What's new

Vietnam a Growing Threat to Taiwan’s South China Sea Claims: Report

Viet

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
29,950
Reaction score
0
Country
Viet Nam
Location
Germany
I believe the Taiwanese begin to wet their pants. Maybe it is best for them to surrender.


Vietnam a Growing Threat to Taiwan’s South China Sea Claims: Report | The Diplomat
Taiwan weighs Vietnam’s threat to its military outpost in Itu Aba

thediplomat_2014-08-19_13-42-52-36x36.jpg

By Prashanth Parameswaran
December 31, 2014

Vietnam’s military expansion on nearby islands could threaten Taiwan’s lone outpost in the South China Sea, according to a new report submitted to Taiwan’s Control Yuan.

The report, published by the Ministry of National Defense, noted that Vietnam’s deployment of mobile missiles and artillery guns on island bases could pose a threat to Taiwan’s military outpost Itu Aba (which Taiwan calls Taiping Island), the largest feature in the Spratly Islands which is also claimed by Vietnam, the Philippines and China.

Of particular concern are moves by Vietnam to expand its troop presence in Sand Cay Island, including by deploying new shoulder-fired anti-aircraft missiles (known as Dunqian Sand Island in Chinese Son Ca Island to the Vietnamese) – which lies just 11 km east of Itu Aba. If Vietnam plans on deploying these portable missiles close to Itu Aba, the report says it could attack Taiwan’s C-130 military transport planes and supply ships on their routine visits to Taiping Island.

“Vietnam may plan to deploy these portable missiles to reef islets closer to Taiping Island or might carry them on patrol boats to within striking range. In such a scenario, our military transport aircraft heading to Taiping Island would be directly threatened,” The Taipei Times quoted the report as saying.

Itu Aba, the only physical manifestation of Taiwan’s claims in the South China Sea, is an important feature not just because of its size, but because of its supporting infrastructure – including a large runway and fresh water supply – which makes habitation possible. As a result, experts say controlling Itu Aba could eventually help a country advance a legal claim not just on the island itself, but its immediate surroundings or potentially the whole Spratly archipelago and the resources within it.

The report, part of an evaluation of the regional security environment in East Asia, implored Taiwan to boost its defenses in the South China Sea in the face of military expansion by Vietnam as well as China and the Philippines.

In response to the report, some lawmakers have recommended that the country strengthen its own capabilities in the wake of the report’s findings. Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislators Johnny Chiang and Lin fu-fang said a new-generation Tuo-Jiang-class corvette, equipped with five surface-to-surface Hsiung Feng 2E missiles, could help Taiwan increase its deterrence capabilities.

“We must flex our firepower muscle there to deter such threats. Therefore, I request the military to station one or two Tuo Jiang corvettes at the Taiping base on a long-term basis,” Chiang said.

But Minister of National Defense Yen Ming reminded the legislators that since Vietnam has yet to deploy the shoulder-fired missiles on Sand Cay Island, their limited range did not yet pose an imminent threat to Itu Aba. He also said preparations were already underway to help Taiwan adjust to different military contingencies and defend its claims.

Taiwan has been looking to boost its own capabilities on Itu Aba, which is administered by its coast guard, in recent months. Taiwanese officials have announced plans to improve its runway to accommodate transport and marine patrol aircraft and to construct a port that would allow naval frigates and coastguard cutters to be stationed there permanently.

The plans have predictably drawn protests from Vietnam and the Philippines, who have questioned both the legality of Taiwan’s expansion as well as its impact on peace and stability in the South China Sea.
 
.
That is precisely why the US military weapon sales recently approved to Taiwan shall not be seen as hostile by PRC. Taiwan has the right to arm themselves. ROC will never win PRC China but Taiwan can beat the shit out of Philippines and Vietnam in protecting their China territories.
 
.
That is precisely why the US military weapon sales recently approved to Taiwan shall not be seen as hostile by PRC. Taiwan has the right to arm themselves. ROC will never win PRC China but Taiwan can beat the shit out of Philippines and Vietnam in protecting their China territories.
no, the taiwanese get outdated junks from uncle sam. 30+ years old warships. the softie boys from taiwan have no chance against vietnam.

but the article is just a joke. we will never start a war against taiwan. why should we? we maintain a very good economics/cultural relationship to taiwan.
 
.
no, the taiwanese get outdated junks from uncle sam. 30+ years old warships. the softie boys from taiwan have no chance against vietnam.

but the article is just a joke. we will never start a war against taiwan. why should we? we maintain a very good economics/cultural relationship to taiwan.

Based on what? The Taiwanese armed forces may not be able to deter China, but it can certainly beat Vietnam.
 
.
no, the taiwanese get outdated junks from uncle sam. 30+ years old warships. the softie boys from taiwan have no chance against vietnam.

but the article is just a joke. we will never start a war against taiwan. why should we? we maintain a very good economics/cultural relationship to taiwan.

RoC navy is certainly better than VN's. Taiwan has poured all its effort and resources into the navy because that was the critical branch for defending against PRC military operations.
 
.
That is precisely why the US military weapon sales recently approved to Taiwan shall not be seen as hostile by PRC. Taiwan has the right to arm themselves. ROC will never win PRC China but Taiwan can beat the shit out of Philippines and Vietnam in protecting their China territories.

Taiwan is just born as a pitiful puppet, and they are doing what their master has requested them to do.

When Pinoy killed their fisherman, they can't even do a sh1t. What an embarrassing regime, since ROC was born as a shame since the beginning.

RoC navy is certainly better than VN's. Taiwan has poured all its effort and resources into the navy because that was the critical branch for defending against PRC military operations.

Don't expect too much from those Taiwanese coward army.

When the KMT had the German equipment, yet they still lost against Imperial Japan's third class land army.
 
.
It's not important whether Taiwan Navy can beat VN or not. There's ALWAYS a GIGANTIC Dragon around should the Vietcongs dare touch Taiping island. PLAN will blow them up sending them sky high before becoming fish food
 
.
Vietnam has an OK navy, but besides the Kilo subs, I don't see how Vietnam's equipments are any better than Taiwan's equipments. Sure the recently purchased Perry Frigates are old, but they are proven and reliable. Vietnam's navy consists of mainly missile boats from Russia, nothing in the 3-4 ton range of the Perry class.

Also, considering how Taiwan has 3 times the economy of Vietnam, they can certainly outspend their Vietnamese counterpart.

Also, it is not always about the equipments, it is also about the skills of the naval officers, tactics, and bravery. The Cultural Revolution devastated PRC manage to annihilate the far superior Vietnamese navy in Parcel islands with a few old rusty fast attack crafts in 1974 for example.
 
.
It's not important whether Taiwan Navy can beat VN or not. There's ALWAYS a GIGANTIC Dragon around should the Vietcongs dare touch Taiping island. PLAN will blow them up sending them sky high before becoming fish food

Yep, just forget about Taiwan, only China can protect the Taiping Island.
 
.
Itu Aba is island of Vietnam. we will take back in future. Occupation with force by Taiwan 1956 is illegal.
 
.
Yep, just forget about Taiwan, only China can protect the Taiping Island.
Seem like u r the only Chinese who can speak out the Truth. As I know, our frogmen dive aroud Itu-aba isl every week, and those TW troops dare not do any thing.

But I think that we wont attack Itu-aba, its just a waste, we cant defend Itu-aba now. We only can do something if we successfully unify sub-Mekong region, If we can not unify sub-Mekong region, then the only thing VN can do in SCS(east sea) is to keep defending the rocks under our control.:pop:
 
. . .
Don't expect too much from those Taiwanese coward army.

When the KMT had the German equipment, yet they still lost against Imperial Japan's third class land army.


while i dint dispute your other claims/comments. I disagree about the bold part. Japan's army wasnt a 'third class land Army'.lol Japan sent one of its best trained soldiers/army in its war/Invasion of China. Moreover Imperial Japan back then had one of the largest/best equipped/adavanced/trained army in the world. They are still the only country(after us obviously) to have launch an attack on U.S soil itself, they also invaded almost all of Asia in a matter of months. They even invaded/defeated some of our soldiers in our colonial terriroties in Asia like Singapore, Malaysia etc. They also initially defeated even the U.S in philippines and successful captured ruled the philippines for over a year before the U.S was able to regroup itself well and launch a renewed attack/inavasion of philippines from Japan. So calling Japan a third class army is rather laughable to be honest.

The KMT by all means wasnt that bad at all, they defended/fought the Japanese in the battle of Shanghai for over 6 months, though they were ill equipped compared to Mighty Japan who had a formidable Naval fleet bombarding shanghai from the sea with land/air assault, all which the KMT lack(or even when they had 1, it was in small numbers). Also Japan suffered its highest casualty during the war, not from the U.S,Russia,Britain , but in China, where over 50% of their death was in China fighting mainly against the official KMT government. And Japan never suceeded in invading the whole China in its over 9 year war with the KMT government., they could only invade/rule the coastal regions(meanwhile they had basically overan almost the whole of Asia in just under a year.lol). So calling the KMT coward/useless during the 2nd world war, while praising your CCP(obviously.lol), is funny. I know the CCP never acknowledges their rival KMT contribution during the war(which i think its normal, since they want to take all the glory for it, even though they played little or no role against japan back then.lol) against Japan, but that doesnt means you should believe all what they say(which is a lie by the way).:chilli:

So we should learn to put things into perspective. I admire imperial Japan's(just like Nazi Germany) past military prowess by the way(not their actions though).:D @Nihonjin1051 :cheers:

believe me, we can take the ROC island in the SC Sea before breakfast.

Well im not sure Vietnam can defeat Taiwan in any Naval confrontation in SCS. Its true Vietnam has potent missiles it purchased from Russia, plus the 6 kilos subs Vietnam has pruchased from Russia(2 already delivered), all of which Taiwan lacks. But Taiwan has a more advanced surface fleet/industrial base than Vietnam which means it can sustain a prolong naval war much more than Vietnam. So i think in a short naval confrontation, Vietnam might win, but in any long term/prolong naval confrontation hmmmmmm........not so sure. Though that reamains to be seen as well.:D
 
Last edited:
.
The KMT by all means wasnt that bad at all, they defended/fought the Japanese in the battle of Shanghai for over 6 months, though they were ill equipped compared to Mighty Japan who had a formidable Naval fleet bombarding shanghai from the sea with land/air assault, all which the KMT lack(or even when they had 1, it was in small numbers). Also Japan suffered its highest casualty during the war, not from the U.S,Russia,Britain , but in China, where over 50% of their death was in China fighting mainly against the official KMT government. And Japan never suceeded in invading the whole China in its over 9 year war with the KMT government., they could only invade/rule the coastal regions(meanwhile they had basically overan almost the whole of Asia in just under a year.lol). So calling the KMT coward/useless during the 2nd world war, while praising your CCP(obviously.lol), is funny. I know the CCP never acknowledges their rival KMT contribution during the war(which i think its normal, since they want to take all the glory for it, even though they played little or no role against japan back then.lol) against Japan, but that doesnt means you should
I agree KMT did their part. but CCP does acknowledges their rival KMT contribution during the war, though they definitely put more emphasis on themselves (which is natural)
 
.
Back
Top Bottom