You were saying that Ummah is dead.
Wow! I did not know that Broken and Dead have the same meanings! Kindly quote my post saying 'Ummah is dead'!
What does this mean? Does this means that all 1.6 billion Muslims are sinful? I must say its a big leap of imagination, to declare whole of the Muslim world as sinful due to wrongdoings of few.
The statement I made is backed by Quran and Hadith. Those who
start bidaat and/or wrongful acts and their followers in those bidaat and wrongful acts are committing sins. Those who start or introduce these acts will bear the sins of their followers too! On the judgement day, the followers will ask for increase of punishment for their leaders/ancestors who started those acts - references to this shouldn't be too difficult for you to find, I hope.
Quran and Hadith translation are within easy access to everyone. As long as one is not illiterate, they should learn directly from. There is no excuse of 'I did not know this was a bidaat' etc, and 'my elders did this and I will continue to do this as well' ... your statement above sounds like justification of a follower. Next the typical excuse of 'where is it prohibited in Quran and Hadith' will come out ... but do try justifying 'chaleeswan' (40th) from Quran and Hadith without resorting to this excuse and one of ijema (of a sect)!
صحیح مسلم
کتاب: جمعہ کا بیان
باب: خطبہ جمعہ اور نماز جمعہ مختصر پڑھانے کے بیان میں
حدیث نمبر: 2005
ترجمہ:
محمد بن مثنی، عبدالوہاب بن عبدالمجید، جعفربن محمد، جابر بن عبداللہ سے روایت ہے کہ رسول اللہ ﷺ جب خطبہ ارشاد فرماتے تھے تو آپ ﷺ کی آنکھیں سرخ ہوجاتیں اور آپ ﷺ کی آواز بلند ہوجاتی اور غصہ شدید ہوجاتا (اور یوں معلوم ہوتا) گویا کہ آپ ﷺ کسی ایسے لشکر سے ڈرا رہے ہوں کہ وہ صبح یا شام حملہ کرنے والا ہے اور فرماتے ہیں کہ قیامت کو اور مجھے اس طرح بھیجا گیا جس طرح یہ دو انگلیاں اور شہادت والی اور درمیانی انگلی ملا کر فرماتے
اما بعد کہ بہترین بات اللہ کی کتاب ہے اور بہترین سیرت محمد ﷺ کی سیرت ہے اور سارے کاموں میں بدترین کام نئے نئے طریقے ہیں (یعنی دین کے نام سے نئے طریقے جاری کرنا) اور ہر بدعت گمراہی ہے پھر فرماتے ہیں کہ میں ہر مومن کو اس کی جان سے زیادہ عزیز ہوں جو مومن مال چھوڑ کر مرا وہ اس کے گھر والوں کے لئے ہے اور جو مومن قرض یا بچے چھوڑ جائے اس کی تر بیت و پرورش اور ان کے خرچ کی ذمہ داری مجھ محمد ﷺ پر ہے۔
Fixing home does not means that we should accept Israel like other traitors and help in their oppression. This will be ethically and morally wrong. It will also not give us any strategic benefit and will prove to be a political suicide for any government.
Israel matter is closed. No one here now is saying anymore that Israel should be accepted. Pakistan should raise the voice in support of all those being persecuted and play the peacemaker role.
Placing four Mussalas in Majid e Haram was not Ijma. I dont think anyone claimed that. This action of a regime and some individuals can not be acceptable, at all.
Kindly study history. Before the 4 mussalas were removed, it was claimed to be ijema as this wrong act was uninterrupted for hundreds of years, until the Saudis removed them. Given a choice today by Saudis, these 4 mussalas would be put back immediately (coming back to fissures)!
I am referring to Sunni majority. They are being taught in their textbooks of theology that they can offer prayer behind anyone. It is the accepted and recognized principle of Sunni Islam. If large number of individuals are not highlighting this fact then its their fault.
And a large number of sunni individuals/so-called ulema are NOT highlighting this, intentionally. Whichever sunni sect you belong to, please get a fatwa from your top so-called ulema that praying behind all sunni sects imams
and all sunni sects mosque is totally acceptable and valid.
He won't do that (& if he does, he will be thrown out of that sect). It will damage his sect's chanda collection shop! But do try and see how you are treated (don't expect tea and sweets though)!
