What's new

The problem with military fanpages on Facebook

Status
Not open for further replies.

Koovie

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
8,288
Reaction score
6
I have been following a couple of unofficial fanpages of the Indian Air Force, the Indian Army and the Indian Navy for some time now.

Those sites, mainly Indian Army Fans and Indian Air Force and some others, have well over 2 million followers by now.

https://www.facebook.com/ProudFans?fref=ts
https://www.facebook.com/IAFJaiHind?fref=ts
https://www.facebook.com/IndianArmyAirForceNavy?fref=ts

This might be a great thing on the first look.....
But in recent times you could notice that the admins of those pages are getting more and more politicized and are making no efforts to hide their anti government feelings/views.

Moreover, they even started to ban anyone who does not share their same opinion in the comments section.

For example, I read this on the Indian Air Force fanpage today:

The admin was crying about another fanpage that was accused by him of "stealing" pictures from his fanpage which are not even his own property....



-Status update by one of these admins:

"Dear 'Indian Army Fans' admin, if you take (steal) the photos from our page. Atleast show courtesy."


-Then the reply from a user:

"even if the admin steals pictures from your page, it shouldnt matter to you because you arent here on facebook to get likes or promote your posts. technically it isnt stealing because you dont have a patent do you. it would do us a world of good to just try and promote the forces instead of fighting for likes comments or shares" (got over 70 likes for that)



-The arrogant and childish reply from the IAF fanpage admin:

"Don't teach us what to do. We know better then you."



-After some more critical comments from others, the admin (obviously ********) wrote:

"All abusers ll be banned. Enjoy. Bye" and "We are the admins from first day. Don't teach us."







So my point of all this is:

What the heck are the PR guys of the MoD, IA, IAF and the IN doing? How can`t they notice all this?!

This behaviour of those FB fanpages is contradicting with two major principles of this country and hurting two major pillars of our democracy and constitution:

1.) Separation of power (Here: The non involvement of the military in to politics)
2.) Freedom of speech

All this would not be a big deal..... but if a page that calls itself "Indian Air Force" promotes all this, it does not reflect the stand of the military and might hurt its reputation since most people probably dont even know that these pages are created by fanboys.




So what are your views on this?
 
.
I have been following a couple of unofficial fanpages of the Indian Air Force, the Indian Army and the Indian Navy for some time now.

Those sites, mainly Indian Army Fans and Indian Air Force and some others, have well over 2 million followers by now.

https://www.facebook.com/ProudFans?fref=ts
https://www.facebook.com/IAFJaiHind?fref=ts
https://www.facebook.com/IndianArmyAirForceNavy?fref=ts

This might be a great thing on the first look.....
But in recent times you could notice that the admins of those pages are getting more and more politicized and are making no efforts to hide their anti government feelings/views.

Moreover, they even started to ban anyone who does not share their same opinion in the comments section.

For example, I read this on the Indian Air Force fanpage today:



-Status update by one of the admins:

"Dear 'Indian Army Fans' admin, if you take (steal) the photos from our page. Atleast show courtesy."


-Then the reply from a user:

"even if the admin steals pictures from your page, it shouldnt matter to you because you arent here on facebook to get likes or promote your posts. technically it isnt stealing because you dont have a patent do you. it would do us a world of good to just try and promote the forces instead of fighting for likes comments or shares" (got over 70 likes for that)



-The arrogant and childish reply from the IAF fanpage admin:

"Don't teach us what to do. We know better then you."



-After some more critical comments from others, the admin (obviously ********) wrote:

"All abusers ll be banned. Enjoy. Bye" and "We are the admins from first day. Don't teach us."







So my point of all this is:

What the heck are the PR guys of the MoD, IA, IAF and the IN doing? How can`t they notice all this?!

This behaviour of those FB fanpages is contradicting with two major principles of this country and hurting two major pillars of our democracy and constitution:

1.) Separation of power (Here: The non involvement of the military in to politics)
2.) Freedom of speech

All this would not be a big deal..... but if a page that calls itself "Indian Air Force" promotes all this, it does not reflect the stand of the military and might hurt its reputation since most people probably dont even know that these pages are created by fanboys.




