jhungary
MILITARY PROFESSIONAL
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2012
- Messages
- 19,295
- Reaction score
- 387
- Country
- Location
So, y'all ready for round 2?
This time, I am going to have to limit the scope a bit, I will format the detail in a more detail scene, and please noted that for this moment, I will be taking as a role of the crime scene investigator, and you are a detective, you can ask me anything you want about the scene and I will tell you (According to the actual case) what I know and what I don't know, but I will not be making any speculation. At the end of this case detail, you are to submit a report for indictment out of the possible suspect and what kind of charge you think you can get for your suspect.
This case will be a bit harder to get solved, unlike last time, because all the suspect have motive, mean and opportunities, it's up to you to find out who is the true killer. As usual, I will be posting the actual case detail in 5 days (7 days is too much I guess) so we can have a debate within that 5 days and everyone can post their theory and who did it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Small Town Murder.
On an autumn day in Long Island Sound. Shop worker Vivian failed to show up for her shift, the other workers growth worried and asked the duty supervisor to go up to her apartment to check her out, make sure she was okay. But when the duty supervisor arrived on Vivian Apartment, what he found is a gruesome crime scene
The Victim - Vivian
Vivian was a 29 years old woman, after serving in the Military, Vivian had came to this small town to enjoy the small town atmosphere, she live near the shop she works, have a good relationship to the neighbour and her work mate, she is a carefree, outgoing person with a love of nature.
She was killed by multiple blunt force trauma to her heads, murder weapon is the fire extinguisher found near her body.
The Crime Scene
The Crime Scene is Vivian apartment, on the second floor, she laid dead face down near the sofa, next to her on either side is a fire extinguisher and a broken jewellery box, a bit further laid 2 house hold gloves, used and discarded inside out with fingertip folded into the gloves, the origin of the gloves is unknown, could be belong to the household, or could be brought in by the killer or killers.
The scene have minimal struggle, beside a few thing displaced on the coffee table next to Vivian (possibly when she felt and disrupted the setting) the scene is otherwise tidy, there is a clear sign of break in, with the window being open and broken inside, indicated someone went thru the window.
The Investigation
The investigation started almost immediately after the discovery of Vivian death, time of death is determined to be between 11 pm the night before to 3 am that morning. There is one single latent print discovered by the bedside, belong to the victim, and there were blood that was on the window that was open (allegedly broke in). Blood Sample was NOT collected.
The window was open, and the ledge was broken from the outside, a clear sign of break in.
When interviewing the co-worker and friend of the deceased, the investigation found out that the victim was recently broke up with a casual boyfriend, whom was married, and before that, the victim was in a turbulence relationship with another man, which did not end the relationship on a good term.
There are no physical and forensic evidence collected on the scene which can be definitely link to any involvement.
The Evidence
The evidence collected on the scene included;
1.) The Fire Extinguisher collected from the scene, no print can be lifted, and was belong to Vivian
2.) A Pair of Household Gloves, no prints, unclear of origin.
3.) An Unsent Letter send to the boyfriend at that time, detailing the affair and the mind of don't want to have the affair end.
4.) A Police Report lodged by the victim a few weeks before her death, detailing a harassment of the old boy friend.
The Suspect
After the initial investigation concluded. There are 3 possible suspects on this case using the MMO (Means, Motives and Opportunities Model).
Suspect 1 - Rachel
Rachel is the wife of Sam, which was the boyfriend who recently broken up with Vivian.
Motive : Jealousy, possibility of knowing the affair between Vivian and her Husband.
Means : Being bludgeon to death with a fire extinguisher, it's something Rachel can possibly have access to and it's within Rachel mean to be able to do it.
Opportunities : On the night of the murder, Rachel and her Husband were attending a Police Bash (party) however, Rachel left Early at around 10 pm, and she claim she went home afterward, and claim to be with her husband at home (which turn out to be false, read below.)
Side Note : Was not asked nor took a Polygraph test, she is about 5 ft 10, slight/medium build.
Suspect 2 - Sam
Sam was 26 at the time of Murder, a serving Policeman, a detective of the local police department. He had been involved in a affair with Vivian about a month before the murder, he broke up with Vivian just a few days prior to the murder.
Motive : Killing Vivian to hide the Affair or end the affair from his wife.
Means : Being a Police Detective, he is strong enough and knowledgeable enough to commit this murder without leaving any trace of evidence. He also know the layout of Vivian apartment as he has been involve in an relationship with Vivian before.
Opportunities : He, along with his wife, Rachel was attending a party by the department the night of murder, he was observed a short argument with his wife Rachel before Rachel departed the party alone, Sam left approximately 1 hour later with his brother, who drop him off at home afterward, however, unlike what his wife (Rachel) testimony claim, he did not stay home and went back to the party at about 1am, witness at the party claim Sam seems shocked on return to the party.
Side Note : He Offered and Took a Polygraph Test, and he passed the Polygraph.
Suspect 3 - Tommy
Tommy, was 31 at that time of murder, work as a carpenter, was the former on and off boyfriend of Vivian, broken up with her approximately 2 to 3 months before her death, he broke up with her when one day she show up to his work place unannounced.
Tommy have been and still affected by the break up, and was trying to patch thing up with her even when she was dating Sam.
Motive : Jealousy, unable to let go and accept Vivian have moved on with her new boyfriend, obsessed with her and killed her.
Means : Being a former lover, he knows Vivian's living place and know her routine, he is in his prime so he would not have any problem committing the crime and overpower Vivian.
Opportunities : Largely unaccountable, Tommy claim he was drunk, and last at a bar til midnight, then gone straight back home. His whereabouts cannot be and did not be collaborated with anyone during the time of murder.
Side Note : Upon interviewing Vivian's friend, they testified that Tommy is a "Sticky" boyfriend, and would not let go of the break up (even thought it was him who broke off with Vivian) Vivian at one point call the Police station and lodge a report about her ex-boyfriend harassing her by calling her on the phone, the police department dispatched (or rather Vivian requested) Sam to attend the scene, and hence starting the extra-martial relationship.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please refer to the notes and give me your opinion. Please states what kind of crime would you be able to proof (beside actually proofing it) if you can indict any of the above suspect.
Time, People and Location was changed to preserve integrity of the case, I will reveal the case in 5 days (Oct 4) so, please stay tune, in the mean time, please put in your thought(s)
Thank You
This time, I am going to have to limit the scope a bit, I will format the detail in a more detail scene, and please noted that for this moment, I will be taking as a role of the crime scene investigator, and you are a detective, you can ask me anything you want about the scene and I will tell you (According to the actual case) what I know and what I don't know, but I will not be making any speculation. At the end of this case detail, you are to submit a report for indictment out of the possible suspect and what kind of charge you think you can get for your suspect.
This case will be a bit harder to get solved, unlike last time, because all the suspect have motive, mean and opportunities, it's up to you to find out who is the true killer. As usual, I will be posting the actual case detail in 5 days (7 days is too much I guess) so we can have a debate within that 5 days and everyone can post their theory and who did it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Small Town Murder.
On an autumn day in Long Island Sound. Shop worker Vivian failed to show up for her shift, the other workers growth worried and asked the duty supervisor to go up to her apartment to check her out, make sure she was okay. But when the duty supervisor arrived on Vivian Apartment, what he found is a gruesome crime scene
The Victim - Vivian
Vivian was a 29 years old woman, after serving in the Military, Vivian had came to this small town to enjoy the small town atmosphere, she live near the shop she works, have a good relationship to the neighbour and her work mate, she is a carefree, outgoing person with a love of nature.
She was killed by multiple blunt force trauma to her heads, murder weapon is the fire extinguisher found near her body.
The Crime Scene
The Crime Scene is Vivian apartment, on the second floor, she laid dead face down near the sofa, next to her on either side is a fire extinguisher and a broken jewellery box, a bit further laid 2 house hold gloves, used and discarded inside out with fingertip folded into the gloves, the origin of the gloves is unknown, could be belong to the household, or could be brought in by the killer or killers.
The scene have minimal struggle, beside a few thing displaced on the coffee table next to Vivian (possibly when she felt and disrupted the setting) the scene is otherwise tidy, there is a clear sign of break in, with the window being open and broken inside, indicated someone went thru the window.
The Investigation
The investigation started almost immediately after the discovery of Vivian death, time of death is determined to be between 11 pm the night before to 3 am that morning. There is one single latent print discovered by the bedside, belong to the victim, and there were blood that was on the window that was open (allegedly broke in). Blood Sample was NOT collected.
The window was open, and the ledge was broken from the outside, a clear sign of break in.
When interviewing the co-worker and friend of the deceased, the investigation found out that the victim was recently broke up with a casual boyfriend, whom was married, and before that, the victim was in a turbulence relationship with another man, which did not end the relationship on a good term.
There are no physical and forensic evidence collected on the scene which can be definitely link to any involvement.
The Evidence
The evidence collected on the scene included;
1.) The Fire Extinguisher collected from the scene, no print can be lifted, and was belong to Vivian
2.) A Pair of Household Gloves, no prints, unclear of origin.
3.) An Unsent Letter send to the boyfriend at that time, detailing the affair and the mind of don't want to have the affair end.
4.) A Police Report lodged by the victim a few weeks before her death, detailing a harassment of the old boy friend.
The Suspect
After the initial investigation concluded. There are 3 possible suspects on this case using the MMO (Means, Motives and Opportunities Model).
Suspect 1 - Rachel
Rachel is the wife of Sam, which was the boyfriend who recently broken up with Vivian.
Motive : Jealousy, possibility of knowing the affair between Vivian and her Husband.
Means : Being bludgeon to death with a fire extinguisher, it's something Rachel can possibly have access to and it's within Rachel mean to be able to do it.
Opportunities : On the night of the murder, Rachel and her Husband were attending a Police Bash (party) however, Rachel left Early at around 10 pm, and she claim she went home afterward, and claim to be with her husband at home (which turn out to be false, read below.)
Side Note : Was not asked nor took a Polygraph test, she is about 5 ft 10, slight/medium build.
Suspect 2 - Sam
Sam was 26 at the time of Murder, a serving Policeman, a detective of the local police department. He had been involved in a affair with Vivian about a month before the murder, he broke up with Vivian just a few days prior to the murder.
Motive : Killing Vivian to hide the Affair or end the affair from his wife.
Means : Being a Police Detective, he is strong enough and knowledgeable enough to commit this murder without leaving any trace of evidence. He also know the layout of Vivian apartment as he has been involve in an relationship with Vivian before.
Opportunities : He, along with his wife, Rachel was attending a party by the department the night of murder, he was observed a short argument with his wife Rachel before Rachel departed the party alone, Sam left approximately 1 hour later with his brother, who drop him off at home afterward, however, unlike what his wife (Rachel) testimony claim, he did not stay home and went back to the party at about 1am, witness at the party claim Sam seems shocked on return to the party.
Side Note : He Offered and Took a Polygraph Test, and he passed the Polygraph.
Suspect 3 - Tommy
Tommy, was 31 at that time of murder, work as a carpenter, was the former on and off boyfriend of Vivian, broken up with her approximately 2 to 3 months before her death, he broke up with her when one day she show up to his work place unannounced.
Tommy have been and still affected by the break up, and was trying to patch thing up with her even when she was dating Sam.
Motive : Jealousy, unable to let go and accept Vivian have moved on with her new boyfriend, obsessed with her and killed her.
Means : Being a former lover, he knows Vivian's living place and know her routine, he is in his prime so he would not have any problem committing the crime and overpower Vivian.
Opportunities : Largely unaccountable, Tommy claim he was drunk, and last at a bar til midnight, then gone straight back home. His whereabouts cannot be and did not be collaborated with anyone during the time of murder.
Side Note : Upon interviewing Vivian's friend, they testified that Tommy is a "Sticky" boyfriend, and would not let go of the break up (even thought it was him who broke off with Vivian) Vivian at one point call the Police station and lodge a report about her ex-boyfriend harassing her by calling her on the phone, the police department dispatched (or rather Vivian requested) Sam to attend the scene, and hence starting the extra-martial relationship.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please refer to the notes and give me your opinion. Please states what kind of crime would you be able to proof (beside actually proofing it) if you can indict any of the above suspect.
Time, People and Location was changed to preserve integrity of the case, I will reveal the case in 5 days (Oct 4) so, please stay tune, in the mean time, please put in your thought(s)
Thank You
