What's new

NTDC blows whistle on govt’s claim of Nandipur power generation

Leader

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 7, 2010
Messages
29,159
Reaction score
9
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
NTDC blows whistle on govt’s claim of Nandipur power generation

inp-02-02.jpg


Although State Minister for Water and Power Abid Sher Ali claimed on Wednesday that the Nandipur Power Plant is contributing 95 Megawatts to the national grid ever since its inauguration by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on May 31 this year, revelations by representatives of the National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) will leave the minister red-faced because according to these officials the Nandipur plant was shut down just after five days of operation as it was not feasible to run it at a record cost of Rs 42 per unit.

The NTDC officials made the disclosure at a public hearing conducted by the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) the other day.

The hearing, presided over by NEPRA Vice Chairman Habibullah Khilji, was also informed that the Nandipur Power Project had not yet officially or legally achieved its commercial operation date (COD). The first unit of the plants to come online was run on diesel fuel for five days after its inauguration, but closed down for being too expensive. In these five days, the plant produced electricity at an average cost of Rs 42 per unit.

NTDC officials said the decision to bring the plant online was made by the government: NTDC and PEPCO had neither requested the operations, nor did they approve the premature generation.

The inauguration of the Guddu Thermal Power Station and Uch-II; the ground breaking of a 1320MW coal-fired plant at Port Qasim by a consortium of Qatari and Chinese companies, put together by former Ehtesab Bureau chief Saifur Rehman are other examples of the government’s rush to get things done quickly.

Prime Minister Sharif inaugurated the first 95MW plant of the controversial Nandipur Power Project on May 31. The project had been stalled under the PPP government amid allegations of graft, declared an “unforgivable sin” by the prime minister as the plant and related machinery remained stranded at the Karachi port for more than five years.

The project cost more than doubled to Rs 57 billion (instead of Rs 23 billion) and the nation suffered a loss of Rs 165 billion, according to Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif, who spearheaded the project’s revival.

The project will be able to generate 425MW on furnace oil, which can be upgraded to 525MW if natural gas is used as fuel. However, the plant will take another five months or so to achieve commercial operation status.

While the NTDC officials were blowing the whistle on the power plant, Minister Abid Sher Ali was dispelling ‘misconceptions’ about the project to a group of journalists in Nandipur.

Flanked by Punjab Law Minister Rana Mashhood Ahmad and Project Director Muhammad Mahmood at Nandipur, Abid Sher told reporters that the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf leadership was lying (about the project) with the nation in Ramazan.

“Imran Khan is not criticising the PPP government which had delayed the project leading to enhanced cost – Rs 23 billion to Rs 57 billion. Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif negotiated with the Chinese government and brought engineers back to undertake the project,” he said.

The minister claimed that one turbine of the project was operational and generating 95MW and that work on other turbines was underway and they would be operational by end of this year.



NTDC blows whistle on govt’s claim of Nandipur power generation | Pakistan Today

continuous incompetent pmln !!
 
Incompetent " NUTJOBS ".

Now I know what the "N" in PMLN stands for... :pissed:
 
Noon walas, Pee walas and Insaaf wala are all incompetents.

I mean do u see any professional among any of the three from the power / energy sector. The answer is big no. How can you expect a bank manager (ASif Kh) and Tedi badmash (Abid Loin ) to handle technical issues like load depatch, power distribution, circular debts etc. They are all incompetents.

Please note I do not consider Omar Asad competent. He also blew the Engro Power project due to his incompetence.
 
Noon walas, Pee walas and Insaaf wala are all incompetents.

I mean do u see any professional among any of the three from the power / energy sector. The answer is big no. How can you expect a bank manager (ASif Kh) and Tedi badmash (Abid Loin ) to handle technical issues like load depatch, power distribution, circular debts etc. They are all incompetents.

Please note I do not consider Omar Asad competent. He also blew the Engro Power project due to his incompetence.

These issues are Generally handled by the bureaucracy,Minister just needs to approve projects & get clearance in a time bound manner.But yes having a professional will really help a lot in these things.Good news is these are just some supply side Bottlenecks & if the Govt is serious it will take no time to solve them.
 
NTDC blows whistle on govt’s claim of Nandipur power generation

inp-02-02.jpg


Although State Minister for Water and Power Abid Sher Ali claimed on Wednesday that the Nandipur Power Plant is contributing 95 Megawatts to the national grid ever since its inauguration by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on May 31 this year, revelations by representatives of the National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) will leave the minister red-faced because according to these officials the Nandipur plant was shut down just after five days of operation as it was not feasible to run it at a record cost of Rs 42 per unit.

The NTDC officials made the disclosure at a public hearing conducted by the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) the other day.

The hearing, presided over by NEPRA Vice Chairman Habibullah Khilji, was also informed that the Nandipur Power Project had not yet officially or legally achieved its commercial operation date (COD). The first unit of the plants to come online was run on diesel fuel for five days after its inauguration, but closed down for being too expensive. In these five days, the plant produced electricity at an average cost of Rs 42 per unit.

NTDC officials said the decision to bring the plant online was made by the government: NTDC and PEPCO had neither requested the operations, nor did they approve the premature generation.

The inauguration of the Guddu Thermal Power Station and Uch-II; the ground breaking of a 1320MW coal-fired plant at Port Qasim by a consortium of Qatari and Chinese companies, put together by former Ehtesab Bureau chief Saifur Rehman are other examples of the government’s rush to get things done quickly.

Prime Minister Sharif inaugurated the first 95MW plant of the controversial Nandipur Power Project on May 31. The project had been stalled under the PPP government amid allegations of graft, declared an “unforgivable sin” by the prime minister as the plant and related machinery remained stranded at the Karachi port for more than five years.

The project cost more than doubled to Rs 57 billion (instead of Rs 23 billion) and the nation suffered a loss of Rs 165 billion, according to Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif, who spearheaded the project’s revival.

The project will be able to generate 425MW on furnace oil, which can be upgraded to 525MW if natural gas is used as fuel. However, the plant will take another five months or so to achieve commercial operation status.

While the NTDC officials were blowing the whistle on the power plant, Minister Abid Sher Ali was dispelling ‘misconceptions’ about the project to a group of journalists in Nandipur.

Flanked by Punjab Law Minister Rana Mashhood Ahmad and Project Director Muhammad Mahmood at Nandipur, Abid Sher told reporters that the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf leadership was lying (about the project) with the nation in Ramazan.

“Imran Khan is not criticising the PPP government which had delayed the project leading to enhanced cost – Rs 23 billion to Rs 57 billion. Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif negotiated with the Chinese government and brought engineers back to undertake the project,” he said.

The minister claimed that one turbine of the project was operational and generating 95MW and that work on other turbines was underway and they would be operational by end of this year.



NTDC blows whistle on govt’s claim of Nandipur power generation | Pakistan Today

continuous incompetent pmln !!


Rs 42/unit ????:o::o:
 
Rs 42/unit ????:o::o:
42/unit hahahahahah

It could be correct under certain conditions. But if the plant is run continuously on Furnace oil, the cost should be less than Rs. 17 IMO. In any case, there is relevant information missing here. Perhaps something to do with overhead costs being accounted during the trial run? If so, that would be incorrect.
 
These issues are Generally handled by the bureaucracy,Minister just needs to approve projects & get clearance in a time bound manner.But yes having a professional will really help a lot in these things.Good news is these are just some supply side Bottlenecks & if the Govt is serious it will take no time to solve them.
Sahi. But in Pakistan most of bureaucracy consist of liberal art graduate. Unfortunately we do not have professional basis of selection in it. Ministry of power might have a doctor as its incharge or a law graduate.

Rs 42/unit ????:o::o:
Possible hai
Fixed cost of all plant
Furnace Oil as variable cost.
So a plant with a 600 MW capacity and only 95 MW is producing therefore cost can go beyound 40 to 42

It could be correct under certain conditions. But if the plant is run continuously on Furnace oil, the cost should be less than Rs. 17 IMO. In any case, there is relevant information missing here. Perhaps something to do with overhead costs being accounted during the trial run? If so, that would be incorrect.

Phir kidher dalo gay ye costs?
 
Any government can lie at this extend ?
Yes if they are shameless and counting their days or
Majority of population is really illiterate and brainwashed- I feel second option is much near to truth

Government, sold half baked cake to public as baked cake. Public liked it felt happy even though it was half baked cake and they never got to eat it.

At least in India if any minister lie at this extend , he will leave office in next week or so.
This is another thing I noticed about GOP (PPP or PML-N) minters never leave office. Once they will get fear of losing job they will try to improve at least.
 
Its a hybrid project . 95 MW from water and other 335MW from furnace oil.

Our beloved PM inaugurated the project in a haste ,for now it is not completed. The installed capacity is only around 100 MW.
They ca going to start the production once the project is totally complete .

ps: aik kam zaroor hova hay nandipur main khutoon ke kami ho gaye hay . aapnay chinese engineers ke wajha say :D
 
Possible hai
Fixed cost of all plant
Furnace Oil as variable cost.
So a plant with a 600 MW capacity and only 95 MW is producing therefore cost can go beyound 40 to 42



Phir kidher dalo gay ye costs?

In baseless allegations and wild conjectures - that is where these costs would be put.

How many neurons are needed to see that one can not be serious about cost of electricity at this point in plant's life. PTI people ought to bring hard data, not allegations.
 
Back
Top Bottom