What's new

Triple Talaq bill passed by Parliament

Soumitra

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jan 11, 2011
Messages
8,415
Reaction score
-17
Country
India
Location
India
The contentious bill to ban 'Triple Talaq', which failed the the Rajya Sabha test last time, sailed through the opposition-dominated upper house today aided by a series of walkouts and abstentions. The bill, which sought to end the practice of Muslim men instantly divorcing their wives by uttering "talaq" thrice, saw stiff opposition when it was presented in the Lok Sabha. But several of the parties that opposed it - including Nitish Kumar's Janata Dal United, AIADMK and K Chandrashekar Rao's Telangana Rashtra Samithi -- ended up aiding the bill's passage.

While the AIADMK and Nitish Kumar's party walked out, the Telangana Rashtra Samithi and Mehbooba Mufti's PDP abstained from voting, bringing down the majority mark.

A number of opposition lawmakers also gave the vote a miss. The list of absentees included Sharad Pawar and Praful Patel of the NCP, five lawmakers from the Congress, six from the Samajwadi Party, four from Mayawati's Bahujan Samaj Party, two from Trinamool Congress, and one each from Lalu Yadav's Rashtruya Janata Dal and MK Stalin's DMK.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi, after the bill was passed in Rajya Sabha, tweeted that it was a victory of gender justice.

"An archaic and medieval practice has finally been confined to the dustbin of history! Parliament abolishes Triple Talaq and corrects a historical wrong done to Muslim women. This is a victory of gender justice and will further equality in society. India rejoices today!" PM Modi tweeted.

The bill was passed, with 99 votes in its favour and 84 against. Law minister Ravi Shankar Prasad, who tabled the bill, said, "Today is a historic day. Both the Houses have given justice to the Muslim women. This is the beginning of a transforming India".

The smooth passage of a second contentious bill within a week marked a change in the government's fortunes in the upper house, where it lacks numbers.


Last week, the controversial amendment to the landmark Right to Information Act also made it through the upper house, with the help of non-aligned parties that give issue-based support -- the TRS, Naveen Patnaik's Biju Janata Dal and the YSR Congress of Jaganmohan Reddy.

The TRS and Biju Janata Dal, which were opposing the bill, changed their mind after calls from Prime Minister Narendra Modi and BJP chief Amit Shah.

Last evening, PM Modi had dialled Nitish Kumar to discuss the flood situation in Bihar. Despite being a BJP ally, Mr Kumar's Janata Dal United has made no secret of its opposition to the Triple Talaq bill. During its passage in the Lok Sabha last week, the party said the proposed law will "create a lack of trust in society".

AIADMK lawmaker Navneet Krishna told NDTV: "We walked out of Rajya Sabha because the government did not accept our demand to send the Triple Talaq Bill to a Select Committee... We believe that parliament does not have the legislative competency to make such a law. It will not withstand judicial scrutiny."

The opposition parties had demanded that the bill be sent to a select committee for further deliberation and scrutiny. They were against the provision for a three-year jail term for erring husbands and claimed that the proposed law will be misused to victimise Muslims.

The government maintained that the Triple Talaq bill was a step towards ensuring gender equality and justice and that the opposition parties were politicising the issue.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/bil...-sabha-in-big-win-for-modi-government-2077719
 
. . . .
Progressive India.

Welcomed move by Terror Mata
Yes this is a regressive law and we are glad that it has been struck off. Der aaye, durust aaye.

BTW did you know we are behind Pakistan in banning this. The only reason it was not abolished so far was that "secular" parties did not want to lose their vote bank.
 
. . . . .
Instant Tripple Talaq is outlawed in Pakistan right?

Yes.

Tripple Talaq is anti-Islamic because the traditional method of Talaq in Islamic law is completely different. Tripple Talaq is one of those idiotic South Asian practice that pollutes proper Islam.

Having said that, criminalizing Muslim men while letting others go is hatred of Muslims. Why is this not addressed?

Tripple talaq ban is welcome but why discrimination?

Btw, legally practice is not recognized but many Pakistanis do it because you know....South Asia :angel:
 
.
Having said that, criminalizing Muslim men while letting others go is hatred of Muslims. Why is this not addressed?
Who are those others? This is practiced only in one community, for others divorce proceedings are done through court. After divorce the husband should pay alimony if the women do not remarry.

Because Muslim are seen as a vote bank the Congress made a law that denied Muslim women alimony. Basically if the husband divorce her she's without any support and have to rely on her parents if they're alive or remarry. All these don't go on records either.

Tripple talaq ban is welcome but why discrimination?
:DOthers go through a great ordeal to get a divorced, you have no idea how long this divorce proceedings go for others. Meanwhile, Muslim men in India divorce through whatsapp from gulf, or just say the three words when they can't take it anymore are lucky they didn't have any consequence.

Now tell me where is the discrimination? Pampering of Muslims by political parties made the life of Muslim hell. Which is one reason why BJP is in power. Wonder why BJP gained a lot of votes from Muslim majority areas?

Btw, legally practice is not recognized but many Pakistanis do it because you know....South Asia :angel:
Then enforce it. You're a Muslim majority nation, so you don't have to worry about "vote banks".
 
.
Having said that, criminalizing Muslim men while letting others go is hatred of Muslims. Why is this not addressed?

Tripple talaq ban is welcome but why discrimination?
There is no discrimination. In other communities, divorce is given via courts. Here, just saying talak talak talak makes men believe that they are free now. Divorces were being given on whatsapp for godsakes.
Congress is saying that its a civil matter then why jail? Well guess what, dowry is also a civil matter. Calling someone from less fortunate community by his/her caste is also a civil matter. All 3 of these are social ills and all 3 will have criminal punishment.
now they are saying that muslim men are being singled out.
Can u tell me an instance where hindu, christian or sikh gave triple talakh?
Yes there are cases where husbands abandon their wives, but the wives go to the court and get alimony and other benefits. Did muslim women had these rights? Men would simply claim that this is divorce as per Islam!
 
. .
Instead of banning polygamy, why don't they make it legal for other religions also besides Islam ? I would love me some polygamy babyyyy... yeah.

True, but why only Polygamy ? why not Polyandry ?

i.e. One women having multiple husbands.
 
.
Who are those others? This is practiced only in one community, for others divorce proceedings are done through court. After divorce the husband should pay alimony if the women do not remarry.
For others, they can just dump their wives like our very own Prime minister. Infact they vastly outnumber the triple talaaq victims..

Abandoned women vastly outnumber victims of Triple Talaq; it's time Modi spoke up for them

Source: https://www.business-standard.com/a...me-modi-spoke-up-for-them-116121300251_1.html

Because Muslim are seen as a vote bank the Congress made a law that denied Muslim women alimony. Basically if the husband divorce her she's without any support and have to rely on her parents if they're alive or remarry. All these don't go on records either.
So muslims are seen as votebank by Congress, Are muslim women not part of muslim community which is supposedly a vote bank for congress? Anyways for your info, muslim women who are divorced do get alimony in the form of Meher along with maintenance of women during iddat period.

:DOthers go through a great ordeal to get a divorced, you have no idea how long this divorce proceedings go for others. Meanwhile, Muslim men in India divorce through whatsapp from gulf, or just say the three words when they can't take it anymore are lucky they didn't have any consequence.
A minuscule percentage of talaaqs are done instantly while majority of them follow a process of iddat period of 3 months with multiple meetings for reconciliation. Women can also take divorce in a similar way and is called khula.

Now tell me where is the discrimination? Pampering of Muslims by political parties made the life of Muslim hell. Which is one reason why BJP is in power. Wonder why BJP gained a lot of votes from Muslim majority areas?
Pampering of muslims by political parties??? LOL they are so pampered that they languish at the bottom of development indices in India while the poor discriminated hindus disproportionately occupy almost all positions of power be it Police, Politics, Armed Forces, Bureaucracy etc
 
.
Back
Top Bottom