Reality of 2-Nation Theory

[kris]

So indians WANTED Pakistan to be created in 1947? They were not against the idea? So the idea of a "United india" was never wanted by indians? So even by your own admission, india today has no justifiable reason to exist as indians are not concerned about losing territory.
Is this why india has ceded 39,000 square kms of it's territory to China?:

https://eurasiantimes.com/china-has...f-indian-land-in-ladakh-arunachal-india-govt/

What nonsense...
India gave away land for peaceful co existence..
I never said Indians don't worry about loss of territory

Bringing china is off topic, you can join many cheerleaders in other topics in pdf forum

india doesn't have any successionist movements then?..................What succesionist movements are there in Pakistan?............ Can you be specific and explain them?

PS Muslims may have issues with one another but nothing compared to what we would have had, had Pakistan or bangladesh not been created. That in itself is the 2-nation theory.

Only seccessionist movements india have are Nagaland which is curtailed and Khalistan which lives only in Pakistan and Canada....

Balochistan problem, pashtuns.
And as Pakistan was broken and seperate from Bangladesh now come and live in reality

You have bigger problems to handle

 

[Cookie Monster]

So tell me how does the two nation theory justify the acceptance of the accession of Junagarh

I would be happy to spoonfeed these things to a genuinely curious person who is perhaps in his teens and isn't charged with blind nationalism(India/Pak specific).

From ur posts that I've read in general...and our previous discussions...u r too charged with Indian nationalism(and not in a healthy way...more like the type of nationalism of Arnab Goswami). Additionally u r not a child...pick up a book and read. That kind of a spoon feeding isn't for u...it would only be a waste of my time.

 

[kris]

Don't distort history. Congress, Gandhi and Nehru denied 2 nation theory. Indian constitution was against 2 antion theory. If India accepts 2 nation theory then it has no rights on may of the states having Muslim majority.

We are highlighting the treachery of the Congress that they created India on the basis of secularism and now they are converting it into an Hindutva state. Thats treachery.

Please support your fraudulent claims

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

What nonsense...
India gave away land for peaceful co existence..
I never said Indians don't worry about loss of territory

Bringing china is off topic, you can join many cheerleaders in other topics in pdf forum

You are looking for excuses but not addressing or explaining your points concisely. The biggest cheerleading comes from indians who claim that the bengalis and afghnas are going to fight Pakistan on their behalf.

 

[KhanBaba2]

I would be happy to spoonfeed these things to a genuinely curious person who is perhaps in his teens and isn't charged with blind nationalism(India/Pak specific).

From ur posts that I've read in general...and our previous discussions...u r too charged with Indian nationalism(and not in a healthy way...more like the type of nationalism of Arnab Goswami). Additionally u r not a child...pick up a book and read. That kind of a spoon feeding isn't for u...it would only be a waste of my time.

No answer then.

 

[kris]

The 2-nation theory and it's validity is neither here nor there. It is the subject of meaningless conjecture. Pakistan exists and it's people have a unique racial and cultural heritage. Nothing is going to change that nor is that in question. The creation of both Pakistan and bangladesh, ultimately destroyed the myth of a "United india", whatever that means.






Pakistan is the world's first ever Islamic nuclear weapons state that has thwarted an enemy that is more than 7x bigger that it, for 73 years. Thanks to CPEC and other similar initiatives, Pakistan is having billions invested in it by a global superpower set to become the world's FIRST EVER Global hyper power. india on the other hand is a beggar nation that receives the highest amount of american aid and is also home to the greatest number of severely malnourished and extreme poor people in the world:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...-third-of-worlds-poorest-says-World-Bank.html

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...591/India-accused-of-poverty-smokescreen.html

https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/a-third-of-the-worlds-poor-live-in-india-says-un-45376

https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/half-world-s-poor-live-just-5-countries

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/sputniknews.com/amp/asia/201507141024617963/



The above irrefutable evidence clearly shows that india is a failed state capable of nothing but hot air and talk on the internet.

There is hardly any racial or cultural heritage to be called for Pakistan.

And for calling india a failed state either you should be on someone's payroll or mentally immature..

 

[Cookie Monster]

No answer then.

Correction...no answer for u specifically(and others like u).

I have discussed such things with members like @Nilgiri(in the discord channel). Maybe u have the time to waste on internet nobodies...I don't. First establish urself as the kind of person who is worth discussing things with.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

What nonsense...
India gave away land for peaceful co existence..
I never said Indians don't worry about loss of territory

Bringing china is off topic, you can join many cheerleaders in other topics in pdf forum


Only seccessionist movements india have are Nagaland which is curtailed and Khalistan which lives only in Pakistan and Canada....

Balochistan problem, pashtuns.
And as Pakistan was broken and seperate from Bangladesh now come and live in reality

You have bigger problems to handle

The BLA and Pustun movement are virtually dead now. CPEC killed them both off. Combined they both don't even number 1000. In fact, probably less than 500. That too despite american and indian backing. india was dismembered when it lost over 35% of it's territory in the creation of Pakistan. Then losing over 38,000 square kms to China. india is a broken, dismembered country that has the greatest number of severely malnourished and poor people in the world. It is a truely a failed state in every respect with problems that dwarf the whole of Pakistan. After failing in everything and losing so much territory, india has no justifiable reason to exist anymore.

 

[kris]

You are looking for excuses but not addressing or explaining your points concisely. The biggest cheerleading comes from indians who claim that the bengalis and afghnas are going to fight Pakistan on their behalf.

Where didn't I answer precisely according to you.
You may number them so that I can reply

India really need not do anything for them to keep fighting you. They have deep rooted hatred with you.
No need to bring in india for your past

The BLA and Pustun movement are virtually dead now. CPEC killed them both off. Combined they both don't even number 1000. In fact, probably less than 500. That too despite american and indian backing. india was dismembered when it lost over 35% of it's territory in the creation of Pakistan. Then losing over 38,000 square kms to China. india is a broken, dismembered country that has the greatest number of severely malnourished and poor people in the world. It is a truely a failed state in every respect with problems that dwarf the whole of Pakistan. After failing in everything and losing so much territory, india has no justifiable reason to exist anymore.

If bla is defeated good for you.. then don't keep on pulling india name and how dense head you have to be calling india a dismembered state?
Even if india is a failed state it's none of your business.
We can take care of our problems
Please worry about your upcoming debt. Good if you won't go to IMF with a bowl again

No need to bring off topic terms.....

 

[Joe Shearer]

No...my response to u was separate in the context of ur post...
...he got his reply separately and in a rather harsh tone...which is sometimes necessary with ppl who are blatantly trolling.

Don't waste time on them; report them. I've got 5-minute responses!

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

There is hardly any racial or cultural heritage to be called for Pakistan.

And for calling india a failed state either you should be on someone's payroll or mentally immature..

Harrapa and Mohenjo Dara are situated in modern day Pakistan and are one of the most advanced civilizations of the ancient world........................they probably even predate Ancient Egypt. That is going back over 5000 years..................modern day Pakistanis are their descendants.

The uniqueness of Pakistani racial and cultural heritage is so different and alien to india and indians, you can never understand this. In fact, it is indians who have no culture or heritage.

Where didn't I answer precisely according to you.
You may number them so that I can reply

India really need not do anything for them to keep fighting you. They have deep rooted hatred with you.
No need to bring in india for your past


If bla is defeated good for you.. then don't keep on pulling india name and how dense head you have to be calling india a dismembered state?
Even if india is a failed state it's none of your business.
We can take care of our problems
Please worry about your upcoming debt. Good if you won't go to IMF with a bowl again

No need to bring off topic terms.....

Reality is that india is the biggest beggar on the planet who is also the biggest recipient of american aid. It also has a huge proportion of the world's poorest:

https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/half-world-s-poor-live-just-5-countries

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/sputniknews.com/amp/asia/201507141024617963/



Australia, Argentina, Spain, Italy and Greece have way more IMF debt than Pakistan do yet they are all astronomically superior to india in every way so your point about IMF is?............

 

[KhanBaba2]

Correction...no answer for u specifically(and others like u).

I have discussed such things with members like @Nilgiri(in the discord channel). Maybe u have the time to waste on internet nobodies...I don't. First establish urself as the kind of person who is worth discussing things with.

And yet you continue discussing with me.

 

[kris]

Even with nukes, india is still the biggest recipient of american aid and has the greatest number of severely malnourished and extreme poor people in the world:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...591/India-accused-of-poverty-smokescreen.html

https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/a-third-of-the-worlds-poor-live-in-india-says-un-45376

https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/half-world-s-poor-live-just-5-countries

https://wap.business-standard.com/a...-stunted-children-under-5-118121000073_1.html

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/sputniknews.com/amp/asia/201507141024617963/




Spain, Italy, Greece, Argentina and Australia have more IMF debt than Pakistan yet they leagues ahead of india in every respect so what's your point?

You won't throw gold just because it fell in mud, same doesn't apply to Pakistan

 

[The Accountant]

Please support your fraudulent claims

Lolz, I am not your teacher to educate you on a world known fact. Go and study yourself.

Don't have time for trolls like you

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

You won't throw gold just because it fell in mud, same doesn't apply to Pakistan

What gold can you have when you have the greatest number of severely malnourished and extreme poor people in the world? You are right that doesn't apply to Pakistan. Here is the reality of india and the indian people:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...-third-of-worlds-poorest-says-World-Bank.html

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...591/India-accused-of-poverty-smokescreen.html

https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/a-third-of-the-worlds-poor-live-in-india-says-un-45376

https://wap.business-standard.com/a...-stunted-children-under-5-118121000073_1.html

https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/half-world-s-poor-live-just-5-countries