The Durand Line-S. Asia's New Trouble Spot

[Ahmad]

the internet is a big place

can you provide me a few example of indians posing as afghans? as an afghan i will straightaway tell you the truth.

 

[LaBong]

Where did Salim aka Brig Ray say that NWFP should be a part of Afghanistan. But that is a demand echoed by some pashtuns both from Pakistan and Afghanistan, isn't it? Why blame Indians for that? :s

 

[Spring Onion]

Now where are liberalists and the champions of freedom of speech who declared war on me for questioning ajtr's flag and who asked me not issue 'flag fatwas'.

Perhaps it is high time they advise their compatriot and sister rather the 'enemy' Bharti.

P.s.: Jana, please now dont chide users who question aftr's flag because it seems you preach and not practise.

Two very different things. as far as ajtr is concerned i know about her and even another member knows about her more details and have seen the proofs of her being Indian thats why.



in case of this member here yeh i could be wrong too but then we have seen another Indian with Afghan flag

and this one will be exposed in no time its not easy to pose as Afghan or Pakistani Pukhtun for too long

 

[Spring Onion]

Where did Salim aka Brig Ray say that NWFP should be a part of Afghanistan. But that is a demand echoed by some pashtuns both from Pakistan and Afghanistan, isn't it? Why blame Indians for that? :s

"Some" who are these some" the internet users? as far as blaming Indians well i am blaming them for their useless redundant propaganda.

 

[LaBong]

in case of this member here yeh i could be wrong too but then we have seen another Indian with Afghan flag

If the other Indian is Kinetic, I think we know the meaning of the second flag in our profile. Lots of Indians are working in Afghanistan.

 

[LaBong]

"Some" who are these some" the internet users? as far as blaming Indians well i am blaming them for their useless redundant propaganda.

Yeah mainly Internet users, how would I know otherwise, I don't know any Afghans in person. I don't know about the propaganda, but India is DO spending lots of money in Afghanistan and mainly for good works. Yes there is a purpose behind it, noone do things out of pure goodwill anyway.

Also you fought a skirmish against Afghans, isn't it?

 

[KS]

Two very different things. as far as ajtr is concerned i know about her and even another member knows about her more details and have seen the proofs of her being Indian thats why.

That part was not intended for you. It is for two esteemed senior members over here.

And if you are mentioning Kinetic, his immediate ancestors belonged to Afg and came to India roughly during partition and that's why the Afghan flag.

 

[ice_man]

guys/gals let's leave the issue of ethnicity here! please and concentrate on the real topic!

as for being afghan or what not well...its simple alot of bombay as well as karachi people try and relate themselves to pashtouns and alot of others try to relate thesmelves to rajputs and all!

while some go overboard to relate themselves to ALEXANDER's army!!!

so guys you can feel you are one of the lost tribes of Jews for all it matters BUT the fact of the matter is you are indian pakistani or afghani by where you live in currently!!!

 

[Ahmad]

That is not the issue.

The issue is precedence.

And that is what will be the bone of contention.

If the Durand Line decision is upheld, so will the MacMohan line. That will surely not please the Chinese.

So called Duran Line is not upheld, the cruel Amir Abdul Rahman lost territories in north and east to the russians and british, he signed it and gave it away, why should we bother about it now? If none of the so called scholars in Afghanistan talks about Pamir, Badakhshan, and Panjdeh which is not part of Afghanistan now and was lost to the russians by the same Amir, why on earth we should bother about NWFP? If NWFP was part of Afghanistan once upon a time and so were Pamir, Panjdeh and Badakhshan.

If Amir didnt understand the terms of agreement with the british then it was nobody's fault but his own, why did he sign it? stupid i would say. Secondly, there is no time limit on this agreement, anybody who claims about any expiry date then kindly present us here with a proof.

Durand line shouldnt be called Durand Line, it's a proper border between the 2 indepent countries called pakistan and afghanistan. fence or plant this border with landmine so nobody will cross it.

 

[greatsequence]

Got a bit emotional here it goes

 

[Ahmad]

what is the relation of this song with the thread?

 

[Ahmad]

Ethnicity wise we support them and we feel for them and they do for us.

Territory-wise we will never liked to be called Afghanistanis and they wont liked to be called Pakistanis.

So our bharati members are just beating the bush around trying to wield their silly propaganda

you cant have it both ways jana.

 

[Subramanian]

Ahmad infact Brigadier Ray aka Salim forgot to recall that by his criterion, India will be broken down in many pieces specially the Tamil land applying his criteria should be included in Tamil country along with Sri Lankan Tamils.

Thanks to Indo-China war that South India felt closer to rest of India otherwise this ethnicity thing there would have got more roots

well jana,tamil people have in the past been in the biritsh army,bose's INA against the brits and japanese and also a lot on the Indian army.I mean apart from a small bunch of pussies,i dont think anyone here ever thinks of anything other than a hindu identity.I guess if one feels strongly as ahindu,he got nowhere to go except india.Chinese war has nothing to do with it.

It is the dream of a small bunch that TN should secede and shud exist as a country along with Northern SL but they neitehr have the support of people nor the balls to survive as one.