Quran, Bible not central to soul of India, says culture minister Mahesh Sharma

[ThaniOruvan]

Wrong, Hinduism is an ideology imposed on the people of this region by foreign invaders.

You have absolutely nothing to claim being the original from this region.

We Pakistanis on the other hand have the whole Indus Valley Civilization behind us to claim that we are the real people from the region.

India is a fake country, a mere space and collection of forcefully occupied territories and states. That is why you have insurgencies in more than 20 states.

Now go figure.

Let me go check other posts for meaningful discussion instead of wasting time with you.

 

[coffee_cup]

Let me go check other posts for meaningful discussion instead of wasting time with you.

Are you 2nd, 3rd ID of people I addressed in my posts?

Just curious.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Wrong, Hinduism is an ideology imposed on the people of this region by foreign invaders.

You have absolutely nothing to claim being the original from this region.

We Pakistanis on the other hand have the whole Indus Valley Civilization behind us to claim that we are the real people from the region.

India is a fake country, a mere space and collection of forcefully occupied territories and states. That is why you have insurgencies in more than 20 states.

Now go figure.

Agreed.
100/100 in Pakistan Studies. Congos.

 

[Assange]

Whatever Hinduism is, it is as foreigner to the region as the claim from the Indian Tongue-Rambo about Islam, Christianity (and Judaism, which he did not name for obvious reasons, )

Second: Going by the antics of all those South Indians such as Ajit Devil and several others sitting in the top positions, your claim does not stand one bit. They are pure war mongering extremist nutcases.

Well let's keep Hinduism and other religious debate aside for now coz this will never end...

Well regarding India's NSA.....you are just because he is doing his job aggressively you are considering all South Indians are war mongers....this is like saying entire Muslim population is also terrorists because ISIS people are Muslim...I hope you understand....

 

[ThaniOruvan]

Are you 2nd, 3rd ID of people I addressed in my posts?

Just curious.

Are you a Muslim, If I may ask ......

 

[tested]

So paganism, paganism, paganism and paganism

Yeah. Trust us, its better than one true Terrorism.

 

[coffee_cup]

Agreed.
100/100 in Pakistan Studies. Congos.

Only because mythologies and no facts are being taught in your curriculum does not mean that reality will vanish.

India is a fake country. Stealing name from "British India" and forcefully occupying several independent states, you people think you have a natural country?

Not even close!

 

[ThaniOruvan]

Only because mythologies and no facts are being taught in your curriculum does not mean that reality will vanish.

India is a fake country. Stealing name from "British India" and forcefully occupying several independent states, you people think you have a natural country?

Not even close!

Yeah one such state revolted and got its own land, Pakistan !!
Soon another state revolted and got its own land, Bangladesh !!!
Lets see who is next to get their share from Pakistan.

 

[Srinivas]

Wrong, Hinduism is an ideology imposed on the people of this region by foreign invaders.

You have absolutely nothing to claim being the original from this region.

We Pakistanis on the other hand have the whole Indus Valley Civilization behind us to claim that we are the real people from the region.

India is a fake country, a mere space and collection of forcefully occupied territories and states. That is why you have insurgencies in more than 20 states.

Now go figure.

If you want to claim , convert to Hinduism and talk or claim. ( I am not asking you to convert either)

IVC has its part in Hindusim, but Hinduism is much more than that !

Hinduism itself is a modern and progressive philosophy.

 

[haviZsultan]

As a Muslim, you can barely even scratch the understanding, depth, history and links between the 4 great religions of India - Hinduism, Budhism, Sikhism and Jainism.

Ask any Jain, Budhist or Sikh. Whatever else they say they would not and do not like being lumped together as Hindus. Theirs is a separate religion. India does not even recognize this. We Lucknowis have constantly seen Indian shaitan policy of labelling our worship places and historical figures Hindu linked. For example Muhammed was mentioned in Gita and eating meat is haram in Islam. These claims show that India is bent on linking Hinduism with every other religion.

The approach is purely wrong and does not keep in mind the religious and ethnic diversity in Indian occupied regions. Each religion should be free to progress, even proselytize. Don't tell me what you think of Christian evangelists. Most Indians think its okay to attack them.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Only because mythologies and no facts are being taught in your curriculum does not mean that reality will vanish.

India is a fake country. Stealing name from "British India" and forcefully occupying several independent states, you people think you have a natural country?

Not even close!

You can't get more than 100. I can't give you more than that.

We Lucknowis have constantly seen Indian shaitan

Ctrl+F 'Lucknow'.... 1 result found.

 

[tested]

Ask any Jain, Budhist or Sikh. Whatever else they say they would not and do not like being lumped together as Hindus. Theirs is a separate religion. India does not even recognize this. We Lucknowis have constantly seen Indian shaitan policy of labelling our worship places and historical figures Hindu linked. For example Muhammed was mentioned in Gita and eating meat is haram in Islam. These claims show that India is bent on linking Hinduism with every other religion.

The approach is purely wrong and does not keep in mind the religious and ethnic diversity in Indian occupied regions. Each religion should be free to progress, even proselytize. Don't tell me what you think of Christian evangelists. Most Indians think its okay to attack them.

I really don't need a lecture about this.
There are a multitude of Sikhs and Budhists on this forum who have stated otherwise. You are free to talk to them regarding this.

I only stated that you lack the depth of thought to comprehend what these Dharmic religions are. Good day.

 

[coffee_cup]

If you want to claim , convert to Hinduism and talk or claim.

IVC has its part in Hindusim, but Hinduism is much more than that !

Hinduism itself is a modern and progressive philosophy.

Wrong on so many accounts.

Hinduism is an oppressive religion (at least it is made to look like one by the hardliner extremists in India). We have so many examples such as Ghar Wapsi, Beef ban, demolition of Mosques and Churches, Caste system etc etc. And right now the Indian Rambo culture minister's latest rantings.

But I do not want to debate Hinduism as a religion. Everyone is free to chose whatever he/she finds more suitable for him/her.

The fact remains: That Hinduism is a foreign religion to this region, only because it arrived a little earlier than Judaism, Islam or Christianity does not mean that the people in this region were Hindus from the beginning.

With time and generations people change their religions and their way of living. It is a continuous process.

So just stop claiming the heritage of this region, you have nothing to claim here!

 

[SarthakGanguly]

It is a continuous process.

Not it is not. Prophet Muhammad is the last messenger of Allah. You can't change anymore. The process of change for you is over.

The rest of your post is anti Hindu bigotry, so I will not reply to them.

 

[Srinivas]

Wrong on so many accounts.

Hinduism is an oppressive religion (at least it is made to look like one by the hardliner extremists in India). We have so many examples such as Ghar Wapsi, Beef ban, demolition of Mosques and Churches, Caste system etc etc. And right now the Indian Rambo culture minister's latest rantings.

Hinduism and Hindus are so oppressive that we have 14 % of Muslims and 2 % Christians in India. We are so oppressive that Jews, Zoroastrians and other people around the world migrated here to safe guard themselves from persecution.

you have no right to talk about tolerance , there some extremists every where and India is not exception but Indians are tolerant, Intolerant and delusional guys migrated to got separated in 1947.

When you say oppression I think you are pointing out the caste system which is becoming irrelevant with time in India.

But I do not want to debate Hinduism as a religion. Everyone is free to chose whatever he/she finds more suitable for him/her.

The fact remains: That Hinduism is a foreign religion to this region, only because it arrived a little earlier than Judaism, Islam or Christianity does not mean that the people in this region were Hindus from the beginning.

Rig Veda is the oldest written scripture in the world and some say it predates the date 4000 B.C which according to Bible this earth was created. No go figure out what you are talking here.

There is no proof that Vedas are written outside India.

With time and generations people change their religions and their way of living. It is a continuous process.

So just stop claiming the heritage of this region, you have nothing to claim here!

what heritage I am claiming here, am I claiming your Beef Biryani or Keema naan??