Why Iran Is Deporting Scores of Afghan Refugees

[maximuswarrior]

I say for Pakistan and Afghan relations need to have two things 1.Pakistanis need to stop dreaming that they could control Afghanistan at will, and push it around 2.Afghans need to stop claiming all their problems is on Pakistan and that we are all just chess pawns on geopoltical stage



Pakistan is bit to close to Beijing nothing wrong but all I see Pakistan's future is economic stagnation and mild growth India the same nothing special just the west needs them to prop it up as counter to China

Pak economy will grow manifold in coming years. That is if we continue to have PTI as the ruling party. Yes, we have our challange cut out with surgically removing PPP and PML-N scumbags.

 

[Yankee-stani]

Pak economy will grow manifold in coming years. That is if we continue to have PTI as the ruling party.

I dont know about high growth but modest at best

 

[maximuswarrior]

I dont know about high growth but modest at best

Initially modest to recover from earlier damage.

 

[H. Dawary]

Afghanistan needs to team up with India and USA. Remember that Pakistan is the enemy here.

Pakistan won't be poor. We have teamed up with China for a specific reason.

Afghanistan will always consider Pakistan an enemy because it has never ever accepted it from independence till this very day.

India can go to h*ll for all I care. If Pakistan is out of the picture, we would be next on their target list.

This so called team is a delusion, this same team between China and PAK is also a delusion. Friends are only good if they will be there for you in your time of greatest need. I doubt China and India will give two cents about us. Aside from economics they aren’t anything worth bragging about.

A strong relationship between AFG and PAK would actually benefit the people’s o both nations.

 

[Sineva]

Unfortunate but understandable.In light of the economic warfare by the west directed at iran,its foolish to believe that iran can continue to squander resources on refugees who are only in iran as a direct result of western policies of war and destabilization in the region.Let the nato nations pay for their upkeep.

 

[maximuswarrior]

India can go to h*ll for all I care. If Pakistan is out of the picture, we would be next on their target list.

This so called team is a delusion, this same team between China and PAK is also a delusion. Friends are only good if they will be there for you in your time of greatest need. I doubt China and India will give two cents about us. Aside from economics they aren’t anything worth bragging about.

A strong relationship between AFG and PAK would actually benefit the people’s o both nations.

That is a fantasy and you know it too. Afghan government consists of Pakistan haters and pro-India elements. That is just a fact.

Also, Afghan territorial dispute with Pakistan is very harmful for cordial relations.

Afghans should by all means concentrate on improving the economy and security in their nation. This talk of merging is a non-starter. It is next to impossible.

 

[Yankee-stani]

India can go to h*ll for all I care. If Pakistan is out of the picture, we would be next on their target list.

This so called team is a delusion, this same team between China and PAK is also a delusion. Friends are only good if they will be there for you in your time of greatest need. I doubt China and India will give two cents about us. Aside from economics they aren’t anything worth bragging about.

A strong relationship between AFG and PAK would actually benefit the people’s o both nations.

40 years of constant warfare in Afghanistan and 30 years prior of brainwashing of the Afghan elite for Pasthunistan, have led to generations of hatred of both peoples for Pakistanis who dont really have much of identity thanks to the Govts lack of cohesive identity tried to nice with you guys but again no work too much distrust hence the only realistic options I see is a Stable Afghanistan on its own but Pak needs cordial ties at best as for China they are the only world power that backs us in good and hard times and its a fact

Unfortunate but understandable.In light of the economic warfare by the west directed at iran,its foolish to believe that iran can continue to squander resources on refugees who are only in iran as a direct result of western policies of war and destabilization in the region.Let the nato nations pay for their upkeep.

One thing the Iranians get right is drafting of Young Afghan Men

 

[H. Dawary]

That is a fantasy and you know it too. Afghan government consists of Pakistan haters and pro-India elements. That is just a fact.

Also, Afghan territorial dispute with Pakistan is very harmful for cordial relations.

Afghans should by all means concentrate on improving the economy and security in their nation. This talk of merging is a non-starter. It is next to impossible.

It does sound like a fantasy, but I don’t see Afg and Pak benefitting if both are always at odds with each other, this simply cannot work especially since we share the same people and have such a long border.

I agree with the territorial dispute. Most Afghans live in fantasy land and think the people of KPK want to be apart of us when it’s the exact opposite. This is something that should be settled, otherwise cordial relations will not happen.

Out of curiosity I’d like to ask, would you a support a merge if it was within possibility?

 

[OldenWisdom...قول بزرگ]

Afghanistan is being setup again for another failure. The Afghan people and Pakistani people will be victims. Don't allow your own fields to be used against yourself. Iranians could care less about Sunni Afghans ... of push comes to shove they may claim western Afghanistan and Pakistan's Balochistan.
No man is an island!

 

[TNT]

Iran, just like their brother gangus will deport all sunnis and will keep the shias as cannon fodder. Iranian mullahs learned feom their hindu brothers how to hold a country on religious or sectarian basis. India is a heaven for hindus and iran is a heaven for shias in the area. Pakistan, instead of being fooled by brown sahibs and liberal retards should keep its sunni roots strong. These iranian snakes and their allies can never be trusted, we nees to keep our strong relations with GCC and arabs.

 

[Apocalypse]

Out of curiosity I’d like to ask, would you a support a merge if it was within possibility?

Do a poll on the forums. I for one would support the merger.

 

[B.K.N]

To integrate the Afghan refugees we should draft them in the army and armed forces I think thats better at this point

Pakistan doesn't have any scarcity of people that it would recruit foreigners in army.

Pakistan and Afghanistan are both beggar nations brother, this is the sad reality for both.

Only Afghanistan is beggar. Don't compare it with Pakistan and no one in Pakistan is interested in your country

 

[maximuswarrior]

It does sound like a fantasy, but I don’t see Afg and Pak benefitting if both are always at odds with each other, this simply cannot work especially since we share the same people and have such a long border.

I agree with the territorial dispute. Most Afghans live in fantasy land and think the people of KPK want to be apart of us when it’s the exact opposite. This is something that should be settled, otherwise cordial relations will not happen.

Out of curiosity I’d like to ask, would you a support a merge if it was within possibility?

I would entertain and support this idea only if Afghans stop seeing Pakistan as the enemy on Indian behalf.

 

[Pakistani Fighter]

most Pakistani Shia volunteers are mostly Afghan refugees

You mean Hazara Aghan Refugees?

 

[PakGuns]

This is what I don’t understand about the Afghanistani govt. They never bark against Iranian influence, and won’t dare say anything even when they are literally throwing them back over the border. Yet if Pakistan even sneezes they will condemn & protest day or night.

that's because they've been in bed with india