What's new

Pakistan Elections 2018: News and Discussions

IPOR survey finds PML-N leading in Punjab, PTI gaining ground

Listen





337126_358695_akhbar.jpg


ISLAMABAD: A constituency-wise survey of entire Punjab has found the PML-N maintaining popularity despite the ongoing corruption trial of Nawaz Sharif, disqualification of its prominent leaders, and defection of so-called electables.

Although, the PML-N is ahead with 51 percent vote bank, it has largely preserved its vote with only a 2 percent increase in comparison with 2013. This is in contrast with the significant increase in PTI's vote -- from 19 percent in 2013 to 30 percent in 2018.

Exclusive: How will Pakistan vote in elections 2018

The Institute of Public Opinion Research (IPOR) conducted the survey with the biggest-ever sample size of 200,349 respondents from the province. The opinion poll was carried out between April 15 and June 2 this year with a response rate of over 72 percent. All National Assembly constituencies of Punjab (141) were surveyed with average sample size of 1,420 respondents from each constituency. This is in contrast with most country-wide surveys, where the total respondents generally range between 3,000 and 4,000.

According to the survey, the PML-N is ahead of the PTI with 5:3 ratio of voters. The majority of these respondents said loadshedding significantly decreased in the past five years and posed trust in the performance of their MNAs and MPAs in terms of development work. But respondents also identified three most important issues they face: access to clean drinking water, gas, and sewerage. Health, education, unemployment and corruption received the lowest scores in their priority list.

Survey findings indicate that the PTI largely took away the PPP vote in Punjab, which has now been reduced to 5 percent from 11 percent in 2013, as many PPP leaders switched to the PTI in addition to the PML-Q leaders. Imran Khan’s party is also considered a beneficiary of the fresh vote as 20 million new voters were enrolled after the population census. Tehreek-e-Labbaik with 3 percent emerged as the fourth largest party, whereas the PML-Q and Jamaat-e-Islami have 1 percent vote each.

337126_3131795_akhbar.jpg


Performance of Shahbaz Sharif, despite his general perception as the most efficient chief minister, hasn’t been well-received in the public. To a question that how they see the five-year performance of his government, only 28 percent rated it very good whereas 48 percent termed it average, 13 percent considered it bad, and 7 percent declared it very bad. However, 64 percent respondents were satisfied with the development work carried out by their respective MNAs and 63 percent endorsed their MPAs.

Unlike yet another general perception that the PTI is very popular among the youth, in particular women, the survey gives the verdict in favour of the PML-N.

The majority of voters (46 percent) fell in the age-bracket of 26-40 years. Of the total respondents, 24 percent belonged to this age bracket and identified themselves as supporters of the PML-N compared to 14 percent for the PTI. The second biggest number of respondents (23 percent) was in the age-bracket of 18-25 years. Of the respondents surveyed, 11 percent fell in this age group and said their vote was for PML-N in comparison with 8 percent for the PTI. Seventeen percent of the respondents were 41 to 50 years old, with 9 percent supporting the PML-N compared to 5 percent supporting the PTI.

If a gender-wise comparison is taken, 34 percent of the men and 17 percent of the women support the PML-N, whereas 22 percent male and 8 percent female respondents said they support the PTI.

When surveyors asked about the single most important issue facing their constituencies, 17 percent each ticked drinking water and gas, while 16 percent said it was sewerage. The top three divisions where respondents identified drinking water as the most important issue were Bahawalpur (28 percent), Sahiwal (2 percent) and Rawalpindi (22 percent) respectively. Gas was the most important issue in Rawalpindi (22 percent), Faisalabad (19 percent) and Gujranwala (19 percent), while sewerage was the single most important concern for respondents in Multan (22 percent), Sargodha (21 percent), and Faisalabad (19 percent).

Although health, education, unemployment and corruption are generally thought to be the most important issues being faced by Pakistanis, three percent declared health, education and unemployment each as the biggest concern, whereas one percent identified corruption. Only 8 percent pointed towards loadshedding as the most important issue.

Responding to a separate question, 67 percent declared that loadshedding had significantly decreased in their respective constituencies in the last five years, 24 percent said it had not decreased, while 8 percent didn’t respond.

The survey has also mapped the vote bank region-wise. The PML-N has the highest vote in Central Punjab (55 percent). This is followed by Western Punjab (52 percent), Southern Punjab (49 percent), and Northern Punjab (42 percent).

Meanwhile, the PTI leads in Northern Punjab (31 percent) and Western Punjab (31 percent), followed by Central Punjab (30 percent) and South Punjab (29 percent). The PPP’s highest vote is in South Punjab (8 percent).





Note from Editor/Disclaimer: Surveys and polls are not always accurate but are useful in capturing trends. Surveys and polls results change as per events and as the election day approaches. IPOR is a syndicated survey that includes commissioning by different political parties such as the PTI and PML-N and others. It was not commissioned by Jang, Geo, The News.

Elections exclusive: How will Pakistan vote?
July 4, 2018
News Desk

Listen

337125_8209033_akhbar.jpg


Gallup Pakistan (national), Pulse Consultant (national) and IPOR (provincial) polls show that PML-N remains the preferred party among voters in the largest province, but PTI has gained ground and narrowed the gap significantly. PTI remains the dominant party for voters in KPK, while PPP is ahead in Sindh. Balochistan, there is a three party mix. Nationally polled respondent in the Gallup poll shows PML-N ahead, while the PTI has taken the lead in the Pulse survey. Undecided voters to play decisive role in polls.

Two nationally and one provincially conducted polls have found voter preference in Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Sindh to have remained unchanged, staying with the same political parties elected to power in 2013. In Balochistan, voter preference varies between polls. On the national level, polls show that the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) has gained ground on the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz. While the PML-N is ahead according to the Gallup poll, the party has lost popularity. The Pulse survey reveals that the PTI is the preferred party for voters across the country.

337125_6474225_akhbar.jpg


Surveys also found that undecided voters have emerged as a key battleground for political parties. Gallup poll shows this group to be at 20% as compared with 26% of respondents who would vote for the PML-N and 25% for the PTI at the national level. In the Pulse poll, the undecided voter group stands at 9% forming the fourth largest block after PTI at 30%, PML-N at 27% and PPP at 17%.

Also read: IPOR survey finds PML-N leading in Punjab, PTI gaining ground

Results of the surveys may vary from those conducted in November 2017 as several key political developments have taken place in the country. The government fell in Balochistan in January while the Senate elections were held in early March without the official presence of the PML-N due to a technicality as a result of the ruling by the honourable Supreme Court detailed judgment against former prime minister Nawaz Sharif. In early May, politicians associated with the PML-N from South Punjab left the party, joining the opposition PTI. In the same month, Nawaz Sharif gave an interview perceived by many as controversial.

National voting preference showed the PTI gaining ground on the PML-N in the Gallup survey and moving ahead according to Pulse. While the Gallup survey still had the PML-N as the leading party for voter preference, it witnessed an 8% decrease from 2017, with 26% of respondents saying they would vote for the party in 2018. Voter preference for PTI was 25%, which was 1% decrease from 2017. 16% of respondents said they would vote for the PPP.

The PTI overtook the PML-N as the preferred party of voters in the Pulse survey. The PTI, which stood at 23% in 2017, saw a 7% increase with 30% of respondents saying they would vote for the party. The PML-N, which was in the lead in the 2017 survey, dropped 9% with 27% of respondents preferring to vote for the party. The PPP was the preferred party for 17% of respondents.

In Pakistan’s most populous province of Punjab, which has the highest number of National Assembly seats, the PML-N remains the preferred party of voters. However, PTI has gained ground and narrowed the difference with its political opponent. According to the Gallup survey, 40% of respondents said they would vote for the PML-N in the province in 2018, a figure which was 10% less when respondents were asked the same question in 2017. The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) had 31% of respondents voting for the party in the 2017 poll, a number which fell to 26% in 2018. The Pakistan Peoples’ Party (PPP) saw an increase of 1%, with 6% respondents stating they would vote for the party in 2018.

337125_3999953_akhbar.jpg


Findings of the Pulse survey revealed that although the PML-N remained the preferred party among voters in Punjab, its popularity had fallen 12% since 2017. In the 2018 poll, 43% of respondents said they would vote for the PML-N which was 55% in 2017. The PTI gained 14% points among voters, with 34% of respondents voting for the party in 2018, compared to 20% in 2017. Fewer voters also favoured the PPP, with the party’s preference among voters in Punjab falling to 5% from 7%.

A third poll conducted by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR) focused on 141 National Assembly constituencies in Punjab. The survey conducted from April 15 to June 2, 2018 revealed 51% of respondents voting for the PML-N, 30% saying they would vote for the PTI, and 5% choosing the PPP.

In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the PTI gained popularity among voters in 2018, with 57% respondents polled by Gallup stating they would vote for the PTI, up 10% from 2017. The survey found 9% of respondents voting for the PML-N compared to 10% in 2017. The JUI-F and ANP had 6% respondents each in 2018 casting their ballot for the parties.

337125_6503194_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey showed a similar trend for the PTI in the province, with 57% respondents voting for the party in 2018 compared with 53% in 2017. 10% of voters preferred PML-N, which was a 3% decrease from 2017. Voter preference for PPP grew slightly in the province, rising to 9% in 2018.

In Sindh, the PPP remained the most preferred party. The Gallup poll found no change in voter preference for the party from 2017 and 2018, with 44% still stating they would vote for the PPP. The PTI’s popularity among voters remained unchanged at 9%, while 7% fewer respondents said they would be voting for the PML-N in the province.

337125_8384671_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey also listed PPP as the preferred party of voters in Sindh with 45% of respondents saying they would vote for the party. The PTI saw a slight increase, with 11% of voters saying they would for the party. Voter preference remained unchanged for the PML-N at 4%.

There was a shift in preference in Balochistan, with the PML-N falling out of the top three in both Gallup and Pulse surveys. The main factor contributing to this significant decline was the government of the province being dissolved in January.

The Gallup poll findings in the province showed 23% of respondents voting for the JUI-F which was a 10% increase from the November 2017 poll. The PPP also saw its popularity increase among voters with 20% preferring the party compared to 7% previously. The popularity for the PTI remained unchanged at 5%.

337125_8517011_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey showed the PPP as the preferred party for voters in Balochistan, with 36% of respondents. The PPP gained a significant 31% since the 2017 poll. The PTI was the preferred party for 12% of voters, a figure which was 21% in 2017. The JUI-F gained 1% from 2017.





Note from Editor/ Disclaimer: Surveys and polls are not always accurate but are useful in capturing trends. Surveys and polls results change as per events and as the Election Day approaches. IPOR is a syndicated survey that includes commissioning by different political parties such as PTI and PML-N and others. It was not commissioned by Jang, GEO, The News. Gallop and Pulse survey were commissioned by Jang Group Editorial Board.
 
Last edited:
In the Eye of the Storm

The dye is cast, the inevitable is upon us; we are now in the eye of a storm that took handlers of our society and their proxies several years to create for purely petty power ambitions.

A jail sentence for Nawaz Sharif and his daughter is without doubt the likely outcome of a political and legal trial that started in August 2014.

The next few days may propel the situation to a point where some hard choices would have to be made by those driving the crisis; If Nawaz Sharif receives a mammoth public welcome upon his return from London, the choice would be to either postpone elections or to rig elections like never before making the on-going pre-poll rigging look like child’s play.

Each option carries extreme risks including civil and political strife not seen for a long time with the on-going economic meltdown only adding fuel to the raging political fire.

The third and more sensible option of holding free and fair elections is no longer a viable option as ‘Hara-kiri’ is haram in Islam. More so as political proxies continue to lose public traction despite blatant attempts to strengthen them with forced feed injections of electables.

Holding sham elections and expecting political stability is like exploding a bomb in the middle of a hustling bazar and not expecting casualties. How long and how far the political strife is allowed to persist depends on the strategic objectives of the masterminds. In case the consequential economic meltdown reaches alarming proportions, the cost of the bailout package would determine the real agenda of the induced political strife.

As all crises do, this one will also produce casualties, both political as well as others. Those who thought they could ride the wave of political instability and thrive on it may soon find themselves to be its early victims as the ‘Tabdeeli’ of the kind upon us has no real winners,’ only losers.



وطن کی فکر کر ناداں مصيبت آنے والی ہے
تری برباديوں کے مشورے ہيں آسمانوں ميں
 
IPOR survey finds PML-N leading in Punjab, PTI gaining ground

Listen





337126_358695_akhbar.jpg


ISLAMABAD: A constituency-wise survey of entire Punjab has found the PML-N maintaining popularity despite the ongoing corruption trial of Nawaz Sharif, disqualification of its prominent leaders, and defection of so-called electables.

Although, the PML-N is ahead with 51 percent vote bank, it has largely preserved its vote with only a 2 percent increase in comparison with 2013. This is in contrast with the significant increase in PTI's vote -- from 19 percent in 2013 to 30 percent in 2018.

Exclusive: How will Pakistan vote in elections 2018

The Institute of Public Opinion Research (IPOR) conducted the survey with the biggest-ever sample size of 200,349 respondents from the province. The opinion poll was carried out between April 15 and June 2 this year with a response rate of over 72 percent. All National Assembly constituencies of Punjab (141) were surveyed with average sample size of 1,420 respondents from each constituency. This is in contrast with most country-wide surveys, where the total respondents generally range between 3,000 and 4,000.

According to the survey, the PML-N is ahead of the PTI with 5:3 ratio of voters. The majority of these respondents said loadshedding significantly decreased in the past five years and posed trust in the performance of their MNAs and MPAs in terms of development work. But respondents also identified three most important issues they face: access to clean drinking water, gas, and sewerage. Health, education, unemployment and corruption received the lowest scores in their priority list.

Survey findings indicate that the PTI largely took away the PPP vote in Punjab, which has now been reduced to 5 percent from 11 percent in 2013, as many PPP leaders switched to the PTI in addition to the PML-Q leaders. Imran Khan’s party is also considered a beneficiary of the fresh vote as 20 million new voters were enrolled after the population census. Tehreek-e-Labbaik with 3 percent emerged as the fourth largest party, whereas the PML-Q and Jamaat-e-Islami have 1 percent vote each.

337126_3131795_akhbar.jpg


Performance of Shahbaz Sharif, despite his general perception as the most efficient chief minister, hasn’t been well-received in the public. To a question that how they see the five-year performance of his government, only 28 percent rated it very good whereas 48 percent termed it average, 13 percent considered it bad, and 7 percent declared it very bad. However, 64 percent respondents were satisfied with the development work carried out by their respective MNAs and 63 percent endorsed their MPAs.

Unlike yet another general perception that the PTI is very popular among the youth, in particular women, the survey gives the verdict in favour of the PML-N.

The majority of voters (46 percent) fell in the age-bracket of 26-40 years. Of the total respondents, 24 percent belonged to this age bracket and identified themselves as supporters of the PML-N compared to 14 percent for the PTI. The second biggest number of respondents (23 percent) was in the age-bracket of 18-25 years. Of the respondents surveyed, 11 percent fell in this age group and said their vote was for PML-N in comparison with 8 percent for the PTI. Seventeen percent of the respondents were 41 to 50 years old, with 9 percent supporting the PML-N compared to 5 percent supporting the PTI.

If a gender-wise comparison is taken, 34 percent of the men and 17 percent of the women support the PML-N, whereas 22 percent male and 8 percent female respondents said they support the PTI.

When surveyors asked about the single most important issue facing their constituencies, 17 percent each ticked drinking water and gas, while 16 percent said it was sewerage. The top three divisions where respondents identified drinking water as the most important issue were Bahawalpur (28 percent), Sahiwal (2 percent) and Rawalpindi (22 percent) respectively. Gas was the most important issue in Rawalpindi (22 percent), Faisalabad (19 percent) and Gujranwala (19 percent), while sewerage was the single most important concern for respondents in Multan (22 percent), Sargodha (21 percent), and Faisalabad (19 percent).

Although health, education, unemployment and corruption are generally thought to be the most important issues being faced by Pakistanis, three percent declared health, education and unemployment each as the biggest concern, whereas one percent identified corruption. Only 8 percent pointed towards loadshedding as the most important issue.

Responding to a separate question, 67 percent declared that loadshedding had significantly decreased in their respective constituencies in the last five years, 24 percent said it had not decreased, while 8 percent didn’t respond.

The survey has also mapped the vote bank region-wise. The PML-N has the highest vote in Central Punjab (55 percent). This is followed by Western Punjab (52 percent), Southern Punjab (49 percent), and Northern Punjab (42 percent).

Meanwhile, the PTI leads in Northern Punjab (31 percent) and Western Punjab (31 percent), followed by Central Punjab (30 percent) and South Punjab (29 percent). The PPP’s highest vote is in South Punjab (8 percent).





Note from Editor/Disclaimer: Surveys and polls are not always accurate but are useful in capturing trends. Surveys and polls results change as per events and as the election day approaches. IPOR is a syndicated survey that includes commissioning by different political parties such as the PTI and PML-N and others. It was not commissioned by Jang, Geo, The News.

Elections exclusive: How will Pakistan vote?
July 4, 2018
News Desk

Listen

337125_8209033_akhbar.jpg


Gallup Pakistan (national), Pulse Consultant (national) and IPOR (provincial) polls show that PML-N remains the preferred party among voters in the largest province, but PTI has gained ground and narrowed the gap significantly. PTI remains the dominant party for voters in KPK, while PPP is ahead in Sindh. Balochistan, there is a three party mix. Nationally polled respondent in the Gallup poll shows PML-N ahead, while the PTI has taken the lead in the Pulse survey. Undecided voters to play decisive role in polls.

Two nationally and one provincially conducted polls have found voter preference in Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Sindh to have remained unchanged, staying with the same political parties elected to power in 2013. In Balochistan, voter preference varies between polls. On the national level, polls show that the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) has gained ground on the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz. While the PML-N is ahead according to the Gallup poll, the party has lost popularity. The Pulse survey reveals that the PTI is the preferred party for voters across the country.

337125_6474225_akhbar.jpg


Surveys also found that undecided voters have emerged as a key battleground for political parties. Gallup poll shows this group to be at 20% as compared with 26% of respondents who would vote for the PML-N and 25% for the PTI at the national level. In the Pulse poll, the undecided voter group stands at 9% forming the fourth largest block after PTI at 30%, PML-N at 27% and PPP at 17%.

Also read: IPOR survey finds PML-N leading in Punjab, PTI gaining ground

Results of the surveys may vary from those conducted in November 2017 as several key political developments have taken place in the country. The government fell in Balochistan in January while the Senate elections were held in early March without the official presence of the PML-N due to a technicality as a result of the ruling by the honourable Supreme Court detailed judgment against former prime minister Nawaz Sharif. In early May, politicians associated with the PML-N from South Punjab left the party, joining the opposition PTI. In the same month, Nawaz Sharif gave an interview perceived by many as controversial.

National voting preference showed the PTI gaining ground on the PML-N in the Gallup survey and moving ahead according to Pulse. While the Gallup survey still had the PML-N as the leading party for voter preference, it witnessed an 8% decrease from 2017, with 26% of respondents saying they would vote for the party in 2018. Voter preference for PTI was 25%, which was 1% decrease from 2017. 16% of respondents said they would vote for the PPP.

The PTI overtook the PML-N as the preferred party of voters in the Pulse survey. The PTI, which stood at 23% in 2017, saw a 7% increase with 30% of respondents saying they would vote for the party. The PML-N, which was in the lead in the 2017 survey, dropped 9% with 27% of respondents preferring to vote for the party. The PPP was the preferred party for 17% of respondents.

In Pakistan’s most populous province of Punjab, which has the highest number of National Assembly seats, the PML-N remains the preferred party of voters. However, PTI has gained ground and narrowed the difference with its political opponent. According to the Gallup survey, 40% of respondents said they would vote for the PML-N in the province in 2018, a figure which was 10% less when respondents were asked the same question in 2017. The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) had 31% of respondents voting for the party in the 2017 poll, a number which fell to 26% in 2018. The Pakistan Peoples’ Party (PPP) saw an increase of 1%, with 6% respondents stating they would vote for the party in 2018.

337125_3999953_akhbar.jpg


Findings of the Pulse survey revealed that although the PML-N remained the preferred party among voters in Punjab, its popularity had fallen 12% since 2017. In the 2018 poll, 43% of respondents said they would vote for the PML-N which was 55% in 2017. The PTI gained 14% points among voters, with 34% of respondents voting for the party in 2018, compared to 20% in 2017. Fewer voters also favoured the PPP, with the party’s preference among voters in Punjab falling to 5% from 7%.

A third poll conducted by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR) focused on 141 National Assembly constituencies in Punjab. The survey conducted from April 15 to June 2, 2018 revealed 51% of respondents voting for the PML-N, 30% saying they would vote for the PTI, and 5% choosing the PPP.

In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the PTI gained popularity among voters in 2018, with 57% respondents polled by Gallup stating they would vote for the PTI, up 10% from 2017. The survey found 9% of respondents voting for the PML-N compared to 10% in 2017. The JUI-F and ANP had 6% respondents each in 2018 casting their ballot for the parties.

337125_6503194_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey showed a similar trend for the PTI in the province, with 57% respondents voting for the party in 2018 compared with 53% in 2017. 10% of voters preferred PML-N, which was a 3% decrease from 2017. Voter preference for PPP grew slightly in the province, rising to 9% in 2018.

In Sindh, the PPP remained the most preferred party. The Gallup poll found no change in voter preference for the party from 2017 and 2018, with 44% still stating they would vote for the PPP. The PTI’s popularity among voters remained unchanged at 9%, while 7% fewer respondents said they would be voting for the PML-N in the province.

337125_8384671_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey also listed PPP as the preferred party of voters in Sindh with 45% of respondents saying they would vote for the party. The PTI saw a slight increase, with 11% of voters saying they would for the party. Voter preference remained unchanged for the PML-N at 4%.

There was a shift in preference in Balochistan, with the PML-N falling out of the top three in both Gallup and Pulse surveys. The main factor contributing to this significant decline was the government of the province being dissolved in January.

The Gallup poll findings in the province showed 23% of respondents voting for the JUI-F which was a 10% increase from the November 2017 poll. The PPP also saw its popularity increase among voters with 20% preferring the party compared to 7% previously. The popularity for the PTI remained unchanged at 5%.

337125_8517011_akhbar.jpg


The Pulse survey showed the PPP as the preferred party for voters in Balochistan, with 36% of respondents. The PPP gained a significant 31% since the 2017 poll. The PTI was the preferred party for 12% of voters, a figure which was 21% in 2017. The JUI-F gained 1% from 2017.





Note from Editor/ Disclaimer: Surveys and polls are not always accurate but are useful in capturing trends. Surveys and polls results change as per events and as the Election Day approaches. IPOR is a syndicated survey that includes commissioning by different political parties such as PTI and PML-N and others. It was not commissioned by Jang, GEO, The News. Gallop and Pulse survey were commissioned by Jang Group Editorial Board.

These surveys does not matter, the ongoing political engineering, if it does not changes till elections and afterwards, then most probably you will have very different results as compare to these surveys.


 
the ongoing political engineering, if it does not changes till elections and afterwards, then most probably you will have very different results

The ongoing Political engineering since last 10 years of rule in Punjab and recent 5 in the Center that is changing the minds of the voters even more:


Imran bhai, aap gaari may chalen, nikaltay han....but why??


What level of Political comprehension is at display here is testament of your psychological condition dear... :flame:keep burning lol...:flame:
 
The assault on Pakistan media ahead of vote
By Ahmed RashidLahore
  • 4 July 2018

_102307871_gettyimages-960354408.jpg
Image copyrightAFP/GETTY IMAGES
Image captionThe Dawn newspaper says it has been under attack since late 2016
Imagine waking up in New York without the New York Times, newspaper kiosks shut down and hawkers off the streets.

That is what many Pakistanis have been feeling for months as Dawn - Pakistan's largest English-language newspaper - has disappeared from their breakfast tables.

A massive bout of censorship of TV channels, newspapers and social media is setting the stage for parliamentary elections on 25 July.

The media and some political parties are being micromanaged by an establishment alliance of the army and the judiciary, according to journalists and the former ruling party - the Pakistan Muslim League - and its leader Nawaz Sharif, who was prime minister until being ousted last year on corruption charges and barred from politics.

The army and judiciary deny this.

Fall from grace
However, it is the battle between Dawn and the establishment that has drawn most attention.

Dawn is the unofficial newspaper of record - indispensable for businessmen, diplomats and military officers alike - and known for its influential editorials that affect Pakistan's image worldwide.

Moreover, Dawn has a particular reverence in the national psyche because it was established by Pakistan's founder Mohammed Ali Jinnah before Partition, when Muslims in British India had no voice to communicate with the colonial power.

Since then, Dawn has ironically long been viewed by many as the establishment paper.