So what are your views on this?

I agree the "admins" are some jingoistic fanboys who are just as ignorant to military matters as anyone off the street. Have you seen the cr@p they post not including the political BS.



I agree though that they often post some outrageous political messages that reflect their own views but given the medium is the Indian military FB page they are effectively speaking for the the Indian military. It's not ideal but as long as they don't claim their FB page is the "official" FB page of the Indian military then I guess its acceptable.
 
.
This Motherf###er...

http://www.facebook.com/thefewthefearless?fref=ts


..banned me just because i corrected him by saying that this pic is not of Marcos but Para SF.He saw that i belong to Jammu and Kashmir and called me a Pakistani and even made an update about me saying "Pakistanis get lost".

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This idiot doesnt know half the **** he is posting

http://www.facebook.com/ProudFans?fref=ts


These bloody college college students are less of patriots and more of haters.There is no fcking need to show your frustration in life with every news thats comming.

I have spent 20 yrs in Army cantonments and my patriotism cannot be judged by a bunch of fools running a stupid page even when i am correcting them for wrongly identifying a SF operator..20 saal Army area mein reh k machchar nahi mare mein.I know what i am talking about when i talk about the Indian Army.
 
.
This Motherf###er...

http://www.facebook.com/thefewthefearless?fref=ts


..banned me just because i corrected him by saying that this pic is not of Marcos but Para SF.He saw that i belong to Jammu and Kashmir and called me a Pakistani and even made an update about me saying "Pakistanis get lost".

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This idiot doesnt know half the **** he is posting

http://www.facebook.com/ProudFans?fref=ts


These bloody college college students are less of patriots and more of haters.There is no fcking need to show your frustration in life with every news thats comming.

I have spent 20 yrs in Army cantonments and my patriotism cannot be judged by a bunch of fools running a stupid page even when i am correcting them for wrongly identifying a SF operator..20 saal Army area mein reh k machchar nahi mare mein.I know what i am talking about when i talk about the Indian Army.

The MARCOS page is the most stupid page of all.... They also banned me because I said that the pics of some SF (Indonesian) were not Indian... :hitwall:
 
.
and yeah forgot to add...If the mod of these pages is having a look please take my every abuse seriously coz had i met you personally i would have kicked your ***.


BTW me and couple of my friends here are running the page...I hardly get time for facebook but they are managing it well.Kindly have a look and join if you guys like it.

http://www.facebook.com/INDIA.MILITARY?fref=ts
 
.
and yeah forgot to add...If the mod of these pages is having a look please take my every abuse seriously coz had i met you personally i would have kicked your ***.


BTW me and couple of my friends here are running the page...I hardly get time for facebook but they are managing it well.Kindly have a look and join if you guys like it.

http://www.facebook.com/INDIA.MILITARY?fref=ts

This one looks very nice ! :tup:

What a shame that these pages wont get millions of followers :hitwall:

And I am pretty damn sure that those retarded admins take a look at PDF and other defence forums.
They get the bulk of their pics from here.

And then they start accusing each other of "stealing" their content to get more likes....

Height of stupidity.
 
.
This one looks very nice ! :tup:

What a shame that these pages wont get millions of followers :hitwall:

And I am pretty damn sure that those retarded admins take a look at PDF and other defence forums.
They get the bulk of their pics from here.

And then they start accusing each other of "stealing" their content to get more likes....

Height of stupidity.

The Indian Army Fans page mod is selling ebay T shirts via his page these days...What a shame!
 
.
@OP You can always start a new fan page on Facebook, if you are committed to better governance of fanpages...

And please stop whining because some fool banned you from some foolish facebook page. You should not have joined in the first place... If you wanted genuine knowledge, Facebook was the last place to go.

Facebook "likes" don't matter much in real world.
Likes don't save lives - Vaccination - Unicef Commercial 2013 - YouTube
Thanks.
 
. .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom