Joe Shearer
PROFESSIONAL
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2009
- Messages
- 27,493
- Reaction score
- 162
- Country
- Location
Interesting inputs; my interim responses in blue below.
I think i found this video on youtube from a site called the art of battle
http://img35.imageshack.us/img35/4044/7261.mp4
It is a graphic representation of the battle.
This site was first mentioned to me (it may have been mentioned by others earlier) by Austerlitz, who is most authoritative on these subjects of battle and warfare; I did not look it up immediately, but hurried to do so after receiving painful (and unnecessary) corporal punishment at the hands of Alternative. Jonathan Webb is not a poster, he is the person running the site and creating the animations.
I dare not say this outright, but perhaps you could now compare Webb's account and Tarn's and identify the discrepancies (they exist).
One of the poster with name Jonathan Webb says that the following are the authoritarian books on this which are
# Diodorus Siculus (90-30 BC). Bibliotheca Historica.
# Quintus Curtius Rufus (60-70 AD). Historiae Alexandri Magni.
# Plutarch (75 AD). The Life of Alexander the Great, Parallel Lives.
# Arrian (early 2nd c. AD).
All present and accounted for; there are, in fact, four more who are being presented.
If it is the general wish that I confine myself to the top four, I can do so.
I mean not one India source, a turning point in the history of this country and no one even thought of writing a authoritative account of it!!!!
This was 326 BC. Would you like to help us to understand by informing us what was going on in India at that time?
Sorry but i am not much knowledged on posting videos and photos
i tried but it seems the video doesn't show
may be this could work or this
<video snipped for sake of economy>
Just to remind you: differences, if any?
<video snipped for sake of economy>
According to our family tradition it was the Persian horse archers who carried the day for Alexander - the Punjabi's could not cope with their mobility.
Tarn's account of the battle (other accounts will be available shortly for a deeper comparison) partly agrees and partly disagrees.
Regarding it being a family legend, you will notice that my basic point in uploading these excerts with a considerable expenditure of effort was to promote the use of authoritative historical sources rather than either 'legends' or 'perspectives'. However, whether you do so or not is your personal decision.
You wound, like Parthians, while you fly,
And kill with a retreating eye.
—Samuel Butler
Did you notice that Alexander's archers were neither Persians, nor, strictly speaking, Parthians? Who they were ought to be mentioned clearly somewhere. If not, please let me know and I can cite the passage concerned.