What's new

Why is Pakistan spending so much money on defence amid COVID-19?

Joined
Jul 10, 2018
Messages
2,231
Reaction score
-41
Country
Nepal
Location
Nepal
497cd339eb984bed9c6298e492406fa4_18.jpg
Prime Minister Imran Khan's government allocated $7.85bn for defence and merely $151m for health in the budget for the financial year 2020-2021 [AP/BK Bangash]

The Pakistani government does not seem willing to shift its spending priorities despite the burgeoning COVID-19 challenges.

Pakistan has emerged as one of the countries with the fastest rate of coronavirus infections in recent weeks, according to the World Health Organization (WHO). The country reported its first coronavirus case on February 26 and is now among the top 15 most-affected countries. More than 4,000 people have lost their lives to the disease in Pakistan since the beginning of the outbreak. Moreover, there is a significant shortage of personal protective equipment (PPE) and ventilators in the country.

Despite all this, Islamabad allocated $7.85bn for defence and merely $151m for health in the budget for the financial year 2020-2021. This represents a 12 percent rise in Pakistan's defence spending compared with the last financial year. The single-line figure presented in the budget does not give a full picture of the amount actually being spent on defence either.

To avoid hard questions from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Pakistan refuses to be fully transparent about its military spending. Major acquisitions by the armed forces, spending on the public sector development programme (PSDP), expenditure on the nuclear programme and para-military forces, payments for military pensions, a newly set-up national security division and a few other military expenditures are not reflected in the budget. If these were to be added to it, Pakistan's defence spending would be even higher - at around $11bn.
The increase in defence spending comes at a time when Pakistan is forced to allocate 41 percent of its expenditure to debt servicing. The economy was underperforming even before the onset of COVID-19, surviving on an IMF loan package of $6bn. The gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate had plummeted from 5.5 percent in the 2017-2018 financial year to 2.4 percent in 2020-2021. Following the coronavirus outbreak, it decreased further to -1.5 percent. This marked the first time in Pakistan's history that a negative growth rate was recorded.

Before the pandemic, Pakistan was already burdened by an external debt of about $112bn. Today it is facing the additional challenge of feeding some 25 million poor families that can no longer make a living due to COVID-19. Moreover, the country saw a 30 percent reduction in tax revenue, due to the government's incompetence and decreased spending caused by the coronavirus lockdown. This led to a reduction in overall health spending, as the provincial governments received a less funds from the federal government.
It is, for instance, impossible for the parliamentarians to ask the army to make do with the domestically produced main battle tank al-Khaled, rather than buying new Chinese tanks. Despite paying more than $2bn in military pensions every year (a major expenditure that is not included in the defence budget), the government is not allowed to question what the military does with the revenues from its $20bn private business empire either.

The military business also gets approximately $90.9m annually in tax exemptions from the state. Furthermore, the armed forces, unlike civilian departments, have the authority to move funds from one head of account to another. This means that it never has to surrender resources back to the state at the end of a financial year.

Despite the continuing dispute with India over Kashmir, a war between the two neighbours does not seem likely. Pakistan's nuclear programme provides the necessary deterrence to prevent a ground war. This means there is no need for an increase in defence spending, especially at a time when the country is facing an unprecedented crisis and India's attention is sufficiently diverted towards its own problems with China.

The military is still getting a large share of the nation's resources as a result of its gradual usurpation of power and decades-long dominance of the state apparatus. By claiming more and more funds in the name of "national security" the military is simply trying to grab greater political, economic and social space for itself to the detriment of millions of struggling Pakistani citizens. The army chief is already a member of the top economic decision-making body, and military officers dominate most institutions.

The government and other state institutions seem unable to resist the military's growing demands and put the people first. Pakistan's foreign allies, donors and partners, therefore, have a duty to pressure Islamabad to rethink its priorities.

Source- https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/o...pPboBiJHEu0At_DpxaqN43xUghjmRcdfZksKpFA79YFqM
 
.
View attachment 647134Prime Minister Imran Khan's government allocated $7.85bn for defence and merely $151m for health in the budget for the financial year 2020-2021 [AP/BK Bangash]

The Pakistani government does not seem willing to shift its spending priorities despite the burgeoning COVID-19 challenges.

Pakistan has emerged as one of the countries with the fastest rate of coronavirus infections in recent weeks, according to the World Health Organization (WHO). The country reported its first coronavirus case on February 26 and is now among the top 15 most-affected countries. More than 4,000 people have lost their lives to the disease in Pakistan since the beginning of the outbreak. Moreover, there is a significant shortage of personal protective equipment (PPE) and ventilators in the country.

Despite all this, Islamabad allocated $7.85bn for defence and merely $151m for health in the budget for the financial year 2020-2021. This represents a 12 percent rise in Pakistan's defence spending compared with the last financial year. The single-line figure presented in the budget does not give a full picture of the amount actually being spent on defence either.

To avoid hard questions from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Pakistan refuses to be fully transparent about its military spending. Major acquisitions by the armed forces, spending on the public sector development programme (PSDP), expenditure on the nuclear programme and para-military forces, payments for military pensions, a newly set-up national security division and a few other military expenditures are not reflected in the budget. If these were to be added to it, Pakistan's defence spending would be even higher - at around $11bn.
The increase in defence spending comes at a time when Pakistan is forced to allocate 41 percent of its expenditure to debt servicing. The economy was underperforming even before the onset of COVID-19, surviving on an IMF loan package of $6bn. The gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate had plummeted from 5.5 percent in the 2017-2018 financial year to 2.4 percent in 2020-2021. Following the coronavirus outbreak, it decreased further to -1.5 percent. This marked the first time in Pakistan's history that a negative growth rate was recorded.

Before the pandemic, Pakistan was already burdened by an external debt of about $112bn. Today it is facing the additional challenge of feeding some 25 million poor families that can no longer make a living due to COVID-19. Moreover, the country saw a 30 percent reduction in tax revenue, due to the government's incompetence and decreased spending caused by the coronavirus lockdown. This led to a reduction in overall health spending, as the provincial governments received a less funds from the federal government.
It is, for instance, impossible for the parliamentarians to ask the army to make do with the domestically produced main battle tank al-Khaled, rather than buying new Chinese tanks. Despite paying more than $2bn in military pensions every year (a major expenditure that is not included in the defence budget), the government is not allowed to question what the military does with the revenues from its $20bn private business empire either.

The military business also gets approximately $90.9m annually in tax exemptions from the state. Furthermore, the armed forces, unlike civilian departments, have the authority to move funds from one head of account to another. This means that it never has to surrender resources back to the state at the end of a financial year.

Despite the continuing dispute with India over Kashmir, a war between the two neighbours does not seem likely. Pakistan's nuclear programme provides the necessary deterrence to prevent a ground war. This means there is no need for an increase in defence spending, especially at a time when the country is facing an unprecedented crisis and India's attention is sufficiently diverted towards its own problems with China.

The military is still getting a large share of the nation's resources as a result of its gradual usurpation of power and decades-long dominance of the state apparatus. By claiming more and more funds in the name of "national security" the military is simply trying to grab greater political, economic and social space for itself to the detriment of millions of struggling Pakistani citizens. The army chief is already a member of the top economic decision-making body, and military officers dominate most institutions.

The government and other state institutions seem unable to resist the military's growing demands and put the people first. Pakistan's foreign allies, donors and partners, therefore, have a duty to pressure Islamabad to rethink its priorities.

Source- https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/o...pPboBiJHEu0At_DpxaqN43xUghjmRcdfZksKpFA79YFqM


So we don't become a despot state of others like qatar has become
 
. . . .
Because we are in a bad neighbourhood as WE are in a state of war ever since our existence!!!!
India's economy is way bigger than that of Pakistan. India's defence budget alone is more than Pakistan's entire economy.

I have no issues with Pakistan spending huge sums of money on defence but the thing is unlike India, Pakistan is not being able to expand its economy drastically.
 
.
War is coming
War has been coming for over 50 years but never came. The last time we had a conflict was 20+ years ago because your general decided to do a very brave, discreet invasion which was a glorious failure on all accounts and left Pakistanis with a red face.
 
.
India's economy is way bigger than that of Pakistan. India's defence budget alone is more than Pakistan's entire economy.

I have no issues with Pakistan spending huge sums of money on defence but the thing is unlike India, Pakistan is not being able to expand its economy drastically.


Pakistan economy is massively underdeveloped

Pakistan is a 220 million market
Strategically placed at a crossroads in asia
With both its own and neighbors resources underdeveloped

Pakistan is a economy waiting to take off but burdened with historic corruption

Once that is resolved, Pakistan will be something special

Pakistan also does incredibly well utilising it's frankly average military budget to achieve a big impact
From cruise missiles to nuclear warheads to subs to our own JV jet programme

Pakistan has to be ready armed and prepared for our enemy


War has been coming for over 50 years but never came. The last time we had a conflict was 20+ years ago because your general decided to do a very brave, discreet invasion which was a glorious failure on all accounts and left Pakistanis with a red face.



Last time we had a conflict was last year bruv

When India was humiliated

If it wasn't for our determination to blow India off the face of the earth do you think India would have cowered away after such a humilating episode for it
 
.
India's economy is way bigger than that of Pakistan. India's defence budget alone is more than Pakistan's entire economy.

I have no issues with Pakistan spending huge sums of money on defence but the thing is unlike India, Pakistan is not being able to expand its economy drastically.

India's defence budget = 57b $. Pakistan GDP = 310b$.
 
. . .
Will Ayesha Siddiqa man the border and fend off the Indians with her propaganda when war comes? Maybe she can pick off the missiles from India with her bare teeth. Or just look in India's general direction and they'll surrender.
 
.
Corona is over and it’s only hyped in leftist media to demand new BS regulations and a stronger despotic state. Thank god Pakistan didn’t jump on that bandwagon.
 
.
The money that's allocated for health is hardly spent in the healthcare sector, it's usually eaten up by people in charge of allocating these funds. Whilst I wish our health system had more funding, I certainly don't mind my tax money going to the armed forces of Pakistan. Cut other sectors and allocate them to healthcare, but not the military.

If the army falls, we become another Syria, Libya, Yemen. Thanks, but no thanks. We are not all like Dr Ayesha, that we can run away to the West if there is major unrest in the country.
 
.
India's economy is way bigger than that of Pakistan. India's defence budget alone is more than Pakistan's entire economy.

I have no issues with Pakistan spending huge sums of money on defence but the thing is unlike India, Pakistan is not being able to expand its economy drastically.

So what do you want us to do? Bend our arses backwards toward India? Handover Kashmir and GB to India? Become a client state of a country being run by a Nazified Hindu? Bangladesh might be content with being lapdogs of Indians but we are not by even a long shot or like ever.

FYI Indian defense budget is merely 57 billion not even remotely the size of our economy. As for defense budget of Pakistan it is merely 2.8% of GDP. As for Health it is a provincial subject so even if federal govt allocates funds for health and education it is merely for federal territories.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom