For me it would have been more satisfying to teach a kindergarten kid than a Think Tanky of PDF, a tanky who is hell bent on making a point because his own ego has been hurt.
I allowed you a graceful exit but no ....... you have to prove your arrogance and ignorance.
FBR webportal in fact is a very efficient useful tool, it could have made a lot of difference in forcing the FBR to correct its statistics, but sadly this system was entrusted to babuz in FBR.
The only law that gets enforced in Pakistan is Income Tax law, the only law that gets amended / repealed every year .......... so your baseless assumption that law doesn't get enforced is mere hogwash deprived of any research and understanding. You like this current government are disconnected with reality.
You read and you still don't know that taxable limit for salaried class is PKR 600,000 and people who earn 50% more than their salary from other sources is PKR 400,000 ........... not PKR 200,000.
Seriously .............. why you have to make a fool of yourself and lie that you read ....... the taxable limit has remained PKR 400,000 for quite long ....... don't know from where did you pull this PKR 200,000 ........ using your own words "so you are talking out of your rear".
Section 149 is where every employer deducts income tax from salary of his taxable employees every month and deposits that tax into government treasury using web portal creating a PSID and latter once that payment goes thru a CPR is generated. And in past the employer had to file a withhold tax statement under section 149 for employees and under section 165 for its vendors. And an annual withholding tax statement as well.
I have no idea what you mean by giant corporations ......... but ask a government employee if he is working for any giant corporation then why his tax also gets deducted at source. e.g. ask
@Zibago
Puttar this is my domain, I deal with this everyday, I deal with FBR notices and appeals very frequently .... I know what I am talking about.
The introduction of 149, 153 took the burden off the FBR's shoulders of recovering the tax and put that on the withholding tax agents.
153 deals with withholding on payments for goods and services .... a very robust section, that can be used to track many business individuals and force them to register and file ........ but no FBR likes to stick with 1% statistics because the day it is revealed they will end up paying huge refunds and account for all that money they have spent on their own ayashi.
Only 154 deals with exports and I didn't even ask you to read this section
155 deals with income from property and not property tax ....... genius tanky.
There is no section 231 in Income tax Ordinance (it was omitted) neither did I point to it ....... genius tanky I told you stop making fool of yourself. I asked you to read
231A that deals with deduction of income tax at source on cash withdrawals from bank .... no one, I repeat no one whether he is taxable or not can escape this deduction
231AA deals with advance (income) tax on transaction in a bank .......... again no one irrespective of whether his income is taxable or not can escape this
231B deals with advance (income) tax on private motors vehicles ...... same thing again no one irrespective of whether his income is taxable or not can escape this
Mr Think tanky there is no such thing as transportation / auto taxes ......... its all forms of income tax that we are discussing here. Excise office makes sure that income tax from this source gets deducted and paid.
Mr Think Tanky .......... its the end consumers that pay income tax included in their electricity bills, again irrespective of whether they are liable to pay or not. Your new excuse that people barely pay their bills outside urban cities is another master stroke of ignorance.
A widow if she uses the telephone an orphan if he uses the telephone, a daily wager if he uses a telephone, anyone including students, pensioners, housewives and people who have an annual income of less than PKR 600,000 end up paying income tax by simply using their cellphones, not once multiple times. That income tax withheld from them should be refunded back to them ......... but it never happens nor it will ever happen.
Now please if you would excuse me I am not interested anymore in engaging with you. You hold Zero credibility for me.
Salama alaik.
