Vivek Agnihotri in conversation with India News Junction on Threats and Fatwas

[-=virus=-]

 

[Reichsmarschall]

A cockroach like should have stomped on long ago.

 

[Paitoo]

Everyone is entitled to make the movie they want as long as they are not promoting violence and distorting history. He may have chosen to depict a portion of history for whatever reason, but as long as that happened, he has a right to depict it. Maybe someone else can make a movie on Jammu massacre or something else. Maybe Pakistanis should make it.

There have been movies on Gujarat massacre including one I watched (named Parzania if I am not mistaken), which basically sums up the riots as a false flag operation by Modi. There are other movies too that depict Muslims and Sikhs as victims, though I agree that such movies may not get produced under the current regime. Anti-Sikh riot content is not discouraged as long as the perpetrators are shown as Congressis first.

I disagree with Agnihotri that the massacre of Pandits has been downplayed historically. It is a well known fact which most educated Indians know about and because of this they always have a soft corner for Kashmiri pundits whenever they meet them. In Mumbai University where I did my engineering, there was a quota for children of Kashmiri pandits, although a tiny one. For many Indians Kashmir is synonymous with massacre of Pandits, so I don't know what brushing-under-the-carpet he is referring to.

We need some good comedies and movies that promote communal harmony, not in an in-your-face way with a Khan Chacha like character of 70s, but movies about regular Indians of all communities living regular lives.

 

[Asimzranger]

From questionable vulgar films to propaganda film . Good that this film got banned in few countries

 

[Areesh]

Kia bol raha hai yeh sanghion ka Christopher Nolan?

 

[jamahir]

This terrorist / criminal might describe me as an Urban Naxal. His YouTube channel is called 'I am Buddha' but in fact if Buddha had lived now this terrorist might certainly have described Buddha too as an Urban Naxal. His film has been rejected by the Kashmiri Pandits too.

 

[fitpOsitive]

But killing of Kashmiri Muslims by Indian forces was OK?

 

[-=virus=-]

But killing of Kashmiri Muslims by Indian forces was OK?

I didn't say that, I wouldn't say that either.

Facts are, that the KPs left, were driven out, but the KMs are still very much there.

 

[Maula Jatt]

I didn't say that, I wouldn't say that either.

Facts are, that the KPs left, were driven out, but the KMs are still very much there.

40000 dead according to conservative estimates forget rapes, tortures etc

In comparison 200 KP over 2-3 decades

 

[-=virus=-]

40000 dead according to conservative estimates forget rapes, tortures etc

In comparison 200 KP over 2-3 decades

Don't have the data so can't say for certain.. but on the face of it those numbers you quote sound questionable at the very least.

 

[SuvarnaTeja]

Everyone is entitled to make the movie they want as long as they are not promoting violence and distorting history. He may have chosen to depict a portion of history for whatever reason, but as long as that happened, he has a right to depict it. Maybe someone else can make a movie on Jammu massacre or something else. Maybe Pakistanis should make it.

There have been movies on Gujarat massacre including one I watched (named Parzania if I am not mistaken), which basically sums up the riots as a false flag operation by Modi. There are other movies too that depict Muslims and Sikhs as victims, though I agree that such movies may not get produced under the current regime. Anti-Sikh riot content is not discouraged as long as the perpetrators are shown as Congressis first.

I disagree with Agnihotri that the massacre of Pandits has been downplayed historically. It is a well known fact which most educated Indians know about and because of this they always have a soft corner for Kashmiri pundits whenever they meet them. In Mumbai University where I did my engineering, there was a quota for children of Kashmiri pandits, although a tiny one. For many Indians Kashmir is synonymous with massacre of Pandits, so I don't know what brushing-under-the-carpet he is referring to.

We need some good comedies and movies that promote communal harmony, not in an in-your-face way with a Khan Chacha like character of 70s, but movies about regular Indians of all communities living regular lives.

This movie should be banned and all the people involved in making this movie needs to be booked under UAPA.

No ifs and buts.

 

[Maula Jatt]

Don't have the data so can't say for certain.. but on the face of it those numbers you quote sound questionable at the very least.

22000 "millitants" included

41,000 deaths in 27 years: The anatomy of Kashmir militancy in numbers

Militancy in Kashmir has constantly derailed ties between India and Pakistan. HT looked at the latest available government data to anyalse the deaths and patterns of violence in Kashmir in the past 27 years.

www.hindustantimes.com

This is an Indian source and this is a conservative estimates by gov so they'll try to make it sound as "acceptable" as possible by calling victims millitants, adding soldiers who died on the loc as Kashmir conflict

 

[-=virus=-]

22000 "millitants" included

41,000 deaths in 27 years: The anatomy of Kashmir militancy in numbers

Militancy in Kashmir has constantly derailed ties between India and Pakistan. HT looked at the latest available government data to anyalse the deaths and patterns of violence in Kashmir in the past 27 years.

www.hindustantimes.com

This is an Indian source and this is a conservative estimates by gov so they'll try to make it sound as "acceptable" as possible by calling victims millitants, adding soldiers who died on the loc as Kashmir conflict

Propaganda and counter propaganda, both sides are guilty of cashing in on a tragedy for their own political ends. A most sorry state of affairs.

 

[Akshay89]

During Congress Muslim rule:

 

[-=virus=-]

During Congress Muslim rule:
View attachment 826619View attachment 826619

So ?

He didn't say anything against Islam or muslims, just about the conflict.