What's new

Pakistan must change Currency Notes to get $77 billion hidden in homes

Demonetisation: Success

In my personal opinion right move, but was carried out the wrong way.

The announcement was sudden and unscheduled. In the days following the demonetisation, the country faced severe cash shortages with severe detrimental effects across the economy. People seeking to exchange their bank notes had to stand in lengthy queues, and several deaths were linked to the inconveniences caused due to the rush to exchange cash. As the cash shortages grew in the weeks following the move, the demonetization was heavily criticised by prominent economists and by world media.


Demonetization positive effect on Indian economy.

The Indian Economic Survey has also clarified that income tax collections have touched new high with demonetization and introduction of GST, “From about 2 percent of GDP between 2013-14 and 2015-16, they are likely to rise to 2.3 percent of GDP in 2017-18, a historic high.”

1)Demonetization policy of the Government has been termed as the greatest financial reform that aimed to curb the black money, corruption and counterfeit currency notes

2)Demonetization was done to help India to become corruption-free as it will be difficult now to keep the unaccounted cash

3)Demonetization will help the Indian government to track the black money and the unaccounted cash will now flow no more and the amount collected by means of tax can be better utilized for the public welfare and development schemes.

4)Money laundering will eventually come to halt as the activity can easily be tracked and the money can be seized by the authorities.

5)Demonetization aimed to stop the running of parallel economy due to circulation of fake currency as the banning of Rs.500 and Rs. 1000 notes will eliminate their circulation.

6)The unaccounted cash could be deposited in the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Yojana (amnesty scheme launched by the Narendra Modi led Government of India in December 2016 )after paying 50% tax. The money will remain deposited for 4 years with the bank without incurring any interest. However, after 4 years the amount will be returned. This amount can be utilized for social welfare schemes and making the life of low income groups better.

7)The Public Sector Banks which were reeling under deposit crunch and were running short of funds have suddenly swelled with lot of money which can be used for future finances and loans after keeping a certain amount of reserve as per RBI guidelines.The people who opened the Jan Dhan accounts ( universal access to banking facilities to the people in the country)will now use their accounts and become familiar with banking activity.

My favorite effects ↓↓
8)Demonetization has driven the country towards a cashless society. Lakhs of the people even in remote rural areas have started resorting to use the cashless transactions. The move has promoted banking activities. Now even the small transactions have started going through banking channels and the small savings have turned into a huge national asset.

9)The high rising price pattern and inflationary trends which the Indian economy was facing are taking a down turn making the living possible within low income group reach.

it's obvious people hiding the cash under matters will call this a ridiculous move, but the positive long term effects are very good.
 
People are retarded to think demonisation or note ban is a good idea. If IK does it then he should be thrown out of office. Inregards to modi, he has a God/Emperor complex, the policy was and is a failure. So many reasons for why it did not work, only supreme modi says it is a success.

The retarded pakistanis who think it is a good idea, please be silent. You on par with modi on this issue.

Sorry to be harsh in language. It annoys me that people think its a great idea. The lost work days of people queueing, people starving and more reasons. The rich have already converted money in foreign currency and in precious metals. The poor have not.
 
Last edited:
One of the reasons Pakistan supported the action is because Pakistan will soon be doing something similar on one of its neighbors if things dont work out...
 
what is demonetization ;-

it is the government's effort to end cash based black economy by 'banning' large bank notes ( or eliminating cash altogether) and instead forcing people to use banks

the idea is to get more tax revenue, control over wealth , and monitoring via banks

does it work ;-

demonetization failed in india . the banks there are too few in numbers to serve the huge population ( cash is convenient) . banks are also not to be trusted . PMC bank in India just defaulted and people's saving are gone .

can it work in pakistan ?

people will never let go their cash savings and put in banks to be taxed, monitored, controlled . period.

plus, people have a choice now, they can use crypto currencies to protect their wealth from govt fascism like demonetization
 
https://www.chitralnews.com/pakistan-must-change-currency-notes-to-get-77-billion-hidden-in-homes
“At least Rs 5 Trillion black money is hidden in Pakistani homes”, claimed Aqeel Kareem Dheede who has been given presidential award on 23rd March 2019, in a live TV program. If Pakistan government really want to get out of this financial crisis, they must immediately change the design of five thousand and one thousand and Rs. 500 currency notes. Government should give 30 days notes to deposit all the money in the banks or it will be invalid after 30 days.

Recovery from the Agha Siraj Durrani Speaker of the Sind Assembly
sddefault.jpg

It seems only armed forces and poor people are sacrificing their lives, limbs and wealth by indirect taxations and increasing oil prices. The un-patriotic elite of Pakistan is stealing wealth of Pakistan and sending abroad in bulks. The armed forces and intelligence agencies must launch special classified operation like they were doing in 5% FATA while 95% is being looted by the corrupt civil servants, politicians and businessmen. Pakistan’s current judicial system is cancerous and corrupt, can not deliver the results. Special military courts are the only solution to get the money back from these criminals. Shaukat Aziz introduced highest currency notes of Rs 5000 to make money laundering and black economy easy.

“Money laundering cannot happen without the cooperation of corrupt bankers and printing of high denomination currency notes is step one to money laundering”, few years ago I said to the Colombian ambassador to London in the British parliament at ‘ABC Colombia’ which is chaired by Jeremy Corbyn now leader of the Labour Party.

Pakistani media reported that: “Pakistan’s Supreme Court has been informed that transactions of more than 100 billion Pakistani rupees ($77 billion) have been carried out through 107 fake bank accounts, the authorities said.

According to the reports, a three-member bench of the country’s top court on Monday resumed the hearing of its suo-motu case on an investigation into money-laundering and fake bank accounts, reports Xinhua news agency.

A joint investigation team of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) has submitted a report to the apex court, revealing that the transactions of 47 billion Pakistani rupees have been done through fake bank accounts and 54 billion Pakistani rupees were transferred through the fictitious accounts of 36 companies.

Several fictitious accounts at some private banks were opened in 2013, 2014 and 2015, and illegal transactions worth billions of rupees were made through these accounts, according to investigation team.

The FIA has been investigating 32 people in the case, the reports added. Earlier, the Pakistani Interior Ministry barred 95 persons suspected to be involved in the case from leaving the country.

Former president Asif Ali Zardari, his sister FaryalTalpur and their associates are accused of sending Rs.35 billion abroad through fake accounts after which, their names were placed on Exit Control List (ECL).

FIA had prepared a report, revealing that more than 10 political personalities were allegedly involved in fictitious transactions worth Rs.35 billion.

“A Joint Investigation Team (JIT) tasked with probing fake bank accounts submitted a progress report in the Supreme Court on Monday which revealed that transactions of Rs54 billion were made through 107 fake bank accounts.

An FIA JIT had been investigating a 2015 case regarding fake accounts and fictitious transactions conducted through ‘benami’ accounts in Summit Bank, Sindh Bank and UBL.

Seven individuals, including PPP Co-Chairman Asif Zardari and his sister Faryal Talpur, were said to be involved in using those accounts for suspicious transactions. The accounts were allegedly used to channel funds received through kickbacks. While hearing a suo motu case regarding a delay in the FIA probe into the case, the SC had constituted a JIT to probe into the matter.” The daily Dawn reported on 22 Oct 2018.

Pakistan’s FIA Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) on traced banking transactions worth over Rs4 bln from fake accounts opened on the name of a dead man identified as Mohammad Iqbal.

As per details garnered, Mohammad Iqbal had passed away on May 9, 2014. All fake bank accounts were opened in three branches of the same private bank.

Sources privy to development stated that both FIA and joint investigation team [constituted on the directives of Supreme Court (SC)] were separately probing the incident.

On the other hand, JIT questioned Korangi’s Sarwat and recorded her statement. Sarwat—on whose name fake bank account was opened—distanced herself while asserting that she was unaware of the account.

Apart from bank account, a fake company was also registered on Sarwat’s name whereas she was supposed to give Rs11 million in terms of tax.

Fake accounts are on the rise in Pakistan, at some place any hawker becomes billionaire while on the other a nurse gets millionaire, of course by doing nothing. The matter took hype especially after a Karachi’s falooda seller Abdul Qadir turned out to be a billionaire. He was baffled and wanted to know the notice issued to him by FIA.

At the time of opening an account, genuine CNIC and other relevant information are required and in case of a person living abroad, a passport is needed but fake accounts are being opened and being operated in spite of strict criteria.

(Dr Shahid Qureshi is senior analyst with BBC and chief editor of The London Post. He writes on security, terrorism and foreign policy. He also appears as analyst on Al-Jazeera, Press TV, MBC, Kazak TV (Kazakhstan), LBC Radio London. He was also international election observer for Azerbaijan April 2018, Kazakhstan 2015 and 2016 and Pakistan 2002. He has written a famous book “War on Terror and Siege of Pakistan” published in 2009. At Government College Lahore he wrote his MA thesis on ‘Political Thought of Imam Khomeini’ and visited Tehran University. He is PhD in ‘Political Psychology’ and studied Law at a British University. He also speaks at Cambridge University. He is a visiting Professor at Hebe University in China.)
We have just been on stabalization path.
Also when your traders and retailers openly say that we would not give tax do whatever you may nor document ourselves and do business as usual.
When you retailers threaten government who ask them to come in to tax net and even ready for fix net.
When you big industrialist are just running in subcidies. And looting common people.
And you want government to do this
So as to create the mess that happened in India demonetisation that Indian economy has not come out yet .
 
I think it was a brilliant move, but the real question is 'did it work?'



Those look like EUROS and other European Currency notes, possibly equal to hundreds of millions or perhaps even Billions of USD. It has to be a FAKE picture.


Demonetization is a stupid Idea
Since the corrupt will find a way to white wash the black money into white
Indian house holds were supposed to be holding over 180billion USD in black cash
Anyone depositing more than Rs 5 lac was supposed to be questioned by the Income Tax Department.

But what really happened
99.5 % of the black money got deposited into bank. Only Rs 60000 crores of black money holders were apprehended and had to pay 50% tax on their money, most of these holders were middle class or upper middle class people without the access to ways to convert their black money

In the end Demonetization caused a slowdown in the economic activity since it pretty much destroyed the hidden economy or unorganized sectors which contribute a significant portion of jobs .

Indian economy was growing at 7% now it's growing at 5%, all thanks to demonetization
Your economic growth is 2.5 % under Kaptaan.
Do u really want demonetization since your unorganized sector is closed to 40% of GDP compared to 25% in case of India.
 
I think it was a brilliant move, but the real question is 'did it work?'



Those look like EUROS and other European Currency notes, possibly equal to hundreds of millions or perhaps even Billions of USD. It has to be a FAKE picture.
It won't. Look the mess it created in India.
You have to tighten the noose but don't create panic . Let people adjust to little strictness. Use carrot and stick approach give incentive and use force. Such as they are doing. If big retailers register by Dec 1 they would pay only 14 percent otherwise fined heavily
 
Kuch nahi hoga sif log sif dollar khareedege.
 
Demonetization is a stupid Idea
Since the corrupt will find a way to white wash the black money into white
Indian house holds were supposed to be holding over 180billion USD in black cash
Anyone depositing more than Rs 5 lac was supposed to be questioned by the Income Tax Department.

But what really happened
99.5 % of the black money got deposited into bank. Only Rs 60000 crores of black money holders were apprehended and had to pay 50% tax on their money, most of these holders were middle class or upper middle class people without the access to ways to convert their black money

In the end Demonetization caused a slowdown in the economic activity since it pretty much destroyed the hidden economy or unorganized sectors which contribute a significant portion of jobs .

Indian economy was growing at 7% now it's growing at 5%, all thanks to demonetization
Your economic growth is 2.5 % under Kaptaan.
Do u really want demonetization since your unorganized sector is closed to 40% of GDP compared to 25% in case of India.

demonetization is nothing but a pervert desire of fascist central banks to have a cashless society where every transaction can be tagged, monitored and taxed .

not that cash is a holy grail( the central bank can debase/ devalue currency any time) , yet for an averge joe small trader, cash is blood and his life savings .

im now afraid that the fools incharge of running the pak economy would do this stupidity next and crash land the economy altogether
 
New Currency is due !!!:agree::smokin::chilli:

4201970224434630824.jpg


  • All Old currency should be replaced by transferring old notes to a Bank Account and then withdrawals are made from Bank accounts, After 30 days
  • Sum at 5 Lakh Rupee or less will be Taxed 5%
  • Sum larger than more than 5 lakh to 1 Crore Rupee will be taxed 7%
  • Sum larger than 5 Crore Rupee will be taxed 10%


People who paid tax on this figure would get a certificate from the bank that they have paid tax on this "Cash" deposit
which they were hoarding in their closets


If you don't bring out your cash !!! The currency note will expire and it will worthless
 
Last edited:
Demonetization in India was a failure in achieving its stated goals.

How so? The time frame analysis for that was always a much longer one (regd broader formalisation impact compared to a now hypothetical world where demonetisation was not done).

Jobs:

https://www.businesstoday.in/sector...ia-formalise-7-million-jobs/story/357079.html

https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...2015-report/articleshow/69842971.cms?from=mdr

Tax:

https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...ome-above-rs-1-crore/articleshow/71549734.cms

The income tax department begun extensive use of data post the demonetisation announced on November 8, 2016. Data from bank deposits made during the period were used to nab those who were not declaring true incomes, which the department claims led to increase in compliance. About 6.21 crore returns were filed up to December 2018. These included returns for past assessment years that taxpayers filed to comply.

============

Use of cash for general day to day liquidity is the only thing thats not meeting the first projections made, but that comes more from the follow up (lack of E-infra and also the dumb decision to pursue 2000 Rs notes)....but that can also be learned from and used in later policy reform measures too.

Over-leftie media (found as the default norm in any country) can only think in over-leftie simplistic terms (because thats just the easiest thing to sell to the masses as they perceive it - and the media is mostly a business of which hypocrisy can bray the loudest in the end).

Its why they always had a hard on for GOSPLAN kind of stuff (in the short term emotional churn they love, salt and peppered by sputnik breakout kind of movements)....and we all know how that turned out in the end...in final reality....with the requisite time for proper analysis actually given. Its not without reason the same kind of brigade was painting up a whole election to be lost just because of this one issue "perception" that they completely got sold on themselves....rather than sampling the public opinion adequately on....and again the result in the end spoke for itself verdict wise.

Demonetization is a stupid Idea
Since the corrupt will find a way to white wash the black money into white
Indian house holds were supposed to be holding over 180billion USD in black cash
Anyone depositing more than Rs 5 lac was supposed to be questioned by the Income Tax Department.

But what really happened
99.5 % of the black money got deposited into bank. Only Rs 60000 crores of black money holders were apprehended and had to pay 50% tax on their money, most of these holders were middle class or upper middle class people without the access to ways to convert their black money

In the end Demonetization caused a slowdown in the economic activity since it pretty much destroyed the hidden economy or unorganized sectors which contribute a significant portion of jobs .

Indian economy was growing at 7% now it's growing at 5%, all thanks to demonetization
Your economic growth is 2.5 % under Kaptaan.
Do u really want demonetization since your unorganized sector is closed to 40% of GDP compared to 25% in case of India.

Here's a good example of a very simplistic analysis.
 
New Currency is due !!!:agree::smokin::chilli:

4201970224434630824.jpg


  • All Old currency should be replaced by transferring old notes to a Bank Account and then withdrawals are made from Bank accounts, After 30 days
  • Sum at 5 Lakh Rupee or less will be Taxed 5%
  • Sum larger than more than 5 lakh to 1 Crore Rupee will be taxed 7%
  • Sum larger than 5 Crore Rupee will be taxed 10%

People who paid tax on this figure would get a certificate from the bank that they have paid tax on this "Cash" deposit
which they were hoarding in their closets


If you don't bring out your cash !!! The currency note will expire and it will worthless
That is a dumb approach. What happens to ppl who have already paid the due tax on that money...and then were keeping some of it at home? They have to pay taxes again? That is beyond unreasonable.

What about the black money that is not in rupees? How can u force ppl to exchange their black money that they have in Euros, Dollars, Pounds, etc? How are they going to address the black money in bank accounts abroad? This above approach would fail to address the issue of black money...it would have very little impact. The ppl most affected would be the middle class who might have a few lakhs around...that might have been their white money on which they have already paid the taxes. If Imran Khan is serious about solving this issue then he should first go after the looted wealth that is kept abroad...that's where the majority of it can be found.
 
If this is true. Do it. Make the lives of wealthy a bit tougher. I am included in this.
Tax net has expanded visibily. With time people will adjust and with honest leadership people will know their money is being spent on the country.
 
Back
Top Bottom