South China Sea Forum

[xunzi]

Nobody know the future ... it maybe hurt for us or ... for you.

That is true. But even if you invade and retake Paracel from us. No guarantee we will not retake it again shortly after. Logic tell me, we can easily retake because our navy asset is in Hainan. It is home to this...

A lot of our submarines are located in Hainan. It is PLAN headquarter so we will respond quickly to any invasion on Paracel.

 

[xunzi]

Do you want to hear our honest truth about the situation?

 

[BoQ77]

Do you want to hear our honest truth about the situation?

go ahead sunzi ... just don't spoil pls !!!

 

[xunzi]

go ahead sunzi ... just don't spoil pls !!!

Alright but don't get hurt if I tell the truth.

Look, ASEAN is naive, extremely naive. You think we do not know that within ASEAN, there is dispute among yourselves? Not too long ago, Vietnam and Philippines were fighting each over some rock, Malaysia and Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, Philippines and Malaysia. The point here is if you can't resolve your own dispute internally, how can you seriously expect us to believe in this united front? This is not mentioning that we outclass all ASEAN together in arm. Do you seriously going to bring this to the negotiate table without much leverage? Show us that you can resolve dispute first before you bring yourself to the table to talk with the big boy.

 

[nufix]

SBY? that guy's office will stop running come July and he can not run for another candidacy, why bother asking whether he can deal with the SCS problem or not? The interesting question should be whether the next President will keep on continuing SBY's neutralist policy or choose sides.

 

[Viet]

Sabotage, my ***. It was you Vietnamese who want to internationalizing the dispute and bring 3rd party to split the resources. We said no. We want bilateral negotiation but you insist on multilateral. Get this fact straight!

you know we are the weaker party as Vietnam is smaller. that is not a fair game. we are not stupid. China is much bigger.
it is similar if we negotiate with Brunei bilateral.

That is true. But even if you invade and retake Paracel from us. No guarantee we will not retake it again shortly after. Logic tell me, we can easily retake because our navy asset is in Hainan. It is home to this...

A lot of our submarines are located in Hainan. It is PLAN headquarter so we will respond quickly to any invasion on Paracel.

nice map. Uncle Sam will take it and configure the missiles accordingly.

 

[Soryu]

Well, so we must destroy it at first if we want to retake Paracel.

P/S: you're easier than others Ah-Q boys to talk, xunzi. It's good.

That is true. But even if you invade and retake Paracel from us. No guarantee we will not retake it again shortly after. Logic tell me, we can easily retake because our navy asset is in Hainan. It is home to this...

A lot of our submarines are located in Hainan. It is PLAN headquarter so we will respond quickly to any invasion on Paracel.

 

[BoQ77]

Alright but don't get hurt if I tell the truth.

Look, ASEAN is naive, extremely naive. You think we do not know that within ASEAN, there is dispute among yourselves? Not too long ago, Vietnam and Philippines were fighting each over some rock, Malaysia and Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, Philippines and Malaysia. The point here is if you can't resolve your own dispute internally, how can you seriously expect us to believe in this united front? This is not mentioning that we outclass all ASEAN together in arm. Do you seriously going to bring this to the negotiate table without much leverage? Show us that you can resolve dispute first before you bring yourself to the table to talk with the big boy.

Xunzi, in fact, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam, Thailand ... settled the sea boundaries that is bi/trilateral joint

 

[Beast]

you know we are the weaker party as Vietnam is smaller. that is not a fair game. we are not stupid. China is much bigger.
it is similar if we negotiate with Brunei bilateral.


nice map. Uncle Sam will take it and configure the missiles accordingly.

why would US fight for a small.insignificant country like vietnam? Very sad vietnam is alone.

 

[EastSea]

Alright but don't get hurt if I tell the truth.

SCS is not china lake. its going on, China is trouble maker in region.

 

[+4vsgorillas-Apebane]

SBY? that guy's office will stop running come July and he can not run for another candidacy, why bother asking whether he can deal with the SCS problem or not? The interesting question should be whether the next President will keep on continuing SBY's neutralist policy or choose sides.

All he has to do is sing really well and ask the population to grant him another term. He did outsing Megawati.

 

[EastSea]

We have offer you Vietnamese the opportunity for joint-exploration and development but you resist. Don't blame us. You Viet are dirty against smaller and weaker country like Philippines. The history of you grabbing Philippines control territory in Spratly is legendary. LOL Like I said, you need big gun and big ball.

what is join exploration in our territory ? Its simplely china dont have right to do it. Don't try to cheat us.

why would US fight for a small.insignificant country like vietnam? Very sad vietnam is alone.

If it should be, not for Vietnam, to destroy China with your hilarious dream to rule a region here and to the world.

 

[sincity]

Will VietNam completely transfer the right to claim of territory to the US adminster of those area? Viet Nam want to push China out must make a concession to the US and transfer the right with the SCS territory to the US, now let US fight against China over the SCS territory. Other than the US directly fighting China in a naval battle, VietNam don't stand a chance whatsoever.

 

[EastSea]

Will VietNam completely transfer the right to claim of territory to the US adminster of those area? Viet Nam want to push China out must make a concession to the US and transfer the right with the SCS territory to the US, now let US fight against China over the SCS territory. Other than the US directly fighting China in a naval battle, VietNam don't stand a chance whatsoever.

nope.
Both Vietnam and China has right for the SCS under rules of internal law. When USA went home, China thought he can steal every thing here and now he do it.

USA will come back, every thing could happen here.

 

[NiceGuy]

end China’s dominance in the South China Sea? But does China really dominate SCS(east sea) ??? Of course No. seem like all papers r trying to demonize China when infact VN control the largest part of SCS(east sea)