What's new

Study: How Pakistan’s recent protests failed

Thousands of protesters have been camped out for more than a week within earshot of Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s house in Islamabad demanding that he resign from office. Some have carried stick figures of Sharif wearing a noose, creating a global image that the prime minister is embattled less than 15 months after he returned to office for his third term.

Yet an extensive new survey of public sentiment in Pakistan reveals that the ongoing demonstrations are hardly reflective of the views of most Pakistanis.

The annual Pew Research Center survey of Pakistan finds that 64 percent of residents have a favorable view of Sharif, a solid rating that has essentially remained constant since Sharif’s returned to power last year.

pew.jpg



Perhaps even more important in Sharif’s bid to hold off the demonstrators, led by former cricket star Imran Khan and firebrand cleric Tahirul Qadri, Pakistanis' positive views about the economy have risen dramatically over the past year.

About four in ten residents now have confidence in Pakistan’s economy, compared to just 17 percent who felt that way last year. Moreover, Pew notes that 36 percent of residents are optimistic that the economy will improve over the next year, twice as many who felt that way compared to last year.

Since returning to office after years of exile in the aftermath of a 1999 military coup that ousted him from his second term as premier, Sharif has made improving Pakistan’s stagnant economy a top priority. He has authorized hundreds of millions of dollars in construction projects, sought international assistance to try to tackle the country’s chronic energy shortages and is working to increase trade with neighboring countries.

Without question, Pakistan remains a long way from being able to call itself a happy, prosperous nation. It’s a country where the lights can still be out for as much as 16 hours a day, polio is known as a real disease and not just a vaccine, and the U.S. dollar has a 100-to-1 advantage over the Pakistani rupee.

Yet the fact that the poll finds that a quarter of voters now think the country is going in the right direction highlights a lifeline for Sharif as he tries to survive the political storm created by Khan and Qadri. Last year, according to Pew, just 8 percent of Pakistanis said the country was going in the right direction.

“Pakistanis are more satisfied with the direction of their country than they have been in six years,” Pew notes.

The Pew poll, which involved 1,203 face-to-face interviews, was conducted in late April and early May -- two months before Khan and Qadri mobilized their supporters to march on Islamabad.

But the poll suggests that Sharif began the summer with far more public support than Khan, whose party finished third in last year’s election but alleges that it was fraudulent.

The poll put Khan’s favorability rating at 53 percent. While still respectable in a country known for its fractious political system, Khan’s favorability rating has declined 17 percent over the past two years. That suggest that the more Pakistanis get to know Khan, who is known for his theatrics and often-inflexible stances on major issues, the less they like him.

If the poll contains any unsettling news for Sharif, it’s that his public support pales in comparison to the sky-high ratings for the country’s military.

Should the military decide that the best way to end the disruptive protest is to get rid of Sharif, it will likely be hard for the prime minister to generate broad public outrage against the move.

Nearly nine out of ten Pakistanis say the military is a positive influence in the country’s affairs – its highest level of support in a Pew poll since 2002, when former army chief Pervez Musharraf ran the country after he ousted Sharif in the 1999 coup.

In other findings, the poll reveals that Pakistan is a country that still doesn’t trust or particularly like the United States, but one where Islamic extremism is also frowned upon.

Only 14 percent of respondents have a favorable view of America, and Obama’s approval rating stands at just 7 percent. But the number of Pakistanis who hold a negative view of America has dropped by 20 percentage points over the past two years, from 80 percent in 2012 to 59 percent today.

And despite impressions from around globe that Pakistanis are too tolerant of Islamist extremism, the poll finds that just 8 percent of residents hold a positive view of the Taliban, while only 2 percent approve of al-Qaeda. Three-fifths of Pakistanis also view the Taliban as a serious threat to the nation.

Still, Pakistanis continue to identify neighboring India as the greatest threat to the country’s security, even though more than 50,000 Pakistanis have been killed in the country’s battle with the Taliban over the past decade.

And the numbers of Pakistanis who feel that way has shot up by about 10 percentage points over the past year, according to Pew.

In a country that has fought three wars against India since 1947, that suggests that old attitudes are hard to erase in Pakistan. That may also be good news for Sharif, who started his first term as prime minister two dozen years ago.


Tim Craig is The Post’s bureau chief in Pakistan. He has also covered conflicts in Iraq, Afghanistan and within the District of Columbia government.
Study: How Pakistan’s recent protests failed - The Washington Post


You mean survey which was conducted in May is the outcome of protest. means result came before beginning of protest :woot:
 
1. Indians are supporting Nawaz
2. American stooges (orangzaib & syed-ali.haider) are supporting Nawaz

Pakistani public hates Indians in general! Pakistanis hate American involvement in Pakistan. 180million you lot keep quoting can't stand Indians and Americans and we don't give a flying f*** what you think! So shut your gobs and stay out of Pakistan's matters.
 
Those are observations of a foreigner. I respect your opinion but i reject it because its primitive and i don't trust your best intentions in this matter. If you were a Pakistani, i would have engaged in this debate.
--
Sorry to Come as guset here ..
@Aeronaut
if you going to reject OPINION based on nationality and riddance place ..
same thoery applied to you too..
rather focus nationlity and perosn knowledge
why dont you reply with more crystal clear opnion and make people realized that their knowledge of pak is primitive and need to be updated with facts , figure, logic and proof .. opinion.. etc
then this forum become meaningless..if your criteria is applied here ..
--
no one have clear picture of situation except very few .. with limitation
so if we put eveyone view point in puzzel we may get better soluton with less time and cost

1. Indians are supporting Nawaz
2. American stooges (orangzaib & syed-ali.haider) are supporting Nawaz

Pakistani public hates Indians in general! Pakistanis hate American involvement in Pakistan. 180million you lot keep quoting can't stand Indians and Americans and we don't give a flying f*** what you think! So shut your gobs and stay out of Pakistan's matters.
--
Have opinion dont abuse ...
----
Indians at large have supporters of both Ik nd NS
---
 
Last edited:
I am not pushing anyone's foreign policy, but need to ask one question. Do you really think that once anyone else including IK comes in power we will be free from American interference, and influence.

No, we won't be, however with a strong leader in power (not necessarily IK), we surely wouldn't be scrappinf our vital national interest to please America and KSA.
 
No, we won't be, however with a strong leader in power (not necessarily IK), we surely wouldn't be scrappinf our vital national interest to please America and KSA.

A strong leader can negotiate better, yes, but only as much as the national fundamentals would give him/her the strength to achieve and no more.
 
The Pew Poll is propaganda directed against Imran Khan. Imran's popularity has risen over the past few weeks, and Nawaz has gone down. Nawaz and his fellow puppet of the US friends are only making the country worse.
 
I have not read all posts in this thread but I think I agree with @Syed.Ali.Haider and @orangzaib

We Pakistanis are basically maula jutt mentality. We believe in make or break. There has never been a system in place which we let it run for couple of decades. Be it Democracy, PCB constitution, Reforms in the government entities such as Pakistan Railways. We want quick fix to every problem in Pakistan and once we open the engine we can't even re-fix it to make it work like before hence we keep dragging ourselves to lowest peak all the time.

I am in favour of democracy and supporting this government not because I like them but what is right. I happily left PTI as it contradicts with my basic principles and has gone on to follow the footsteps of PML-N and PPP of 1990s (extreme), clearly explains how far PTI is in her ambition to mature as a political party. I believe the recent survey conducted by PEW is a fair reflection of public opinion.

The point to consider is:

PML-N got
  • 14.8 million votes or 32.77% votes in 2013
  • 6.8 million votes or about 20% in 2008 and it worthy to note that PPP had attained sympathy votes after Benazir died and also there were several places where PML-N candidate was not stood to make space for PPP
  • 4 million votes or 12% in the worst election ever held in Pakistan in 2002 (as it was simply anti-PML-N election with all leadership under prison)
  • 8.7 million votes or 45% in 1997
  • 8 million votes or 40% in 1993
  • 7.9 million votes or 37% in 1990
  • 5.8 million votes or 30% in 1988
So clearly PML-N always had the support of around 8 million voters or 40% even when the election were completely rigged to make them lose. Now also make a note that the population has increased a lot since 1990s. So assuming PML-N does not have a support base in Pakistan is a foolish thought.

The failure of PTI's long march is a fair reflection of reality-check for Imran Khan where he claimed 1,000,000 people would participate in his long march. It would have been really nice if that number was ever achieved but how many people came forward to support? Initially 50,000 people perhaps and now 15,000 to 20,000 coming in shifts. That is not enough to win even a single seat in Pakistan and even Imran Khan used to gather 150,000 to 200,000 people easily in the last year's public gathering now why the number decreased by 6-10 times? This is a fair reflection of reality which Imran Khan needs to ponder upon and grow up now, if never
 
Some time in the future, PML-N would be doing the same as is being done by IK and TUQ. The sitting government would be shitting in their pants just like today. Pakistan's economy would still be as pathetic as today.

This damn country has become ungovernable. Not even the Army (the most powerful mafia) will be able to govern it.

A typical third-world post-colonial failed state.
 
Back
Top Bottom