Very smart move by Indian Judiciary

[k_arura]

Polygamy not integral part of Islam: SC - The Times of India

Don't let these folks hide behind religious law while it is nothing but a subversive practice to change the demography of India. Smart to label it as personal rather than religious which will just get them worked up!

 

[Ryuzaki]

time for uniform civil code.Scrap muslim personal law

 

[Dandpatta]

UCC (Uniform Civil Code) is never going to happen in India - at least until and unless a majority of India's largest minority religion has modern education as its core belief. Try UCC implementation and you will see India burning. Not at least in the next 50 years...

 

[Jobless Jack]

ok tell me if a man wants to marry a second wife with his wifes permisson what problem does the judge have as long as he can look after them bth ?

UCC (Uniform Civil Code) is never going to happen in India - at least until and unless a majority of India's largest minority religion has modern education as its core belief. Try UCC implementation and you will see India burning. Not at least in the next 50 years...

modern eudcation ? as its core belief ?

are you trying to say muslims should leave islam and turn athiest?


do you even know why and when 4 wives are allowed in islam ?

 

[chhota bheem]

ok tell me if a man wants to marry a second wife with his wifes permisson what problem does the judge have as long as he can look after them bth ?

What if its the otherway around ,if a women can take care of two men or more ,why cant she have more than one husband at a time.the point is not if he can freed them or shelter them,the point is if a man cannt accept his wife to have another or more husbands along with him(that hurts his ego,you see),how can one say wife are happy to accept or share her husband with another women.

modern eudcation ? as its core belief ?

are you trying to say muslims should leave islam and turn athiest?


do you even know why and when 4 wives are allowed in islam ?

To be frank, it has nothing to do with religion.

 

[Yahoooooo!]

modern eudcation ? as its core belief ?
are you trying to say muslims should leave islam and turn athiest?

Religious laws are based on religions established thousands of years back unlike the Modern laws. Hence, modern education as core belief means, Separation of "Any/Religion" and State/Government laws based on modern scientific knowledge.

do you even know why and when 4 wives are allowed in islam ?

Educate us.

 

[third eye]

I like these lines what the SC has ruled :

"the Supreme Court on Monday ruled that a Muslim's fundamental right to profess Islam did not include practicing polygamy.

"What was protected under Article 25 (right to practice and propagate any religion) was the religious faith and not a practice which may run counter to public order, health or morality

The bench said that polygamy was not integral to religion and the practice of polygamy did not acquire sanction of religion simply because it was permitted. "

 

[Soumitra]

ok tell me if a man wants to marry a second wife with his wifes permisson what problem does the judge have as long as he can look after them bth ?

Will you accept sharing your wife with someone else? Why should boys have all the fun? Even your wife may have need for being with two or more men

 

[Abingdonboy]

Man you should see what happens here in the UK with these polygamists, they are truly milking the system....

 

[xyxmt]

Polygamy not integral part of Islam: SC - The Times of India

Don't let these folks hide behind religious law while it is nothing but a subversive practice to change the demography of India. Smart to label it as personal rather than religious which will just get them worked up!

in 100 years Islam will be majority religion in India, they just have to work overtime

 

[third eye]

in 100 years Islam will be majority religion in India, they just have to work overtime

This attitude is at the root of the problem,

Instead of taking a lead through contributions towards all round &all inclusive improvement Islamists want to overwhelm through numbers.

Quantity matters little when compared to quality.

 

[CMYX4BJ]

Don't let these folks hide behind religious law while it is nothing but a subversive practice to change the demography of India. Smart to label it as personal rather than religious which will just get them worked up!

How would it make any difference to demographics?Polygamy is obviously wrong but makes no difference to demographics. If a muslim guy marries 4 wives , that would result in 3 muslim guys who are not going to get married ever.

 

[indiatester]

in 100 years Islam will be majority religion in India, they just have to work overtime

Good god. Hasn't this been tried for over a 1000 years according to you folks? Or have you gotten better recently.

 

[Jobless Jack]

Will you accept sharing your wife with someone else? Why should boys have all the fun? Even your wife may have need for being with two or more men

ah but your reply has nothing to do with my question my trolling friend.

 

[xyxmt]

Good god. Hasn't this been tried for over a 1000 years according to you folks? Or have you gotten better recently.

my folks are not 1.2 billion in numbers!