There was a time when American infrastructure made that of others look like village(s) in comparison. Now if somebody move from let's day Dubai to an American city, he might feel that he moved from a city to a village instead.
Not surprised. Most Americans can easily explain about why Dubai (or many other places) would look better than our cities.
So American cities should be left to rot because some people moved to suburbs?
If that Boston subway system wasn't overhauled in a while, no wonder people decided to buy cars and/or move elsewhere? You developed cities at some point and now you are OK with leaving them to rot because you do not live in one? Strange mindset.
No, the subway was perfectly fine. We had tons of trolleys too. Please watch a few seconds of this 1903 Boston video and everything will fall into place:
Look closely at all the people lining the streets in 1903. This was at a height of city living in the Boston area where the infrastructure was built to support ALL these working people flocking to Boston (subway stations opened in 1897-1901).
But it isn't like that anymore. Even though the Massachusetts population has more than doubled since 1903; the Boston streets are not overflowing with as many workers as you see in this video (most these days are tourists).
A large number of people now live and work in the suburbs and never set foot in the city. So the trolley routes disappeared because of low ridership making them unprofitable. The bus routes are struggling because of low ridership making them unprofitable. The subway is struggling because it is unprofitable. All this infrastructure built to sustain the throngs of people in 1903 is not applicable anymore. The city is struggling with a lower tax base (as the successful abandoned Boston...lower income people moved in to take their place...with their social welfare requirements) and Boston can't maintain their infrastructure anymore.
However having the Federal Government throwing money at it to shine it all up isn't going to solve the core problem. But what is the answer? Do we simply raze almost everything? Tear down billions of dollars worth of 120+ year old buildings?
Right now in the Boston area most of the new infrastructure in the last 70 years has
been in the suburbs..which when seen is almost incomprehensible as just 100 years ago this is what most of the area outside of Boston looked like:
it
was mostly clearcutted farmland from horizon to horizon mile after mile after mile. (like much of the UK countryside). Things look COMPLETELY different now as trees were replanted and all that flat empty farmland was turned into NEW suburban neighborhoods. THIS is the typical "new" infrastructure the US has invested $Billions in (but mostly unseen by non-Americans):
Almost
no money has been invested in Boston in probably 70 years (the last being the Big Dig).\
Meanwhile:
Brand new buildings, fountains, flowers, tons of free parking, trees, grass, etc. People now live in big modern single family houses and drive to places like above instead of the old 1903 way of living in some tiny 4th floor apartment in Boston and jumping on a trolley to get to work.
Why would anybody in their right mind want to deal with the city stuff anymore????
So Boston (like many other US cities) is in
serious decline.
When the New England Patriots built a new Stadium did they put it in downtown Boston right near easy public transportation to guarantee an adequate attendance? Nope, they put it in the suburbs and charge an average of $130 ticket. Sounds like suicide? Nope, they've sold out every game for like the past 20 years.
The Chinese here constantly focus on cities because skyscrapers, tall apartment buildings, cars, and city life is NEW to them and they think living there is cutting edge life compared to their old rural villages. So when they see neglected US cities they say the US must be in decline and not moving forwards. What they don't realize is that we already went through that exact same urban love phase 100 years ago...and after a few decades of flashing neon building lights, all night craziness, and crowding into apartment elevators we mostly decided it simply wasn't for us. We were originally quiet farmers who truly valued self-sufficiency and our "a man's home is his castle" mantra. That wasn't cutting it in urban life as we'd have to rely on building management to fix stuff and having idiot building residents making life miserable. So we moved to single family home living where we take care of everything and your neighbors are more than an arms length away.
China: rural farm village->urban
US: rural farm town -> urban -> suburban