Plan B by Modi, retreat via Supreme Court : Sabir

[Novice09]

Modi has backed off when initially Rohingya were hit by Myanmar, Modi went to Myanmar for talks. But he immediately changed his gesture and started giving civilian goods worth $25 million in aid to Bangladesh.

What was his purpose for visiting Myanmar... did he ever supported the Rohingyas... I don't know...
Few links will be helpful...

Modi has also backed off from Ram Mandir when in November 2018, BJP started to make rallies. Then there was some deal struck with opposition according to which Modi backed off and started to take refuge in Supreme Court.

Was the decision was taken... like 370... in parliament... both are there in their manifesto...since inception... He always talked about resolving the issue AS PER CONSTITUTION...
Have you gone through the tactics used by the lawyers of Muslim parties... who are not leaving any stone un-turned to DELAY the decision...

Citizenship bill was another situation where Modi backed out.

It was passed in Lok Sabha... but was not passed by Rajya Sabha... and it lapsed like triple talaq bill...
Now, one is done and citizenship bill is pending...

No. Modi shouldn't and likely wouldn't back down. That world be political suicide.
But I feel that uncontrolled migration towards Kashmir shouldn't be allowed. Only the elites should be allowed, so that the local culture is not negatively impacted. Hill folk tend to have a nuanced culture.

do you really feel that uncontrolled migration will happen... and why should ONLY ELITES...

First priority is to bring back normalcy... other steps would be taken by keeping situation in mind...

 

[Smarana Mitra]

The current Kashmiris are invaders and only solution is to expel. I don't see how land can belong to anyone who just comes and settles there. We don't need the current batch of Kashmiris but we only need the Kashmir land.

This is the problem with India and Kashmr. Quoting you.
"Kashmiris are unreasonable and hence nothing that India does will change te situation."

Forget Pakistan, as long as India doesnt engage and willing to assimilate Kashmiri's it has no right on their land.

Was the decision was taken... like 370... in parliament... both are there in their manifesto...since inception... He always talked about resolving the issue AS PER CONSTITUTION...
Have you gone through the tactics used by the lawyers of Muslim parties... who are not leaving any stone un-turned to DELAY the decision...

Nonsensical argument. BJP could have passed an ordnance and resolved the issue then and there. It is a political issue and must be solved politically. Going to Court is really cowardly act.

It was passed in Lok Sabha... but was not passed by Rajya Sabha... and it lapsed like triple talaq bill...
Now, one is done and citizenship bill is pending

The voting was not even conducted in Rajya Sabha. It was merely an excuse of not having majority. How did BJP pass J&K reorganisation act without majority? BJP could have arranged or went aggressive about it. But it was chosen to back off

 

[Shabi1]

The current Kashmiris are invaders and only solution is to expel. I don't see how land can belong to anyone who just comes and settles there. We don't need the current batch of Kashmiris but we only need the Kashmir land.



Nonsensical argument. BJP could have passed an ordnance and resolved the issue then and there. It is a political issue and must be solved politically. Going to Court is really cowardly act.


The voting was not even conducted in Rajya Sabha. It was merely an excuse of not having majority. How did BJP pass J&K reorganisation act without majority? BJP could have arranged or went aggressive about it. But it was chosen to back off

So you only want Kashmiri land not their people. Nothing left to say, case rested.

 

[Whirling_dervesh]

The current Kashmiris are invaders and only solution is to expel. I don't see how land can belong to anyone who just comes and settles there. We don't need the current batch of Kashmiris but we only need the Kashmir land.



Nonsensical argument. BJP could have passed an ordnance and resolved the issue then and there. It is a political issue and must be solved politically. Going to Court is really cowardly act.


The voting was not even conducted in Rajya Sabha. It was merely an excuse of not having majority. How did BJP pass J&K reorganisation act without majority? BJP could have arranged or went aggressive about it. But it was chosen to back off

What utter baloney....can you back that with hard unbiased evidence? Not hindutva revisionism please.

The valley kashmiris are as indigenous as it gets

 

[Verve]

Do you think India would retreat from its unilateral actions in Kashmir and reverse its changes in the Constitution of India via decision of Supreme Court of India!!

Does such a move favour Fascists' Israeli masters and planners?

Hindutvas will overrun their SC as well.

 

[Kabira]

As if situation in IoK will get more worse? Doubt it.

 

[newb3e]

ya haray tv anchor itnay chumpo kesay hain?

 

[Max]

But fall back route for what situation? There is no diplomatic pressure on Modi as such.

Human rights violations? Bharat don't give fk.

 

[Pakistan Space Agency]

India is not going to retreat, it'll be political suicide for the Government if it did. Besides, even if they weren't serious in the first place, they've at least learnt how weak a Pakistani response has been to this due an inexperienced Government in power.

Pakistan needs to conduct nuclear tests to make India understand it cannot unilaterally annex Kashmir, however, I don't think PM Khan or the military has the guts to do anything like that.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

I said the same long before Sabir Shakir.

Indian supreme court is "get out of jail card" for Indian establishment, if things goes out of hands.

 

[chander_011]

Does anyone in Pakistan knows, 'how our Indian democracy works!' Indian voters are so happy and excited by this decision to scrap article 370. Do you know why? The answer is simple. We were all very disappointed with the previous handling of the situation which never ends. Our soldiers die and our previous government response was always like they cannot do anything and cannot change the ground realities. Atleast Our PM Modi has courage to take risk and finish the unfinished agenda. Even Mr. Hooda a prominent leader of Congress in Haryana challenged the high command that Congress is following the wrong path by not endorsing this move and Congress party should support this move. Let me make myself clear that Neither I voted for Mr. Modi i.e. BJP nor I like the RSS ideology but I liked this step of Modi. I voted for Kejriwal and will do so in Delhi assembly elections next year.

 

[Psychic]

Don't forget that India already has large number of troops in Kashmir before scrapping Article 370. There was hardly any different response from Kashmiris earlier. So, India gains nothing by backing off. Kashmiris are unreasonable and hence nothing that India does will change te situation. So, backing off from Article 370 makes no sense

And India is the most reasonable nation on the face of this planet.
Indians never lie, always fulfil their promises, abide by agreements and follow UN resolutions to the letter.

 

[Dil Pakistan]

Does anyone in Pakistan knows, 'how our Indian democracy works!' Indian voters are so happy and excited by this decision to scrap article 370. Do you know why? The answer is simple. We were all very disappointed with the previous handling of the situation which never ends. Our soldiers die and our previous government response was always like they cannot do anything and cannot change the ground realities. Atleast Our PM Modi has courage to take risk and finish the unfinished agenda. Even Mr. Hooda a prominent leader of Congress in Haryana challenged the high command that Congress is following the wrong path by not endorsing this move and Congress party should support this move. Let me make myself clear that Neither I voted for Mr. Modi i.e. BJP nor I like the RSS ideology but I liked this step of Modi. I voted for Kejriwal and will do so in Delhi assembly elections next year.

Yes! we do know how your democracy works.....it works by defying the constitution....it works by making the Hindus as the only nation to be allowed to live in this land....it works by murderers getting freedom from the courts.....it works by lynching 20,000 people in Gujarat and not a single person is apprehended.

 

[Psychic]

Yes! we do know how your democracy works.....it works by defying the constitution....it works by making the Hindus as the only nation to be allowed to live in this land....it works by murderers getting freedom from the courts.....it works by lynching 20,000 people in Gujarat and not a single person is apprehended.

Indian democracy has turned into "tyranny of the majority".

 

[Soumitra]

Sabir Shakir says that BJP/Modi had plan B, at which the work has already
started in India. He thinks that BJP/Modi were not expecting the response all around the world. He also thinks that the information India got from the closed door UNSC session is that their actions in Kashmir were not appreciated.

Do you think India would retreat from its unilateral actions in Kashmir and reverse its changes in the Constitution of India via decision of Supreme Court of India!!

Modi will not back track. This has been BJP's core agenda since the beginning. In the 1950's only Jana Sangh the precursor of BJP was founded on that.

There is a very famous picture of a young Modi demonstrating against Article 370.

Believe it or not - majority of the people , even those who dont support the BJP are supporting this move. The only problem some of them have is the way it was done. But belive you me, this was the only way and Modi was the only person who could do it.

He is not going to backtrack. It will be political suicide for him.

And one more thing. The SC is NOT going to overturn it. Modi is like a chess player. He thinks 10 moves ahead of his opponents.

lynching 20,000 people in Gujarat

I think you missed a couple of zeros