Time to Hang Sarbajit Singh ?

[Spring Onion]

If sarabjit is proven guilty in your present judiciary system (after being given a fair chance to defend himself like Kasab got) hang him.No problem at all.

Already proven guilty in court of law sentenced to death. So its time to excecute the sentence. Though i dont favour this moment for the execution but he should have been hanged many years back and even now its not too late. Just hang him in the start of new year.

This Indian terrorist should go to hell for killing Pakistanis.

 

[RazPaK]

What is terrorism?

You fools. A uniform does not make a difference.

 

[INDIC]

That is because he wasn't booked for terrorism and served his sentence but yet your Govt wasn't releasing him !

Your corrupt police bought fake witness against Sarabjit, the witness never ever seen Sarabjeet, the witness himself claimed it.

 

[Abhishek_]

Already proven guilty in court of law sentenced to death. So its time to excecute the sentence. Though i dont favour this moment for the execution but he should have been hanged many years back and even now its not too late. Just hang him in the start of new year.

This Indian terrorist should go to hell for killing Pakistanis.

no issues there.

 

[Spring Onion]

If he is found guilty by Pakistan's Court then hang him. Hang him for his crimes, not because for tit for tat.

I think Pakistan should wait for few weeks for Kasab smoke to clear so that these issues of Tit for Tat doesn't come into play.

Hanging him now will raise many questions especially from families of victims of those attacks, why hang him now not for past 23 years ? Isn't it wrong that justice was delayed for so long and hanging him because India hanged Kasab.

To avoid such doubts, I think Pakistan should hang him after some time. You waited for 23 years, why not wait for few weeks.

Actually some people are implying such tactics to make it look like tit for tat thats why you will see many coming up with provocative ideas at the moment so that this Indian terrorist get some sympathy.

He should had been hanged much before. anyway i agree with your points. he should be hanged in Feb 2013.

 

[third eye]

I do not see the problem.

If pak wants or wanted to hang Sarabjit, what are they waiting for ?

Is he being kept as a bait or bargaining chip ?

What does Pak want to do ? If it is intended to hang him - go ahead.

Kasab was hung without ref to Pak after due legal process. Why does not Pak do the same ?

 

[Secur]

Your corrupt police bought fake witness against Sarabjit, the witness never ever seen Sarabjeet, the witness himself claimed it.

What about his confession and the sentence of death by the court of law ? What about the confirmation of Sarabjeet's guilt by the agent Surjeet who used to work with him but was released on a good will gesture ?

 

[KRAIT]

Actually some people are implying such tactics to make it look like tit for tat thats why you will see many coming up with provocative ideas at the moment so that this Indian terrorist get some sympathy.

He should had been hanged much before. anyway i agree with your points. he should be hanged in Feb 2013.

We all know a lot of politics will be done over this issue too. People will use Kasab hanging in India for political purpose whereas Pakistani politicians will also use Sarabhjeet case as elections are approaching.

Many people in India who used to lament UPA govt are suddenly appreciating that at least this govt. did something good. Point is we people shouldn't get mixed up with the hanging of terrorists and political environment especially in election years.

 

[Bang Galore]

Sarabjit Singh blew bombs in 1990s' in Pakistan killing many Pakistanis whereas Mumbai attacks took place in 2008 if we go by tit for tat policy assumption then you can say Kasab action was a tit for tat not execution of Sarabjit.

If that is the case & you are convinced by it, you can go ahead & hang him. Actually, you have no other logical option but to do that. The case against his conviction is that it seems to be one of wrong identity. If proved otherwise or if you believe that he is guilty, your government should have no business negotiating anything. Negotiations are only possible & makes sense if your government thinks that there is something wrong on the conviction itself, not otherwise.

No one in India is asking for a release of a man who committed acts of terrorism. If you believe that he is wrongly convicted because of mistaken identity, consider a release, if otherwise, do with him as you will.

Stop trying to draw moral equivalence with the Kasab case . No such parity exists.

 

[scorpionx]

We all know a lot of politics will be done over this issue too. People will use Kasab hanging in India for political purpose whereas Pakistani politicians will also use Sarabhjeet case as elections are approaching.

Many people in India who used to lament UPA govt are suddenly appreciating that at least this govt. did something good. Point is we people shouldn't get mixed up with the hanging of terrorists and political environment especially in election years.

Completely agreed. It was a clever tactical maneuver from Pranab Mukherjee.The timing was more than perfect.

 

[Spring Onion]

We all know a lot of politics will be done over this issue too. People will use Kasab hanging in India for political purpose whereas Pakistani politicians will also use Sarabhjeet case as elections are approaching.

Many people in India who used to lament UPA govt are suddenly appreciating that at least this govt. did something good. Point is we people shouldn't get mixed up with the hanging of terrorists and political environment especially in election years.

Your comments about Indian politics are indeed correct whereas for the bold part in your post let me tell you something that here in Pakistan anything about India does not matter in our local politics.

At best only extremist groups can raise hue and cry over Sarabjit Singh linking it to Kasab and liberal extremists will use the opportunity to polish their agenda over the issue but at national political level here in Pakistan this has NOTHING to do coming elections

Here people vote for family politics and the remaining people who has no feelings for any political family either vote for money or facilities in their areas.

 

[Spring Onion]

If that is the case & you are convinced by it, you can go ahead & hang him. Actually, you have no other logical option but to do that. The case against his conviction is that it seems to be one of wrong identity. If proved otherwise or if you believe that he is guilty, your government should have no business negotiating anything. Negotiations are only possible & makes sense if your government thinks that there is something wrong on the conviction itself, not otherwise.

No one in India is asking for a release of a man who committed acts of terrorism. If you believe that he is wrongly convicted because of mistaken identity, consider a release, if otherwise, do with him as you will.

Stop trying to draw moral equivalence with the Kasab case . No such parity exists.

1. Its not case of mistaken idenity since surjeet who was an Indian spy was released by Pakistan and the media thought as if Sarabjit the terrorist was released so the mistaken idenity case was that. Its another thing that Liberal extremist NGOs came up with this new excuse to sound it like that.

2. Since the govt in place or any govt in Pakistan has the right to negotiate or otherwise under the parliamentry power hence it had been delaying (which is NOT liked by anyone of us).

3. The Indian Govt had been asking for release of terrorist Sarabjit Singh hence your claim that nobody is seeking his release is wrong.

 

[third eye]

We all know a lot of politics will be done over this issue too. People will use Kasab hanging in India for political purpose whereas Pakistani politicians will also use Sarabhjeet case as elections are approaching.

Many people in India who used to lament UPA govt are suddenly appreciating that at least this govt. did something good. Point is we people shouldn't get mixed up with the hanging of terrorists and political environment especially in election years.

Do you seriously consider hanging a terrorist to be a good act ?

It was simply the logical conclusion of a terrorist caught red handed.

Something that should not be made much of or taken credit of.

 

[Spring Onion]

Do you seriously consider hanging a terrorist to be a good act ?

It was simply the logical conclusion of a terrorist caught red handed.

Something that should not be made much of or taken credit of.

The Indian opposition is deprived of having this credit by Congress )))

 

[INDIC]

What about his confession and the sentence of death by the court of law ? What about the confirmation of Sarabjeet's guilt by the agent Surjeet who used to work with him but was released on a good will gesture ?

I don't know about surjeet but the main witness Shaukat Salim confessed that he was forced by Police to give false statement against Sarabjeet. How can you sentence him when the witness is false.