What's new

Similarities between the Ajanta caves and petra in Jordan are deep.

The SC

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
32,233
Reaction score
21
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
Petra, the 'rose red city, half as old as time', located in modern day Jordan, is undoubtedly one of the most dramatic archaeological sites of the world.

In a recently conducted Internet poll, Petra was voted by internet users as one of the 'seven wonders of the modern world'. In this abandoned city, which lies hidden behind impenetrable mountains and gorges, magnificent rock-cut temples and palaces have been carved into towering cliffs of red and orange sandstone. The most famous of these structures is the 'Al Khasneh' (or the 'Treasury'), which was made famous in an Indiana Jones film.

Historians tell us that sometime during the 6th - 4th centuries BC, the Nabataeans, a nomadic tribe from north-western Arabia, entered the region of Petra, and established their cultural, commercial and ceremonial center at Petra. Petra was located strategically at the intersection of the overland Silk Route which connected India and China with Egypt and the Hellenistic world, and the Incense Route from Arabia to Damascus. It soon developed into a thriving commercial center.

This unusual array of symbolic elements associated with the chief god of the Nabataeans, Dushara, may have confounded historians, but to anyone familiar with the symbolism of the Vedic deity Shiva, the similarities between Dushara and Shiva will be palpable.

Shiva is still worshipped all over India in the form of a black block of stone known as a Shiva Linga. A Shiva Linga, which is essentially a 'mark' or 'symbol' of Shiva, sometimes appears as an unworked block of stone, much like the idol of Dushara in the temple of Al Deir; but typically it is represented by a smooth, rounded stone which resembles some of the rounded, dome-shaped, baetyls that we find in Petra.

The similarities, however, do not end here. The consort of Dushara was known to the Nabataeans as Al-Uzza or Al-lat. She was a goddess of power and a goddess of the people, and was symbolized by a lion.

Lions are present at many sites in Petra. At the Lion Triclinium in Petra there are two massive lions protecting the doorway. Lions are also seen at the Lion Monument in Petra, a public fountain, where refreshing water for the perspiring pilgrims would have sprouted from the water outlet at the mouth of the lion. At the Temple of the Winged Lions, a considerable amount of material has been found, including feline statuette fragments, which emphasize the 'feline' association of the mother goddess. The supreme mother goddess was also symbolically associated with vegetation, grains and prosperity, and was frequently depicted holding cereal stalks and fruits.

Not surprisingly, the lion is also associated with the consort of Shiva, known as Parvati, Durga or Shakti. As per the Puranic legends, when the entire humanity was threatened by the evil Mahisasura, the goddess Durga, invested with the combined spiritual energies of the Hindu Trinity -- Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva -- and adorned with celestial weapons granted by the divine company of gods, rode her lion to battle this asura. The terrible battle raged over nine days, and on the tenth day Durga defeated and killed Mahisasura. Even now, the victory of Durga over the forces of darkness represented by Mahisasura, is one of the most widely celebrated religious festivals in India, known as Dussehra (or Dasha-Hara, Navratri, Vijaydashami) which is celebrated over a period of ten days.

Is Petra an ancient Shiva temple?

Does Petra city predates the Ajanta caves?
The article seems to be contradictory since it starts with the history of Petra and then says that it might have been inspired from the Indus valley civilisation, forgetting that the Sumerian civilisation originated very closely to where Petra is.
 
.
So did Hinduism originated from an Arab land like Judaism and Christianity ?
The evidences are startling of how close it was to a pagan religion of some early middle eastern civilisations.
 
.
All this time we thought Petra is Roman civilization. It is amazing how far Hinduism has reached even without trying. Is true that a Hindu temple existed at present day Mecca ? A Muslim friend told me this
 
.
All this time we thought Petra is Roman civilization. It is amazing how far Hinduism has reached even without trying. Is true that a Hindu temple existed at present day Mecca ? A Muslim friend told me this

They say that the black stone at kabba is nothing but Shiva linga, and there was a famous temple called meckhaheswarar temple or something like that...
But the saudis refuse this or allow any research on this...
So it cannot be confirmed or proved...
 
.
They say that the black stone at kabba is nothing but Shiva linga, and there was a famous temple called meckhaheswarar temple or something like that...
But the saudis refuse this or allow any research on this...
So it cannot be confirmed or proved...

Not surprising. Hinduism is the oldest religion after all
 
.
All this time we thought Petra is Roman civilization. It is amazing how far Hinduism has reached even without trying. Is true that a Hindu temple existed at present day Mecca ? A Muslim friend told me this

So you have Arab origins!!!
 
.
So you have Arab origins!!!

Other way round is also possible
Even in Jainism history it is mentioned that many Jain monks travel as far as Persia and to modern Iraq thousands of year ago..
We have some references of manuscripts available in some or Iranian and Iraqi Museum but no research ..
 
.
The black stone at Kabba predates Islam and is supposed to have fallen from heaven , and is from the times of Abhraham . The area was a pilgrimage centre even before Islam
 
.
So did Hinduism originated from an Arab land like Judaism and Christianity ?
The evidences are startling of how close it was to a pagan religion of some early middle eastern civilisations.

Dont think so. It originated in the subcontinent.

Anyway if you compare the similarities with other religion, you will see that it is close to each other. If you compare the differences you will see how far it is from each other

So you have Arab origins!!!

more like Proto-Indo-Iranian origins. Hinduism and zoroastrian have the same origins. But i dont think they have semitic origins
 
.
I am surprised why it is being compared it with Ajanta caves. Ajanta Caves belong to Gupta era - 3- 5 century AD
 
.
I am surprised why it is being compared it with Ajanta caves. Ajanta Caves belong to Gupta era - 3- 5 century AD

The caves were built in two phases. The first phase was built in around 200BCE
 
.
Dont think so. It originated in the subcontinent.

Anyway if you compare the similarities with other religion, you will see that it is close to each other. If you compare the differences you will see how far it is from each other



more like Proto-Indo-Iranian origins. Hinduism and zoroastrian have the same origins. But i dont think they have semitic origins


If they have similarities and differences that means they are a variant of the religions they have similarities to, if those are older.

zoroastrians are Thamud in the Koran, so probably hindus were A'ad.
(See about " A'ad oua Thamud "in the Koran)
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom