What's new

Not possible to achieve 100% self-reliance in defence: Manohar Parrikar

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
SOURCE: PTI

455290-manohar-parrikar.jpg


It is not possible to achieve 100 per cent self-reliance in defence production as certain components required in limited numbers have to be purchased off-the-shelf to save money, the Lok Sabha was informed today.
Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar said during Question Hour that huge costs will have to be incurred if certain components are produced in small numbers and it would be better to buy it from open market.

He said this in response to a supplementary on by when India will be 100 per cent self-reliant in defence production.

Parrikar said to attain a high degree of self sufficiency, 70 per cent was a good figure. He, however, did not specify as to whether India has achieved 70 per cent self sufficiency.

Referring to the ‘Make in India’ initiative, he said under the ‘Make one’ programme, government funds 90 per cent of the project cost and the manufacturer has to develop the item to the satisfaction of the forces within two years. If that happens, then the government buys that item.

Under ‘Make two’, the industry puts its money to produce an item which, if found satisfactory, is purchased by the forces.

In his written response, Parrikar said the expenditure in respect of orders placed on foreign vendors, primarily from countries like US, Russia, Israel and France, have come down from Rs 35082.10 crore in 2013-14 to Rs 24992.36 crore in 2014-15 and Rs 22422.12 crore in 2015-16.

He said even in cases where current operational exigencies necessitate import of defence equipment, efforts are made to ensure the involvement of Indian industry as production agencies and offset partners.

He also clarified that no target is fixed for import of defence equipment and therefore, no separate budgetary allocation is made against such targets.

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...nce-manohar-parrikar/articleshow/52040603.cms

http://idrw.org/not-possible-to-achieve-100-self-reliance-in-defence-manohar-parrikar/
 
Never say Never. Parrikar needs to learn how to Speak.

He is one of the worst speakers in the BJP. There is no elegance, culture or refinement in his speech.
 
And therefore his words has more weight, because he is not a good diplomat, and will only speak what he thinks is right.

Of course. He is a terrific guy and you can take what he says on face value.

Only as a National leader he needs to evolve beyond what was required in Goa.

He needs to think more deeply about what he says, how he says it and why he says it.
 
Of course. He is a terrific guy and you can take what he says on face value.

Only as a National leader he needs to evolve beyond what was required in Goa.

He needs to think more deeply about what he says, how he says it and why he says it.


Leagues ahead than Dhoti Antoni you cannot understand even a single word that saint antoni use to say.

But what Parrikar says you can trust every single word.

People like you must know truth dont have many shades, it is always crystal clear. It dont need window dressing.

Only sickular need window dress for their words bcs ugly deceitful dialect needs makeup of what you call elegance and refinement.
 
MoD should come up with a roadmap for indeginisation outlining the key technologies and timelines for indeginisation. This would ensure proper funding and accountability by DRDO/DPSUs/pvt firms involved in R&D and production.
 
Leagues ahead than Dhoti Antoni you cannot understand even a single word that saint antoni use to say.

But what Parrikar says you can trust every single word.

People like you must know truth dont have many shades, it is always crystal clear. It dont need window dressing.

Only sickular need window dress for their words bcs ugly deceitful dialect needs makeup of what you call elegance and refinement.

Truth is over rated. Not everything is done out in the open.

Do you parents discuss the truth about your conception before you ? some things needs to be done behind closed door, however true it is.

Not everybody has sight, Most are blind. They just don't know it, or admit it.

The Truth about how an Elephant looks cannot be explained to the blind, they will see only a rope, or a tree or a wall etc.

That is why wisdom dictates you speak appropriately.

People wear cloths to hide what is ugly, only the naga sadhus and Jain munis walk in the nude, free of window dressing and lies.

So unless the rest of India turn nudist, dressing is what we need. Elegance and Refinement.
 
if 70% is a good figure to him then they r really not interested in their country's betterment. pakistan on the other hand satisfies its 80% of defence needs domestically even when being in a state of war for past 15 years. Thats what our minister of defence production has told our parliamentary defence standing committee.
 
Truth is over rated. Not everything is done out in the open.

Do you parents discuss the truth about your conception before you ? some things needs to be done behind closed door, however true it is.

Not everybody has sight, Most are blind. They just don't know it, or admit it.

The Truth about how an Elephant looks cannot be explained to the blind, they will see only a rope, or a tree or a wall etc.

That is why wisdom dictates you speak appropriately.

People wear cloths to hide what is ugly, only the naga sadhus and Jain munis walk in the nude, free of window dressing and lies.

So unless the rest of India turn nudist, dressing is what we need. Elegance and Refinement.

Yes agreed that's why Bar Dancer consepted Saint Antony with Augusta Westland deal in the darkness of bedroom.

Ohh!!! but our Saint Antoni is VIRGIN SAINT.

We now need to pray him and his son Augusta Westland deal.

Totally agree with you.
 
Yes agreed that's why Bar Dancer consepted Saint Antony with Augusta Westland deal in the darkness of bedroom.

Ohh!!! but our Saint Antoni is VIRGIN SAINT.

We now need to pray him and his son Augusta Westland deal.

Totally agree with you.

You are mixing Transparency with Truth.

Transparency is not the same as the Truth.

Transparency will allow people to see what they choose to see. It does not show the whole truth. But it does provide people who desire to know the whole truth to find it.

Antoni was probably more honest than Air Marshall Tyagi. More honest than Admiral Madhavendra Singh, former Chief of the Naval Staff, General Nirmal Chander Vij, former Chief of Army; General Deepak Kapoor, former Chief of Army, ALL of whom had flats in Aadarsh Scam building and none of them wore Dhoti.
 
MoD should come up with a roadmap for indeginisation outlining the key technologies and timelines for indeginisation. This would ensure proper funding and accountability by DRDO/DPSUs/pvt firms involved in R&D and production.

How you expect filth of Decades to be cleared in year or two. What they are doing is appreciable with all the constrains and legacy of past.

You are mixing Transparency with Truth.

Transparency is not the same as the Truth.

Transparency will allow people to see what they choose to see. It does not show the whole truth. But it does provide people who desire to know the whole truth to find it.

Antoni was probably more honest than Air Marshall Tyagi. More honest than Admiral Madhavendra Singh, former Chief of the Naval Staff, General Nirmal Chander Vij, former Chief of Army; General Deepak Kapoor, former Chief of Army who had flats in Aadarsh Scam building and none of them wore Dhoti.

So the Dhoti is symbol of Honesty???? So same can be said about Puckka Chor (another Dhoti Clad).

So Dhoti Antoni dont know abt AW being a PR Firm not an OEM????

Dhoti dont know abt ASR been diluted????

Dhoti instead of encashing full BG and fining AW bought 3 choppers for settlement of cancellation of the deal.

YES YOU ARE CORRECT DHOTI ANTONI IS UNCORRUPTABLE OF UNCORRUPTABLES.



You say Transparency is not equal to Truth.

But is it not Transparency LEADS to truth. Can Truth stand without Transparency ??????
 
Last edited:
if 70% is a good figure to him then they r really not interested in their country's betterment. pakistan on the other hand satisfies its 80% of defence needs domestically even when being in a state of war for past 15 years. Thats what our minister of defence production has told our parliamentary defence standing committee.

First, Pakistan importing less than India in absolute terms is because of the incapacity of Pakistan to pay for it. There isn't a thing which Pakistan produces and India doesn't, while I can name dozens of advanced military hardwares which India produced (not only licensed production) but Pakistan is years behind from getting such tech. India's purchase list includes Aircraft carrier, nuclear sub's which Pakistan can only dream of getting them.

Secondly, in 2015 Pakistan imported $0.735 billion of defense equipments compared to 3.1 billion of India. Now compare the respective size of the economy, defence budget and you will know who is more dependant on imports.
 
So the Dhoti is symbol of Honesty???? So same can be said about Puckka Chor (another Dhoti Clad).

So Dhoti Antoni dont know abt AW being a PR Firm not an OEM????

Dhoti dont know abt ASR been diluted????

Dhoti instead of encashing full BG and fining AW bought 3 choppers for settlement of cancellation of the deal.

YES YOU ARE CORRECT DHOTI ANTONI IS UNCORRUPTABLE OF UNCORRUPTABLES.

You say Transparency is not equal to Truth.

But is it not Transparency LEADS to truth. Can Truth stand without Transparency ??????

Dhoti is a symbol of South Indian Pride. It a sign of my culture, a dress my people wore with dignity.

Antony's Dhoti is no more corrupt than Manmohan's Pagadi or Sonia Gandhi's Sari.

If you have a problem with Dhoti, keep it to yourself. I am not interested in sharing your fashion sense.


Transparency CAN lead to the truth. It can also lead to obfuscation of the truth by filling the Mind space with all kinds of Irrelevant truths.

No one is against Transparency. Only against unrefined and unreflective speech.
 
Back
Top Bottom