Muslim woman of Madhya Pradesh lauded by Hindu neighbours for her devotion to Durga

[Desert Fox]

Thank god there are at least few who believe all paths leads to same.....
The exclusivity of being real worshippers of real god indoctrinated in Quran doesn't need necessarily to be followed.......

That is the fundamental principle of Islam: the belief in the oneness of God. You can't be a Muslim otherwise.

As soon as one starts ascribing partners to God they become non-Muslim by default.

This isn't something conjured up by "some mullah", this is a accepted fact.

 

[darksider]

Please tell this to the Indian Muslims. There are many many Muslims, including women in burqas praying in Hindu and Sikh Temples and Churches in India.

if they are Muslims they should know it already.
so no need tell them.
its just for you.
idol worship strictly prohibited in islam.we can destroy them but not worship.
islam,s basic rules are same in every sect and must followed otherwise you can be hindu christein or what ever you like but not muslim.

 

[Tiger Genie]

Bhai jaan a Muslim cannot worship or celebrate idol festivals.
If he or she like other religion then just convert.
But you cannot be Muslim and worship idols.

this is obviously not true. Because she is muslim and she is worshipping Ma Durga.

That is the fundamental principle of Islam: the belief in the oneness of God. You can't be a Muslim otherwise.

As soon as one starts ascribing partners to God they become non-Muslim by default.

This isn't something conjured up by "some mullah", this is a accepted fact.

Worshipping Durga or anyother form of God does not mean oneness of God is somehow rejected. Hindus also believe in ONE except they view the God in many forms.

she is not a muslim anymore-

that is not your decision. what religion she follows is her decision and only hers

 

[Tiger Genie]

indian law has no say in Muslim matters-

who made you an authority on either? Indians follow Indian law, period. And Indian law allows religious requirements as LONG as they do not violate other laws including individual rights and freedoms

 

[darksider]

this is obviously not true. Because she is muslim and she is worshipping Ma Durga.



Worshipping Durga or anyother form of God does not mean oneness of God is somehow rejected. Hindus also believe in ONE except they view the God in many forms.



that is not your decision. what religion she follows is her decision and only hers

yes you hidnu troll know more about islam than a muslim
dont quote me again with this kind of rubbish

 

[Tiger Genie]

yes you hidnu troll know more about islam than a muslim
dont quote with these kind of rubbish again

Then do not post such things as 'she is not muslim'. whether you agree or not, she has her individual rights to follow any religion she wants to.

yes you hidnu troll know more about islam than a muslim
dont quote me again with this kind of rubbish

And by the same token, you are not Indian, so why do you claim to pass judgement on Indian law?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

That is the fundamental principle of Islam: the belief in the oneness of God. You can't be a Muslim otherwise.

As soon as one starts ascribing partners to God they become non-Muslim by default.

This isn't something conjured up by "some mullah", this is a accepted fact.

(Many if not most) Indian Muslims follow Indian Islam. Not Islam. Hope that clarifies your doubts.

 

[JonAsad]

that is not your decision. what religion she follows is her decision and only hers

its not about her decision - we are past that already-

 

[SarthakGanguly]

you still talking about your indian law- let me say again indian law doesnt matter when it comes to muslims- ban some core islamic practice and then see how many indian muslims give a flying fcuk to indian laws-


there is no such thing as indian islam- stop living in hinduvta paradise -

If Indian laws are not respected and if a flying f is given, a bullet will put an end to the nonsense. Regardless of the follower's faith. Lead does not discriminate.

 

[Tiger Genie]

its not about her decision - we are past that already-

there is NOTHING past her decision. That is ALL that matters. Indians have religious freedom and this woman chose to be a muslim. That ends the story.

 

[JonAsad]

who made you an authority on either? Indians follow Indian law, period. And Indian law allows religious requirements as LONG as they do not violate other laws including individual rights and freedoms

present your authority over indian laws then before judging my authority over either-

 

[SarthakGanguly]

if they are Muslims they should know it already.
so no need tell them.
its just for you.
idol worship strictly prohibited in islam.we can destroy them but not worship.
islam,s basic rules are same in every sect and must followed otherwise you can be hindu christein or what ever you like but not muslim.

Your time for destroying them is over. Those who remain will be assimilated.

 

[Tiger Genie]

present your authority over indian laws then before judging my authority over either-

Here it is.

 

[I.R.A]

True. She is an Indian Muslim following Indian Islam.

You need to realise not everything is made in India. And Islam has no Indian or Pakistani or African or European chapters, Islam is Islam either you accept and practice it or you reject it, no ifs, no buts, no excuses.

 

[JonAsad]

there is NOTHING past her decision. That is ALL that matters. Indians have religious freedom and this woman chose to be a muslim. That ends the story.

you are talking about a so called muslim woman showing her devotion to hindu durga right?- and religious freedom in india?- wondering whats the recent fuss over cow slaughter really was-