What's new

Pakistanis create rival Muslim Facebook

Status
Not open for further replies.

fawwaxs

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
2,125
Reaction score
-2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Saudi Arabia
ISLAMABAD: Pakistanis outraged with Facebook over “blasphemous” caricatures of the Prophet Mohammed have created a spin-off networking site that they dream can connect the world's 1.6 billion Muslims, reports AFP.

A group of six young IT professionals from Lahore, the cultural and entertainment capital of Pakistan, Launched MillatFacebook.com - Social Networking Place for Every One on Tuesday for Muslims to interact online and protest against blasphemy.

The private venture came after a Pakistani court ordered a block on Facebook until May 31, following deep offence over an “Everyone Draw Mohammed Day” page considered “blasphemous” and “sacrilegious”.

“Millatfacebook is Pakistan's very own, first social networking site. A site for Muslims by Muslims where sweet people of other religions are also welcome,” the website tells people interested in signing up.

Dubbed MFB, after Facebook's moniker FB, its founder says professionals are working around the clock to offer features similar to those pioneered by the wildly popular California-based prototype.

Each member has a “wall” for friends to comment on. The site offers email, photo, video, chat and discussion board facilities.

The Urdu word “Millat” is used by Muslims to refer to their nation. The website claims to have attracted 4,300 members in the last three days — mostly English-speaking Pakistanis in their 20s.

The number of aficionados may be growing, but the community is a drop in the ocean of the 2.5 million Facebook fans in Pakistan and there have been some scathing early reviews of the start-up.

Neither has Facebook been immediately reachable for comment.

“We want to tell Facebook people 'if they mess with us they have to face the consequences',” said Usman Zaheer, the 24-year-old chief operating officer of the software house that hosts the new site.

“If someone commits blasphemy against our Prophet Mohammed then we will become his competitor and give him immense business loss,” he told AFP, dreaming of making “the largest Muslim social networking website”.

Once signed up, members are a click away from debate on the bulletin board.

For example, “Enticing Fury” wrote: “The reason is that this forum must be reserved for ALL MUSLIMS OF THE WORLD and not only Pakistan. So using the word MILLAT is very good!

“Well done guys. You have made a great alternative for the whole Muslim ummah (nation)!”

But the nascent quality of the work-in-progress website has preoccupied and dismayed some, as well as drawn at least one damning newspaper review.

One member wrote: “they need 2 have more info”.

Another posted a mournful: “need games here as well. I miss cafe world” referring to the popular Facebook page where members can run their own virtual cafe.

“It was a good idea... as it can give us a forum to connect, but its reach is too limited,” Mohammad Adeel, a 31-year-old pharmacist told AFP in Karachi, who joined to keep up with friends he missed due to the Facebook ban.

Local newspaper was crushing. “The quality of user experience is so abysmal that it does not merit the humble title, 'Facebook clone',” it wrote online.

“To sum up, MillatFacebook is a bold effort... but it is unlikely to capture a large audience, judging by the online experience it offers currently.”

But Zaheer is pleased with his handiwork, saying the site has already attracted members living in Britain, Bulgaria, Canada, China, Russia, the United Arab Emirates and the United States.

Pakistani law student Rana Adeel, 21, signed up to MillatFB in Lahore after receiving invites through SMS and email from friends.

“In two days, I got more than seven friends. If the Facebook ban is lifted, I'll keep networking on both,” he told AFP.

DAWN.COM | Sci-Tech | Pakistanis create rival Muslim Facebook
 
. . .
honestly...... facebook can actually sue them for copying the theme
 
.
Questions:

Why name it Millatfacebook? I mean it could have been something more original then adding a prefix to facebook. Will that raise IPR or CR violations?

The backend is all exactly like facebook and the changes are just cosmetic. Is this not another case of ICR violations?
 
.
honestly...... facebook can actually sue them for copying the theme

And how will they do that?

Theres no copyright laws in South Asia. If there were, then Pakistani musicians would've sued bollywood a long time ago.


Each country has their own laws. Those Pakistanis who came up with the website are in Pakistan and as long as they follow the law of their country they are fine.
 
.
And how will they do that?

Theres no copyright laws in South Asia. If there were, then Pakistani musicians would've sued bollywood a long time ago.

well i dont how will they do that...

my whole point was that its a copy at best. kind of revenge for blasphemy :undecided:
 
.
And how will they do that?

Theres no copyright laws in South Asia. If there were, then Pakistani musicians would've sued bollywood a long time ago.


Each country has their own laws. Those Pakistanis who came up with the website are in Pakistan and as long as they follow the law of their country they are fine.

Maybe like suing the host servers?
 
.
And how will they do that?

Theres no copyright laws in South Asia. If there were, then Pakistani musicians would've sued bollywood a long time ago.

Each country has their own laws. Those Pakistanis who came up with the website are in Pakistan and as long as they follow the law of their country they are fine.

No India has very strong copy Right laws .
And those who are outraged by copy right infringements ,can easily stop the release of a film and can persecute its makers.

For Pakistani musicians ,i would say they don't raise their voices as they get tangential benefit in terms of publicity ,access to a far bigger marker for products even a bollywood stints enjoyed by quote a few Pakistani artists by now.
 
.
I want to ask ,
Is Muslim a religion only in pakistan?
the westerners created Muhammad's cartoon
was it an attack on Pakistan?
There are other muslim nations like Iraq,Afganisthan etc.they didn't ban Facebook
Why are Pakistani's so overreacting?
 
.
I want to ask ,
Is Muslim a religion only in pakistan?
the westerners created Muhammad's cartoon
was it an attack on Pakistan?
There are other muslim nations like Iraq,Afganisthan etc.they didn't ban Facebook
Why are Pakistani's so overreacting?

bcuz we have nothin better to do....:pakistan::lol:
 
. .
This cheap copy will be a failure just like during second gulf war few intelligent muslims started "Mecca Cola" and "Qibla Cola" with much fanfare to cater to muslims who would be against american companies like Coca-cola and Pepsi Cola.
 
.
This cheap copy will be a failure just like during second gulf war few intelligent muslims started "Mecca Cola" and "Qibla Cola" with much fanfare to cater to muslims who would be against american companies like Coca-cola and Pepsi Cola.

There is no cheapness in copying a design.. If its a good model anybody can copy it.

Its not competing with Face-book, its like any other social networking sites.
Even in India there are many social networking sites which are not successful.

So no need for comparison or judging it as a failure from the start.

And no need to bring cola comparison when India has also banned coca cola not so long ago and bringing something called campa cola.

campa.jpg
 
.
There is no cheapness in copying a design.. If its a good model anybody can copy it.

Its not competing with Face-book, its like any other social networking sites.
Even in India there are many social networking sites which are not successful.

So no need for comparison or judging it as a failure from the start.

And no need to bring cola comparison when India has also banned coca cola not so long ago and bringing something called campa cola.

campa.jpg

There were trying to put their cheap imitations & asking all the muslims to abandon their Coke & Pepsi and drink their own product "Mecca Cola" & "Qibla Cola" as they were made by Muslims.

In that's sense it was a cheap way of marketing your products.

There is no comparision with India banning coke in 1970's , India did not start a Hindu Cola or something similar.

This act of putting up a Muslim Ony facebook clone is trying to gain cheap publicity nothing more.

I think that clone will be a failure and wont see 1st Anniversary.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom