I have read somewhere that Japan is slow on east china sea gas field because it is rather uneconomical for Japan. There are far too little resource, and the pipe line will have to travel far to reach Japan.

Japan actually wanted China to just share some profit, but China doesn't really see a need to comply.
 
.
As per the 2008 Agreement, Japan has shown Beijing that it is open to joint development of Chunxiao. However, these recent political lambasting by Chinese Foreign Affairs Spokeswoman does not do anything to facilitate or encourage joint development, rather, soure tensions. I don't understand why the Chinese foreign ministry is so sharp in its criticisms with Japan.

I have read somewhere that Japan is slow on east china sea gas field because it is rather uneconomical for Japan. There are far too little resource, and the pipe line will have to travel far to reach Japan.

Japan actually wanted China to just share some profit, but China doesn't really see a need to comply.

No. Both sides had agreed to joint development as per the 2008 Agreement. The mechanisms of joint development is there, the Japanese side still extends an olive branch to our partners in Beijing, but what leads us to suspect -- is the recent sharp criticisms of a certain Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman. It behooves us to see such unecessary criticisms when Japan has not touched the issue of the East China Sea situation in almost a year.
 
.
As per the 2008 Agreement, Japan has shown Beijing that it is open to joint development of Chunxiao. However, these recent political lambasting by Chinese Foreign Affairs Spokeswoman does not do anything to facilitate or encourage joint development, rather, soure tensions. I don't understand why the Chinese foreign ministry is so sharp in its criticisms with Japan.


No. Both sides had agreed to joint development as per the 2008 Agreement. The mechanisms of joint development is there, the Japanese side still extends an olive branch to our partners in Beijing, but what leads us to suspect -- is the recent sharp criticisms of a certain Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman. It behooves us to see such unecessary criticisms when Japan has not touched the issue of the East China Sea situation in almost a year.

It is not lambasting. In diplomacy terms, it is disagreement and dispute.

And it is not criticism of a certain spokesperson. It is the country's position.

And Japan has been stirring the waters in SCS for more than a year.
 
.
It is not lambasting. In diplomacy terms, it is disagreement and dispute.

And it is not criticism of a certain spokesperson. It is the country's position.

And Japan has been stirring the waters in SCS for more than a year.

Taishang, the Japanese joint naval exercise with the Philippines took place in Palawan waters, and did not go into disputed waters. Therein lies the clear difference. I can understand if the Chinese side's righteous indignation if Japan and her military branches went inside disputed territory, but that was not the case.
 
.
Nobody in the international arena is going to cry for you because the Chunxiao gas field falls within our EEZ. Your biggest argument is some assumption that the gas field might drain oil over on your side but that had not being proved.

4221.gif
 
.
Here's a more accurate depiction, actually. The one you posted looks like it was painted by an aesthetically disinclined individual using Microsoft Office, lol.

123031_c2cad751353d48949335.jpg
 
.
Taishang, the Japanese joint naval exercise with the Philippines took place in Palawan waters, and did not go into disputed waters. Therein lies the clear difference. I can understand if the Chinese side's righteous indignation if Japan and her military branches went inside disputed territory, but that was not the case.

Japan flew surveillance plane near the disputed waters. To me that is open provocation. Japan can simply stay neutral.

Here's a more accurate depiction, actually. The one you posted looks like it was painted by an aesthetically disinclined individual using Microsoft Office, lol.

123031_c2cad751353d48949335.jpg

In any case, it is within China's claimed EEZ.
 
.
Japan flew surveillance plane near the disputed waters. To me that is open provocation. Japan can simply stay neutral.



In any case, it is within China's claimed EEZ.

As it is in Japan's claimed EEZ.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom