What's new

Should Indians be forced to join the army?

Shinigami

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 15, 2011
Messages
3,611
Reaction score
-10
A crippling shortage in the officers’ ranks of the Indian armed forces that is likely to persist beyond 2020 is reason for serious concern. It could severely undermine the efficiency of the country’s armed forces. The armed forces are facing a shortage of 15,004 officers with the army confronted by the most serious shortfall. While the army is short of around 12,349 officers, the navy and air force have a shortfall of 1,818 and 837 officers respectively. The shortage in the army is particularly serious — over 25 per cent of its sanctioned strength. Not only has the shortfall in officers existed for years but also the gap has grown.

Low salaries, high stress and slow promotions in the armed forces are among the reasons why youngsters are not drawn to a career in the armed forces, especially when compared to a job in the private sector. So unattractive has a career in the forces become that seats in the military academies are going unfilled year after year. Those who do give it a shot and enter the forces are putting in their papers before long. The armed forces are suffering from high attrition rates.

Some have suggested forced conscription to address the shortage. This is a bad idea as it will not make for a motivated force. Besides it goes against India’s ethos of democracy. :-)hitwall: US? Israel? UK? Singapore?) The government has been saying that it is taking remedial measures to deal with the shortfall. It has said that all officers including those in the short service commission (SSC) will be eligible to hold substantive ranks within a few years of reckonable service. The tenure of SSC officers has been increased too. Efforts are on to attract youngsters through advertisements. However, these measures are at best superficial. What is required is a complete overhaul of the salary structure and of the promotions policy so that good officers are motivated to remain in the military and the best and brightest are drawn to a career in the armed forces. In its effort to improve the fighting capability of the armed forces, India is investing billions of dollars in modernising military hardware. It is however neglecting the problem of shortage of officers. The latest weaponry alone will not make our borders safe. We need the right personnel to plan and lead from the front.
 
. .
Its kinda worryin....... indian army faces shortage of officiers and cant get volunteers.......while its opposite in our case.

Good luck.
 
. .
I don't like the idea of conscription . Army life is un-attractive to me. At the moment, i am preparing for IAS, IFS; so i might have shot at achieving my recent department of interest........the RAW :tup:
 
.
Its kinda worryin....... indian army faces shortage of officiers and cant get volunteers.......while its opposite in our case.

Good luck.

Lol, Indian citizens are spoilt for choice these days unlike our Pakistani counter parts. We have a nation to build, and an army cannot do that.
 
. .
Conscription won't work too well in Indian context. What would work better is an overhaul of the entire compensation structure and better advertisements to motivate people. Scholarship programs can also be encouraged for young people who want to earn a degree and then go ahead to work in the armed forces. In the US, the armed forces sponsor for a candidate's degree education if they enroll... something similar to this might help motivate the youth.

With the defence budget growing along with our GDP, a larger chunk can be spent on the salaries which should be a good motivation for most.
 
.
Its kinda worryin....... indian army faces shortage of officiers and cant get volunteers.......while its opposite in our case.

Good luck.

Might be because there aren't too many opportunities in other job sectors in Pakistan, so most take up armed forces as an easier way to get a decent job. Not the case in India though.... the private sector salaries are sometimes 5 to 10 times of the salaries in the armed forces.
 
.
What rubbish! Many of my friends have experiences of something else! I do not want to go in details but getting IA, IN and specially IAF officer technical level jobs are one of the toughest and salary, facilities are high. Those are getting jobs in Siemens, CISCO, Microsoft, Tata or Oracle rejected by IA and IAF. I know many. :taz: :taz::taz:
 
. .
Conscription will only work in countries with low population and India with its population and demographic bulge cannot do conscription sucessfully. Almost 20 million militarily fit youngsters are added each year (Link). How will absorb all of them into the army ?

Already the acceptance ratio in the Army is something like 1 recruit for every 10 or so appliers and in the case of officers, it is even more.

And for those who think IA lacks Officers because there are not enough people, NO its not because of that --- its just the qualification standards have been made very very demanding nowadays.
 
.
Whats this? The citizens do not wanna join army? Why? They say they are proud of it and now when the army is screaming for help, where are all they gone?
And no, you have no rights to force someone to join army. No one has anyright to kill citizens.
 
. .
Whats this? The citizens do not wanna join army? Why? They say they are proud of it and now when the army is screaming for help, where are all they gone?
And no, you have no rights to force someone to join army. No one has anyright to kill citizens.

For screaming out loud. The accpetance to toal application ratio is more than 1:10 or so for ordinary Jawans. Still think youngsters
dont want to serve India.

During disaster time.

I dnt think there is such a concept in india.

@stingray... everybdy here in Pakistan wants to serve the nation...... cant say anything abt india.

The concept is there. If our nation calls we will be there. Let there be no doubt.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom