What's new

Why India’s Defence Export Strategy for BrahMos & Tejas is Failing with Make in India?

ashok321

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 1, 2010
Messages
17,942
Reaction score
4
Country
Canada
Location
Malaysia
https://eurasiantimes.com/make-in-india-export-strategy/

11.jpg



How is Indian Government’s project – Make in India doing? Why is India still importing weapons and not creating own weapons with ake in India program? Indian Army itself rejected a Make in India Rifle for two consecutive years, how can India’s ambition to be a defence export superpower be realized?

On 26th Jan 2018, India celebrated its 69th Republic Day with full panache. The parade hosted 10 ASEAN leaders, a step towards strengthening the India-ASEAN ties. The parade also showcased Made-In-India weapons as an attempt to display India’s defence strength to the potential ASEAN buyers.

India is working towards shifting from being a defence import to defence export nation, offering Indian made weapons like the BrahMos missile system to other Asian countries. The upcoming Air Show in Singapore (where Tejas Fighter Jet will be highlighted by India) is another event where India will display its ability to be recognised as a defence export nation.

India’s Defense Export and Make in India Program Not Strong Enough

According to experts, although India boasts of a 250 billion dollars modernised military program, it is not strong enough. Additionally, the defence procurement system is extremely unorganised too. This unorganised system has made India unable to equip its own Defense forces, thus working towards being a defence export power seems like a far-fetched dream. Although the nation’s spending on the military is higher than Pakistan’s, it is still considered low as compared to China.


According to the secretary of defence production, the main problem with India becoming a defence export nation is the fact that the country continues to import most of the parts. The BrahMos missile system, India’s pride, is itself made up of more than sixty percent imported parts.

The Loopholes in the Defense Export Plan
While PM Modi hopes to become a defence export power to increase employment opportunities and reduce the cost of imports, there are many loopholes that make this ‘make-in-India’ vision blurry. The drawbacks include:

  • India’s prime concern has always been the price
  • Lack of R&D by state-owned defence contractors
  • Over-ambitious goals
  • Incompletion of projects
  • Inflated final price to compensate for added cost as a result of delays

Most of the equipment procured by India is managed by administrative staff who are not experts in the field. This results in poor quality of equipment
. Locally made products cannot be used in sensitive border areas as they are weak in performance and quality. Although the Indian Defense forces are exceptionally well trained, the management, equipment, procurement and organization systems are weak and failing. The forces still rely on imported weapons and defence equipment. If India wants to be known as the defence export power of the world, or even Asia, it needs to regulate and strengthen many systems that work along with it.
 
india is basically a failed country, and if it were not the british, it was not even a country to begin with.

Yes, India is a failed country and your friend Pakistan is a successful country.

Happy now...
 
india is basically a failed country, and if it were not the british, it was not even a country to begin with.

Yes, even the existence of India is artificial and illegitimate. Especially it hijack the term “India”. So India is less than a fail country as it imply that it’s a country in a first place. Indian Union will fail like European Union. People of India don’t deserve this monstrosity called India that is causing so much chaos, hunger, strife to itself and its neighbors.
 
Yes, even the existence of India is artificial and illegitimate. Especially it hijack the term “India”. So India is less than a fail country as it imply that it’s a country in a first place. Indian Union will fail like European Union. People of India don’t deserve this monstrosity called India that is causing so much chaos, hunger, strife to itself and its neighbors.
Go and say this to the founders of British East India company, those who named Caribbean as West Indies, those who named Indian Ocean.

Punny slaves of cpc have to contend with a lake called south china sea, probably natures slap on the face of arrogant hypppuuurrrrr power..
 
Go and say this to the founders of British East India company, those who named Caribbean as West Indies, those who named Indian Ocean.

Punny slaves of cpc have to contend with a lake called south china sea, probably natures slap on the face of arrogant hypppuuurrrrr power..

You are a brave Indian to admit that India is a geographical expression.
 
You are a brave Indian to admit that India is a geographical expression.
Ohh Myyyy Gaawd!!! Gawd Nature is too powerful and cruel to arrogants.

Look at the reality, it has made the world's only hypur power to beg at the feet of a mere geographical expression to for its almighty chips to pass thru.

This is reality you punny slave. You can cry and call whatever you want but whatever I said is reality.
LEARN TO LIVE WITH A GEOGRAPHICAL EXPRESSION. A sad but only option for you.
 
https://eurasiantimes.com/make-in-india-export-strategy/

11.jpg



How is Indian Government’s project – Make in India doing? Why is India still importing weapons and not creating own weapons with make in India program? Indian Army itself rejected a Make in India Rifle for two consecutive years, how can India’s ambition to be a defence export superpower be realized?

On 26th Jan 2018, India celebrated its 69th Republic Day with full panache. The parade hosted 10 ASEAN leaders, a step towards strengthening the India-ASEAN ties. The parade also showcased Made-In-India weapons as an attempt to display India’s defence strength to the potential ASEAN buyers.

India is working towards shifting from being a defence import to defence export nation, offering Indian made weapons like the BrahMos missile system to other Asian countries. The upcoming Air Show in Singapore (where Tejas Fighter Jet will be highlighted by India) is another event where India will display its ability to be recognised as a defence export nation.

India’s Defense Export and Make in India Program Not Strong Enough

According to experts, although India boasts of a 250 billion dollars modernised military program, it is not strong enough. Additionally, the defence procurement system is extremely unorganised too. This unorganised system has made India unable to equip its own Defense forces, thus working towards being a defence export power seems like a far-fetched dream. Although the nation’s spending on the military is higher than Pakistan’s, it is still considered low as compared to China.


According to the secretary of defence production, the main problem with India becoming a defence export nation is the fact that the country continues to import most of the parts. The BrahMos missile system, India’s pride, is itself made up of more than sixty percent imported parts.

The Loopholes in the Defense Export Plan
While PM Modi hopes to become a defence export power to increase employment opportunities and reduce the cost of imports, there are many loopholes that make this ‘make-in-India’ vision blurry. The drawbacks include:

  • India’s prime concern has always been the price
  • Lack of R&D by state-owned defence contractors
  • Over-ambitious goals
  • Incompletion of projects
  • Inflated final price to compensate for added cost as a result of delays

Most of the equipment procured by India is managed by administrative staff who are not experts in the field. This results in poor quality of equipment. Locally made products cannot be used in sensitive border areas as they are weak in performance and quality. Although the Indian Defense forces are exceptionally well trained, the management, equipment, procurement and organization systems are weak and failing. The forces still rely on imported weapons and defence equipment. If India wants to be known as the defence export power of the world, or even Asia, it needs to regulate and strengthen many systems that work along with it.
 
Excerpt:

FDI in defence from 2014 to the end of 2017 was a measly 11.2 million rupees (US$170,400). Despite Modi’s personal push for a “Make in India” policy since 2014, the project is floundering, the culprits for which are within India’s Ministry of Defence (MoD).


Hehehehe

Modi fooling Modians for votes..

Aha:

In a much-publicized ceremony presided over by Sitharaman at DefExpo 2018, eight DRDO technologies were “transferred” to the public and private sectors. This was needless self-aggrandizement because transfer of these technologies had already taken place in 2012 in separate ceremonies.

The DRDO may have fooled the defence minister but not the foreign participants very much, who are abreast of developments in the Indian defence sector. As someone tweeted, if there is nothing new to show, falling back on old stuff is the only recourse.


Lol:

The problem in pushing defence exports is the quality of indigenous products and the time schedule of delivery. Would the defence minister know that in the past when South Korea showed interest in purchasing 12 indigenous bridge-laying tanks, India’s response was delivering two per year – which country would wait for six years?

a bureaucrat in the MoD who leaked military secrets to the media and orchestrated the closure of the army’s Technical Support Division during the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance II is back in the MoD at a higher level under the Bharatiya Janata Party-led National Democratic Alliance II.
 
Back
Top Bottom