New Pakistans in making in India

[soundHound]

And then people wonder why only Muslims in India are forced to prove there patriotism time to time.

 

[Little Falcon]

Yes baby steps are needed for the fourth Reich.

Or maybe khalistan

 

[El Sidd]

Let's make it simple - An Indian is one who keeps his/her country ahead of his/her religion. That would sound absurd to you. But those muslims who were Indian, chose to live in India. All those who didn't chose pakistan.

That is way too simple. It is a hard sell specially in modern scenario.
and don't worry about sounding absurd.
Be a little precise or practical

 

[footmarks]

That is way too simple. It is a hard sell specially in modern scenario.
and don't worry about sounding absurd.
Be a little precise or practical

Beauty lie in simplicity. By complicating the idea of India, western thinkers have long been pulling their hair, how can India survive?

We are simplistic in our approach. We are here, have been living here for thousands of years, before religion came into existence. This is our home, and we love our country.

 

[Sam.]

That's a myth. Some parts of north-India, yes. Like saharanpur, roorkee, azamgarh (where minorities are majority), and there too its mostly local hindu-muslim divide, not a radicalization and terrorist breeding spot (well, mostly). Otherwise, it's Hyderabad, Kerala, WB which are terrorist hotbeds.

I am from Roorkee and you are as delusional as the other guy you talking too. Please visit the place and I will show you around.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

Even with that argument no country has that amount of Muslims. So i do not know how you plan to control all of them without much needed help from Pakistan.
So if its diverse in Pakistan it is a weakness?
We have a thriving democracy tailored to our need.

Since you are sensible than an average propaganda fed Pakistani. Can you answer me what makes an Indian? define the identity?

And when i address in 'you' consider it synonym to 'Indian - Indians'. So keep that in mind please

Indian or Hindu is a geographic and cultural identity. Even those who are born in Pakistan or Bangladesh are Indian. I agree you are a separate land now bcz of borders (just from few years back ) but roots are same "an Indian''. This is the reason we call south Asia region as Indian subcontinent.

 

[footmarks]

I am from Roorkee and you are as delusional as the other guy you talking too. Please visit the place and I will show you around.

I was talking about nearby areas, not roorkee town itself. There is deoband nearby.

 

[El Sidd]

Beauty lie in simplicity. By complicating the idea of India, western thinkers have long been pulling their hair, how can India survive?

We are simplistic in our approach. We are here, have been living here for thousands of years, before religion came into existence. This is our home, and we love our country.

Yes. I fully agree with the part that people have lived in these parts for thousand of years and have adopted accordingly.

by the way your first statement about surviving and western thinkers is quite hard to digest but lets agree to disagree.

 

[Sam.]

I was talking about nearby areas, not roorkee town itself. There is deoband nearby.

30 mins away and they are more patriotic than you. They will die for their motherland unhinged.

I was talking about nearby areas, not roorkee town itself. There is deoband nearby.

You should not make your opinion from the corrupted media. You have no idea about North.

 

[Panzerkampf]

Or maybe khalistan

Or may be 2nd Bangladesh.

 

[footmarks]

30 mins away and they are more patriotic than you. They will die for their motherland unhinged.

You should not make your opinion from the corrupted media. You have no idea about North.

I didn't questioned their patriotism. I said mostly there are hindu-muslim divide in north India. Terror hotbed lie in Kerala, WB and Hyderabad.

 

[Little Falcon]

Or may be 2nd Bangladesh.

Knock Knock ....

 

[El Sidd]

Indian or Hindu is a geographic and cultural identity. Even those who are born in Pakistan or Bangladesh are Indian. I agree you are a separate land now bcz of borders (just from few years back ) but roots are same "an Indian''. This is the reason we call south Asia region as Indian subcontinent.

I don't think many Pakistanis would agree to that. You can ask a Bangladeshi about them frankly i don't give a shizzle.

You can call it a geographical identity but cultural is just pushing it too far. Culture is influenced by language, religion, climate and trade.

 

[footmarks]

I don't think many Pakistanis would agree to that. You can ask a Bangladeshi about them frankly i don't give a shizzle.

You can call it a geographical identity but cultural is just pushing it too far. Culture is influenced by language, religion, climate and trade.

Culture is influenced by aspirations too. Case in point - you would not like to be identified as of indian origin (though most likely that is the case, india being the geographical identity having culture that is nowadays identified as hindus). Muslims in the sub-continent aspire to align themselves as arabs or turks (a class higher perhaps).

 

[countryman]

Culture is influenced by aspirations too. Case in point - you would not like to be identified as of indian origin (though most likely that is the case, india being the geographical identity having culture that is nowadays identified as hindus). Muslims in the sub-continent aspire to align themselves as arabs or turks (a class higher perhaps).

Are not you confusing ethnicity with Identity?
Indian Ethnic != Indian National ( where India is used a nation's name)