What's new

The five men who put the Tricolour before themselves

Neuro

BANNED
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
784
Reaction score
-3
The five men who put the Tricolour before themselves, News - City - Mumbai Mirror

What does the national flag mean to you? Ponder that as you read this. As the fire raged on at the Mantralaya on Thursday, five Class IV workers refused to be rescued till the time they had lowered the Tricolour that is a constant feature atop the Maharashtra state secretariat complex.

As per procedure, every day an employee from the state Public Works Department (PWD) hoists the flag at around 6 am and another lowers it at 7.15 pm. This is followed all days of the year.

The flag-protection department, which has five men on its team - Suresh Baria, Deepak Adsul, Vishal Rane, Ganesh Gunj, Premji Roj - has its office right below the flag pole, in a chamber on the Mantralaya terrace.

On Thursday after 2.40 pm, when the fire broke out on the fourth floor of the seven-storeyed structure, staffers rushed to the flag protection office asking its officials to leave the building as the fire was spreading and all those within it were endangered.

However, the men refused to move unless they got orders from their seniors saying that they could lower the flag the size of which is 14 X 21 ft.

As the fire engulfed the building, these men stood by the flag pole ready to protect it from the flames, unhindered by the thought of the dangers their own lives faced. As the fire department began its rescue operations these officials were asked to leave their post, but they didn’t budge.

Baria, who has been serving at this post for over 10 years, said, “It’s our duty to be with the flag and protect it. Until it has been lowered we can’t come down like other people. When the fire broke out we went to the terrace from our chamber and waited there for orders from seniors. It’s the national flag and we can’t break protocol [i.e. lower the flag before its usual time] until we get a directive from our seniors. There is a proper schedule for flag hoisting and lowering, and it can’t be compromised.”

Senior officials from PWD have to give orders to lower the flag in emergency situations. The directive finally came at 4.05 pm, over an hour after the fire broke out. Fortunately the terrace remained the one area where the fire had not spread.

“We consider ourselves successful considering that we lowered the flag and folded it as per norms. We have kept it in a special room assigned for it,” added Ganesh Munj, who has been doing this job for the last 16 years. The flag is safe from the fire in this room.

2012062220120622041607972ee2075eb_201206220401168939643daaa_pic_original.jpg
 
. .
Good job. Their courage need to be rewarded.
 
. .
Honorable, but someone should really put a Force Majeure clause in their SOP. It just makes sense, flags are important but human life is still more precious (given the scenario they were faced with).

I hope they get a reward and recognition for their commitment.
 
. .
. . .

Note I said it depends on the situation... In a protest against the British Raj, uplifting the flag means something else and in an accidental fire it means something else.

Moreover it just meant folding the flag in the safe place, not even allowing it to get burned anyway. It is foolish to encourage such an SOP. Ultimately that SOP was broken right? So why can't it be just put in a clause that when such a fire type incident occurs, saving your life should take priority.
 
.
There's a fine line between patriotism and foolishness.

It was patriotism - the idea of keeping with the flag hoisted is there even in Wagah and the SOP is followed as accurately as possible. However in normal circumstances priority should be given to saving life, but in our culture this big gesture driven patriotism is drilled into our brains.

However the idea is not to keep the flag hoisted at night, so folding it earlier would be less of an issue than letting it get burned or stay up, while the crew dies of fire.

The idea (at least in Pakistan) is that darkness of night should never fall upon the flag. It is hoisted every morning, taken down every evening before sunset and folded away. It is one of those militaristic concepts.
 
.
It was patriotism - the idea of keeping with the flag hoisted is there even in Wagah and the SOP is followed as accurately as possible. However in normal circumstances priority should be given to saving life, but in our culture this big gesture driven patriotism is drilled into our brains.

However the idea is not to keep the flag hoisted at night, so folding it earlier would be less of an issue than letting it get burned or stay up, while the crew dies of fire.

The idea (at least in Pakistan) is that darkness of night should never fall upon the flag. It is hoisted every morning, taken down every evening before sunset and folded away. It is one of those militaristic concepts.

The world over Flags are generally hoisted from Revellie to Retreat.

The Residiency at lucknow was as far as I know the only place where the flag was never lowered after 1857 till 1947. The reasons were symbolic.

In this case, I suspect it is possible the gents in question felt that the fire would be controlled and were unsure of lowering it till asked to.
 
.
It was patriotism - the idea of keeping with the flag hoisted is there even in Wagah and the SOP is followed as accurately as possible. However in normal circumstances priority should be given to saving life, but in our culture this big gesture driven patriotism is drilled into our brains.

However the idea is not to keep the flag hoisted at night, so folding it earlier would be less of an issue than letting it get burned or stay up, while the crew dies of fire.

The idea (at least in Pakistan) is that darkness of night should never fall upon the flag. It is hoisted every morning, taken down every evening before sunset and folded away. It is one of those militaristic concepts.


In India you can hoist flag in night provided the flag should be Illuminated Properly.
 
.
I agree with Asim here life should be given more importance than the flag under normal circumstances. Aristotle lays importance to practical wisdom(or called Phronesis) - in simple words, rational thinking. Sometimes practical wisdom should be applied but need to commend their patriotism.


RPK, thankyou for bringing out the example of Tirupur Kumaran - not many know about him and atleast few of them will get to know him today.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom