Farah Sohail
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2012
- Messages
- 7,228
- Reaction score
- 4
- Country
- Location
although one judge was still confused.. phir he had to resort to even a lesser punishment/ no punishment.
he knew that abb long run main bhi nikal jaega.. he thought ke lets name him GODFATHER.. at least NS will be called a mafia head from now on..
His verdict was very balanced.. but he changed the tone later.. after feeling helpless..
.
@bold... Was tht one judge Justiec Ijazul Ahsan?..who changed his mind later? But i still dont doubt his intentions though... Haan pakora judge aur advocate ki neeyat par mujhe poora poora shak hai...but I dont doubt Justice Ijazul Ahsan's intentions..still..even if he changed his mind later..
@ red.. What u say is very much possible.. I love him, if this really is the case... Kiun ke its obvious from his verdict tht he wrote this judgment with utter disgust and contempt for the sharif family.. Sirf disqualification ki baat nahi hai.. ......I hate sharif family to the core...but even I was surprised at his tone..ke kia waqayi...koi itni harsh /sarcastic language ek legal document main use karsakta hai..tht too against the sitting PM? Esp when talking abt qatari prince..he remarked..a friend in need is a friend indeed..
Aur aap ki woh baat theek lagti hai..ke inke saath ab bhtt bura honay wala hai... Justice Khosa ne extreme risk liya hai..even Justice Gulzar too., they both have taken extreme risk.... If disqualification was the majority verdict...tab shayad itna farq na parta..because it would then have been implemented...aur nawaz sharif ke liye kuch karna thora sa mushkil hota..
In 2 judges ko pata tha ke inn ki judgment implement nahi hosakti... Phir bhi ITNIII ZIADA harsh tone use karna? Tht too against a sitting PM? Kia inhein Nawaz Sharif ki history nahi pata..ke kaisy SC par hamla kiya tha? Even if army had given them security assurance to the judges earlier on...lekin agar disqualification majority verdict hota..tab itni mushkil na hoti... Ab tu inhon ne sitting PM ko openly dare aur challenge kia hai... Aur bhtt ziada harsh tone use ki hai... Mujhe lagta hai ke inke aur inki family ke liye bhtt risk hai..esp given the history of PML N..
PML N and their social media is extremely pissed off at Justice Khosa, since he write the main dissenting note..tht too in such harsh tone... Infact ek news TV par ye bhi chali thee..tht PM is thinking to go for review..esp against Justice Khosa's remarks..they think he overstepped and used political statements... PM has asked his legal team to give their opinion on this...I am sure..they wouldnt eventually go for appeal..ke uska faida nahi hoga..as scope of review is extremely limited..but atleast this shows tht PM is extrenely pissed off..at Justice Khosa.... So unke liye bhtt ziada risky situation hai..
I am afraid ..aur kuch nahi...tu koi defamation campaign zuroor start hosakti hai.. Gen Raheel ne tu kuch kiya hi nahi tha, PML N ke against..uske bawajood...unko defame kiya... Justice Khosa aur Gulzar ke saath tu jo karein ye log...woh kam hai...esp Justice Khosa ke against
Kia farq parta
Justice Khosa and Gulzar won't even bother reading the JIT report.. They have already made up their mind.. It is only one judge who still has to make up his mind..
Advocate is minority in many aspects of the judgment.. So he won't matter.. But I am talking about the implementation of this judgment in developed countries, not in Pakistan.. In Pakistan you can expect anything..
Mujhe tu lagta hai..ke unless and until its a legal requirement...jaisy Justice Wajih keh rahay thay ke aisy cases ko part heard (?) kaha jaata hai.... Agar legal requirement na hui...tu ye dono dissenting judges us bench main bethein ge hi nahi... Woh khud hi Chief Justice ko keh dien ge ke humara naam na daalein
Haan ...agar legal requirement hui..tu zuroor bethein ge... Us situation main sirf Justice Ijazul Ahsan ko aur convince hona hoga.. And i think ke shayad woh ho bhi jayein.. Kiun ke Justice Wajihuddin keh rahay thay...ke findings of JIT will be not be final and legally binding... Judges will have authority to reject those findings... So maybe Justice Ijazul Ahsan ko convince karna itna mushkil na ho........because unka due process wala objection tu khatam hogaya hoga...