What If Bengal emerged as a unified nation post 1947 ?

[GHALIB]

Indian Govt. fed you a line of reasoning and you swallowed it hook, line and sinker. If by 'We' you mean Indian Govt.

No one does anything out of charity. I am tired of explaining this to every new Indian poster in PDF but here goes.

India gained four things out of sending its army to fight Pakistan Army in East Pakistan and finishing the war.

1. Neutralized the military threat from the Eastern front and to the seven sisters.
2. Created a new market for exclusively Indian products and services worth USD 15 Billion a year.
3. Created new tourism and medical tourism market for India from Bangladeshi citizens. Again about USD 15 Billion worth a year.
4. Created the fourth (probably third) largest remittance source for India worth at least USD 10 Billion a year.

These gains have been running forty-fifty years by now. Multiply fifty by on average 30 Billion a year and you have your answer why India fought that war.

You talk about Hindutva and Go Mata. We in Bangladesh are bigger in value than any Go Mata ever was to Indians.

We are the 'Gavi' that kept on giving....for fifty damn years.

But enough is enough.

One might ask what we got in return in the last fifty years.

• Our citizens being killed at the border by trigger-happy BSF.
• Being derided even though we spend more money in India than at home.
• Constant interference in our internal politics and foreign affairs.
• Rohingya problem foisted on us by Myanmarese with express Indian approval and support.
• Proxy wars in our hill tracts by Shanti Bahini trained by RAW.
• Our citizens called as 'ghuspetias' when they don't even go to India, much less apply for Aadhar card or whatever.

I could go on but I rest my case.

This is not for you - but for the rest of PDF to see.

you forget conditions prior to 1971, whatever we did was for saving bangali people from oppression , bangladesh is friend country that is why we have business worth billions . it is beneficial for both countries . rest is your imagination .

 

[GHALIB]

Oh man , they are just victims . If they do not praise their terrorist country India , they will be in concentration camp by new era Hitler ( chawala ) . I truly feel for India Muslims . They are helpless . Who try to fight back are labelled as terrorists.

lol .....we see illegal bangladeshis in every indian city , they love concentration camp , no indian is leaving india to go live in bangladesh .

 

[X-ray Papa]

who cares ? carry on , there are many .

Yeah, The the whole world hates indians.

 

[X-ray Papa]

you forget conditions prior to 1971, whatever we did was for saving bangali people from oppression , bangladesh is friend country that is why we have business worth billions . it is beneficial for both countries . rest is your imagination .

Just Shut up, Come to dhaka you will see how friendly we are to you indians.

 

[VikingRaider]

lol .....we see illegal bangladeshis in every indian city , they love concentration camp , no indian is leaving india to go live in bangladesh .

. By the way did you get any threat from sanghi folks ? You seem too much vocal as an India Muslim.

 

[VikingRaider]

Just Shut up, Come to dhaka you will see how friendly we are to you indians.

They even don't need to come to Bangladesh . They can just check youtube channels and Fb pages to know how much people love India . The reality is all people love to curse India . Just if any Bangladeshi try to be friendly towards India , they are neutralized by Indians unless they are not bloody sycophants . Well India want stooge inside Bangladesh and they have it . But I do not think other than stooges , any Bangladeshi ( including secular) have any good feelings to India and it's expansionism.

 

[GHALIB]

. By the way did you get any threat fromsanghi folks ? You seem too much vocal as an India Muslim.

who cares for coward sanghis ? they fear patriotic muslims . there is no problem for patriotic muslims who have indian dna .

 

[GHALIB]

They even don't need to come to Bangladesh . They can just check youtube channels and Fb pages to know how much people love India . The reality is all people love to curse India . Just if any Bangladeshi try to be friendly towards India , they are neutralized by Indians unless they are not bloody sycophants . Well India want stooge inside Bangladesh and they have it . But I do not think other than stooges , any Bangladeshi ( including secular) have any good feelings to India and it's expansionism.

indians love bangladesh , indian culture is same as bangladesh . you are doing propaganda because there are jihadi outfits like al shams, al badar , jamat i islami who hate patriotic bangladeshis and indians . in 1971 these extremist organizations killed innocent bangalis . you look to be sympathetic to those extremist organizations .

 

[GHALIB]

Just Shut up, Come to dhaka you will see how friendly we are to you indians.

daily lakhs of bangalis come to india and indians go to dhaka for business . bangalis love india , few jamatis extremists may have problem . nobody cares .

 

[GHALIB]

Yeah, The the whole world hates indians.

that is why indians are leading world organizations .

 

[VikingRaider]

indians love bangladesh , indian culture is same as bangladesh .

Yes sure . Who has lover like India , they do not need enemy to be utterly destroyed .

you are doing propaganda because there are jihadi outfits like al shams, al badar , jamat i islami who hate patriotic bangladeshis and indians . in 1971 these extremist organizations killed innocent bangalis . you look to be sympathetic to those extremist organizations .

Hahaha . Who said that I am sympathetic to those extremist . I am one of them ( crypto Jamati ) . @DalalErMaNodi , look at this Jamati sympathizer @Atlas . New awami jamati hybrid league re deikha lon . Join korte chaile asen dorja khola ache

 

[VikingRaider]

daily lakhs of bangalis come to india and indians go to dhaka for business . bangalis love india , few jamatis extremists may have problem . nobody cares .

Actually Jamat is a tool of India . Same as once Taliban was a tool of India against Pakistan at a time. However the nice thing is India can use such groups easily because people don't believe that mullahs can be stooge of India. Huge benefit for enemy no doubt.

 

[bluesky]

Actually Jamat is a tool of India . Same as once Taliban was a tool for India against Pakistan at a time. However the nice thing is India can use such groups easily because people don't believe that mullahs can be stooge of India. Huge benefit for enemy no doubt.

Not all Jamati Mullahs know that they are being used by India. Very limited few at the top receive money from a certain Muslim source which is an Indian agent with certain agendas. So, all these misguided people are used by India via that agent (s). Jamatis follow the instruction of Indian agent without knowing his real identity.

 

[VikingRaider]

Not all Jamati Mullahs know that they are being used by India. Very limited few at the top receive money from a certain Muslim source which is an Indian agent with certain agendas. So, all these misguided people are used by India via that agent (s). Jamatis follow the instruction of Indian agent without knowing his real identity.

I couldn't have said it better myself. Whole heartedly agree with your message.

You can harm people by becoming a direct enemy , but you can't utterly annihilate their soul without becoming one of them. So if you want to take over their soul, be one of them. Exactly India is now doing so. I take pity on poor common mullahs ,who blindly follow their leaders instead of studying the glorious history of Muslim nation ( dynasties in history) .

 

[idune]

Not all Jamati Mullahs know that they are being used by India. Very limited few at the top receive money from a certain Muslim source which is an Indian agent with certain agendas. So, all these misguided people are used by India via that agent (s). Jamatis follow the instruction of Indian agent without knowing his real identity.

Another on of your cloud nine imagination....oh well.
Let say your wise crack wisdom was to be true. In that case, all heinous crime Jamat had been accused of actually indian instigation and doing. And it was india, tried to prevent Bangladesh independence. Lets see how many buy into your wise crack.