Should India Provide Direct Military Aid To Afghanistan?

[tvsram1992]

Man go sort your own sh!t first... i dont even want to mention the massive issues ur so called shinning india faces.. your a ignorant troll..

Why you wanna taste that an elite troll

Must be the reason you celebrate 1948,1962 and 1965? right..

Why do you always try to get the credit of others . What was the reason behind mentioned 1962 . Pakistan was never involved in that . We literally occupied half of the Kashmir and you know who is the loser . Coming to 1965 i dont you if you are on your senses . You started attack on us to occupy Kashmir and you consider defending lahore itself as victory Why did you leave 1971 , you could have mentioned you won that war too

Wasnt it NATOs mission to destroy taliban etc? also what "strategic asset" can you develop afghanistan into after NATO leaves? nothing but bickering..

So what , average americans were enjoying in their home land while talibans were being killed like rats in an r/c video game played by NATO .The current condition of Pakistan makes you think Afghanistan will not be developed . That is because NATO used you . Unlike them we offer good business for their natural resources and talent along with defence and other exchanges . You will see what we do .

Than why was afghanistan invaded? you know nothing abt anything do you? my hyderabadi fnd!

NATO aim was to loot Afghanistan and Pakistan and get that land into their control . You know the government people are puppets of NATO . That achieves aim of NATO . Its a fact . No offence .

 

[That Guy]

Hardware? No, you'd be wasting money and most of it might end up being sold off to the taliban.

men on ground? it's suicide.

 

[acid rain]

Open the books.

Your talk is just like the old rajas.

Why?

Like you the old rajas mutilated history, and guess what, as a result, history will mutilated those rajas.

Please read a little. You are bringing so much shame to an otherwise educated lot of Indian posters.

Super power aka Commie Russia made Afghanistan a battle zone.

And if you don't even know this much,

then surely you too are mutilating history like the India rajas of the old, and perhaps you you are so ignorant that you don't even know you are mixing up bunch of things. This is the worst kind of world view.

Sadly.

Please open your eyes to reality,who are everyone blaming for the mess in Afghanistan? the creator of AL Qaeda, Taliban and hundreds of other terror groups. If the Afghans had enlisted the help of Soviets - its their destiny - why make it a war between foreign forces? OK even if you did - why not quit once the work is done? why push the bozos into India? and push the talibozos into Afghanistan? You think after doing that both India and Afghanistan will trust Pakistan to not do that again? So, there goes your six months theory out the window.

Now you are on the verge of repeaating the same with another set of superpowers - Pakistans playing both China and US case in point Gwadhar, selling and trading secrets and bases to both at the sametime for funds and favors and the constant need to have a control over Afghanistan and India....again there will be a conflict in the area.

 

[Aamna14]

With all sincerity if India wishes to exist peacefully it shouldn't get involved in the whole mess. I know there is the whole Pakistan vs India element and the repeated accusations but keeping those aside If India gets involved in Afghanistan once then it won't be able to pull out of there. With all the talk about NATO and US planting puppets in Pakistan and elsewhere the fact remains the same they have lost this war miserably and now they want to pull out leaving Indian and Pakistani soldiers to clean the mess or if not for that than surely for this region to burn for long.

 

[Parul]

With all sincerity if India wishes to exist peacefully it shouldn't get involved in the whole mess. I know there is the whole Pakistan vs India element and the repeated accusations but keeping those aside If India gets involved in Afghanistan once then it won't be able to pull out of there. With all the talk about NATO and US planting puppets in Pakistan and elsewhere the fact remains the same they have lost this war miserably and now they want to pull out leaving Indian and Pakistani soldiers to clean the mess or if not for that than surely for this region to burn for long.

We ain't going to send our Soldiers to Afghanistan.

 

[illusion8]

With all sincerity if India wishes to exist peacefully it shouldn't get involved in the whole mess. I know there is the whole Pakistan vs India element and the repeated accusations but keeping those aside If India gets involved in Afghanistan once then it won't be able to pull out of there. With all the talk about NATO and US planting puppets in Pakistan and elsewhere the fact remains the same they have lost this war miserably and now they want to pull out leaving Indian and Pakistani soldiers to clean the mess or if not for that than surely for this region to burn for long.

The best option would be that Pakistan loosens it's grip on Afghanistan and the Taliban - which it wont do so the mess and the war continues, but unlike the last time the theater of war has become the two countries.