No longer.

_98882446_gettyimages-643986190.jpg
Image copyrightAFP
Image captionPakistan is one of the hardest counties in the world for journalists to do their work
Dawn has faced intimidation, harassment of its journalists, a ban on hawkers distributing the newspaper in military cantonments in every city in the country, cable operators told to take its TV channel off air, and massive cuts in revenue as advertisers are warned not to promote their goods in Dawn.

Last year, in the province of Balochistan, the newspaper was unavailable for weeks on end.

Meanwhile, other media personalities have faced kidnappings, arrests and physical abuse by mysterious hooded men who no journalist dare name - but every journalist in the country is convinced belong to the military intelligence agencies.

But after maintaining months of silence as to what it has endured, or what exactly the military's complaints are, Dawn recently published a frank and stinging editorial.

The editorial describes its important, factual reporting about the serious rift between civil and military authorities during the Nawaz Sharif government, which had infuriated the military, and Dawn's insistence on protecting the sources for its stories - a basic element of media ethics worldwide.

The editorial states that "a campaign of disinformation, libel and slander, hate and virtual incitement to violence against Dawn and its staff has necessitated placing certain matters on record".

It added that elements "within or sections of the state" are not upholding constitutional freedoms.

Dawn said it has been under attack since late 2016, but with "greater intensity" since May this year.

_102317178_c5282b05-d701-4d36-89fc-690508139088.jpg
Image copyrightAFP/GETTY IMAGES
Image captionThe military denies that it interferes with the press
Last year, the largest Urdu-language newspaper Jang and its sister TV news channel Geo were subjected to such massive financial pressures and intimidation that they could not pay their staff for three months.

Unlike Dawn, their senior editors appear to have reached some kind of compromise with the military.

Even more targeted are bloggers on social media who write what the army describes as anti-state propaganda.

Meanwhile, the military frequently and with some vehemence denies that it interferes with the press, that it is determined to safeguard a free and fair election on 25 July - although it does admit to monitoring social media commentary.

Defiance by the establishment against both civil society at home and the international community seem to be the order of the day.

Just hours after Pakistan was placed on the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) grey list for failing to act against terror financing from its soil, an extremist leader listed on Pakistan's own terror watch list had his name removed and his party allowed to contest the elections.

Mohammed Ahmed Ludhianvi, head of the Ahl-e-Sunnat Wal Jamaat, a violent sectarian group known for killing Shias in Punjab, is now free to take part in politics.

His group - having adopted another name - has already registered dozens of candidates to stand in the polls.

Another well-known extremist group Lashkar-e-Taiba (or Army of the Faithful) is also fielding several hundred candidates for the elections, under a new electoral name.

Lashkar was declared a global terrorist group in 2014 by the UN, and its leader Hafiz Saeed has a $10m (£7.6m) bounty on his head.

Nobody admits to ordering these policy changes or justifying them. None of the multiple centres of power - the army, the judiciary, the interim government - have taken responsibility.

_101898632_mediaitem101898631.jpg
Image copyrightGUL BUKHARI
Image captionGul Bukhari is a vocal critic of the military
The press is too cowed to discuss the issue of why extremist groups have been given such protection and encouragement, when female bloggers like the well-known Gul Bukhari are being picked up in the streets of Lahore.

Much of the micromanagement that is going on in the elections has the same mysterious and unknown quality as to who is conducting it and why it is happening.

Pakistanis have a long way to go before they can comfortably read Dawn at breakfast every morning while journalists do not face harassment and intimidation for reporting the facts.

_78589977_line976.jpg

Ahmed Rashid
_85287971_010810199-1.jpg

  • Ahmed Rashid is a Pakistani journalist and author based in Lahore
  • His latest book is Pakistan on the Brink - The Future of America, Pakistan and Afghanistan
  • Earlier works include Descent into Chaos and Taliban, first published in 2000, which became a bestseller
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-44693968
 
Good comparison dude :rofl::rofl::rofl::

Champ is making desperate attempts to stop existing pmln and jamaat e ghair Islami supporters from leaving their respective parties to join PTI. What he is forgetting that desertions are happening at the top level.

Mujhay tou lagta hai aik din Maryam Nawaz aur tirchhi topi Siraj will also announce joining PTI despite champoos continuous hard work. Lollllll
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom