"TINDERBOX-The Past And Future Of Pakistan" - Book by M.J Akbar

[WAR-rior]

A very interesting and thought provoking discussion. A gem of an argument by some real quality, rational and exquisite minds. A great piece, especially for those who think and introspect.

PS : Request the posters to listen to whole video and then comment. Its better to have a quantified discussion rather than typical rhetorics of PDF.

 

[jaunty]

Mani Shankar must be playing the role of the Pakistani representative in the panel.

 

[jaunty]

BTW there are plenty of videos of Mr. Akbar about this book on youtube.

 

[WAR-rior]

Mani Shankar must be playing the role of the Pakistani representative in the panel.

Its not bout representative. He has his soft corner for Pakistan coz he visit there often and have them for some really right reasons.

But whole discussion is so filled with rationalism than typical jingoism and factless rhetoric we see often in Indo-Pak topics on both sides of the border.

 

[WAR-rior]

BTW there are plenty of videos of Mr. Akbar about this book on youtube.

Well. Think u are talking bout the other book TINDERBOX : India and its Neighbours.

Its a series of books written in detail with utmost rationalism and ground facts.

 

[jaunty]

Think u are talking bout the other book TINDERBOX : India and its Neighbours.

There is no such book.

 

[WAR-rior]

There is no such book.

OK. Seems I misunderstood the TV show title with the book.

 

[WAR-rior]

Reviews of the book.

M J AKBAR : Books by M J Akbar: Tinderbox:The Past and Future of Pakistan
by M J Akbar

 

[Rafi]

Again a book - tempered by indian bias, all in all - very rare to have an objective analysis.

 

[WAR-rior]

Again a book - tempered by indian bias, all in all - very rare to have an objective analysis.

Really? Nobody in here, pro or anti Pakistan, did see any bias here. Everything here is written with respect to the current situation in Pakistan.

No Pakistani has till date cared to explain certain recent incidents in Pakistan and the ideas behind them. But instead decided to turn a blind eye, decided not to talk bout it, decided to dump their heads in sand like an ostrich.

Anyways. Be it pro Congress of pro BJP, Congressi himself or a BJP guy. Nobody in India simply rejects what M.J Akbar says. Simply for his track record over the decades. He is the biggest name in Journalism till date. Go check his biodata.

 

[SQ8]

Really? Nobody in here, pro or anti Pakistan, did see any bias here. Everything here is written with respect to the current situation in Pakistan.

No Pakistani has till date cared to explain certain recent incidents in Pakistan and the ideas behind them. But instead decided to turn a blind eye, decided not to talk bout it, decided to dump their heads in sand like an ostrich.

Anyways. Be it pro Congress of pro BJP, Congressi himself or a BJP guy. Nobody in India simply rejects what M.J Akbar says. Simply for his track record over the decades. He is the biggest name in Journalism till date. Go check his biodata.

This video and others like have been reviewed and dismissed for their obvious misinformation and bias much before. THREAD CLOSED.