What's new

Museum Review: Unit 731 Germ Warfare Site, Harbin, China

Kylin

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
321
Reaction score
1
Country
China
Location
Canada
Just read this review, is it true that the Museum's main floor exhibits is authored by Japanese? What is the Official Japanese government view on these events?

Didn't know the Emperor was this close to war, I am so glad his grand children are this different.

Museum Review: Unit 731 Germ Warfare Site, Harbin, China

Nicole Freiner, Bryant University

Part of my summer 2011 was spent on a three-week field study in China as part of the East-West Center’s Asian Studies Development Program. Our trip focused on visiting the Northeast of China, a cultural transmission zone between China, Manchuria, Korea and Japan. One of our site visits was the Unit 7311 museum located near Harbin (Pingfan), China. When I found out that we would be visiting the Unit 731 Museum, I was apprehensive. As a long-time scholar of Japan, it is sometimes difficult for me to acknowledge and accept the evil perpetrated by members of a culture with which I closely identify. However, as a political scientist who teaches regularly on human rights, nationalism and the relationship between culture and state, visiting the museum was important. It is also a goal of mine to use tangible displays of culture and history in the classroom. I believe that museums, like texts, including film and other cultural vehicles, can convey powerful messages to students and the general public, so I went to the museum hoping to take away material which I could use in the classroom.

1. Its official name was the Epidemic Prevention and Water Purification Department of the Kwantung Army.


While most Japan specialists and those who are Japan-interested are aware of the Japanese atrocities committed during World War II, the Nanjing massacre has garnered the most academic and international attention, while in fact Japan’s wartime atrocities across Southeast Asia were extensive, including those committed in the Philippines, Malaysia and Indonesia. Th e war crimes committed at Unit 731 were disguised as biological and chemical research, but with the de-classification of documents confiscated by the American military2 and the discovery of human skulls buried at a former medical facility in Tokyo,3 the true purpose of the facility was exposed.

At Unit 731, chemical, medical and biological experiments were carried out on Manchurian and Chinese civilians by imperial decree.4 These experiments included research on cholera, anthrax, smallpox, botulism, typhoid, and dysentery. Th e venereal diseases syphilis and gonorrhea were also studied. Prisoners were injected with the diseases in order to study its effects or were infected using fl eas, clothing and supplies. Medical experiments at Unit 731 included vivisection and amputation. Chemical weapons including grenades and bombs using chemical agents were also used on prisoners.

2. Three key documents of clinical observations were de-classified in 1960 :“Th e Report of A” (anthrax), “Th e Report of G” (glanders),and “Th e Report of Q” (bubonic plague) but were interspersed with other documents. Th e publication of a fi nding aid by Greg Bradsher (National Archives and Records Administration) in 2006 allows researchers to easily compile and locate documents on Japan’s war crimes including those related to Unit 731. See Japanese War Crimes
3. Aft er Unit 731 was vacated by the Japanese, evidence of the facility was burned and bodies of victims were shipped back to a medical facility in Tokyo. Ryall, Julian. “Human bones could reveal truth of Japan’s ‘Unit 731’ experiments” Th e Telegraph. February 15th, 2010.
4.Emperor Hirohito toured the facility.

(continue by clicking on the title link)
 
.
One of the darkest shades of Japanese militarism.

However they tend to centre more on Hiroshima being a "victim" or what they have financially contributed to "World Peace", development in the third world and UN's finance. Simultaneously, they are deliberately indifferent to Unit 731 and many other facts which were even more appalling than Nazi , as some of them called, fabricated history. In that case, there will be no real reconciliation like what we have witnessed in Europe, unless we see enough Japanese tourists in Nanjing Massacre Museum like many Germans in those concentration camps.

No matter how strongly I anticipate for real reconciliation between Asian countries, the current situation is just totally disappointing and becoming more and more disturbing everyday.
 
.
I am really glad that you guys have brought this up when many people are trying to let this greatest tragedy forgotten during the passage of time

It is the equivalent of Nazi-Auschwitz that happened in our Country and the gruesome experiments was also conducted in Korea as well I think!

Japanese are masters to let the world know in much fanfare that they are the victims of the Americans bombs but not the warlords who alongside the Nazis have brought the biggest invasions and destructions to the world
 
.
I am really glad that you guys have brought this up when many people are trying to let this greatest tragedy forgotten during the passage of time

It is the equivalent of Nazi-Auschwitz that happened in our Country and the gruesome experiments was also conducted in Korea as well I think!

Japanese are masters to let the world know in much fanfare that they are the victims of the Americans bombs but not the warlords who alongside the Nazis have brought the biggest invasions and destructions to the world
They are the biggest hypocrite.
 
.
Japanese Manchuria must bring itself to unprecedent glory, prosperity and development. Unit 731 is wicked no doubt but compared to CPC, Japanese killed far far fewer civilian and people in Manchuria. Maybe a few hundreds died under Unit 731.

Siege of Changchun - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Large numbers of civilians starved in the siege; estimates range from 150,000[4] to 330,000


Just the Siege of Changchun alone, CPC deliberate fire machine gun and kill civilians.
Many more are starve to death. We must curse CPC than Japanese. CPC is the most wicked to Manchurian.

Set your focus right.
That's also what some Japanese said, because CPC did wrong, so they didn't have to pay. CPC becomes not some Japanese but an excuse of some anti-China clans. Because colony and invasion also brought what they called, the most advanced tech and lifestyle in that time, so they had no wrong. Even CPC caused 1000billion death, does it intersect with what they have done? Reading you comment is just like reading comments in Japanese extreme right-wing bbs 21CH.
 
.
Japanese Manchuria must bring itself to unprecedent glory, prosperity and development. Unit 731 is wicked no doubt but compared to CPC, Japanese killed far far fewer civilian and people in Manchuria. Maybe a few hundreds died under Unit 731.

Siege of Changchun - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Large numbers of civilians starved in the siege; estimates range from 150,000[4] to 330,000


Just the Siege of Changchun alone, CPC deliberate fire machine gun and kill civilians.
Many more are starve to death. We must curse CPC than Japanese. CPC is the most wicked to Manchurian.

Set your focus right.

Blame the KMT for using the civilians as their cannon fodders and human shields.

The KMT had butched at least 10 million pro-CPC civilians.

蒋介石在红军根据地究竟屠杀了多少人?
 
.
.
Japanese Manchuria must bring itself to unprecedent glory, prosperity and development. Unit 731 is wicked no doubt but compared to CPC, Japanese killed far far fewer civilian and people in Manchuria. Maybe a few hundreds died under Unit 731.

Siege of Changchun - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Large numbers of civilians starved in the siege; estimates range from 150,000[4] to 330,000


Just the Siege of Changchun alone, CPC deliberate fire machine gun and kill civilians.
Many more are starve to death. We must curse CPC than Japanese. CPC is the most wicked to Manchurian.

Set your focus right.

Don't mixed up attrocities by Japanese biological experiment on Chinese with China's internal issues. One is foreign invasion while the other is civil war, the two should not be argued within the same premise. Otherwise, we can flip the entire world's history & simply call every govt to task, to sit along side Adolf Hitler, Hideki Tojo, etc.
 
Last edited:
.
No matter how many civilians KMT and CPC killed, it was another topic, not an excuse of Japanese militarism.

It was Lux who started to troll on CPC.

CPC and KMT, do you think which one can protect your country from the Japanese fascists?

It is ok to let those anti-China trolls to insult your protector?
 
.
It was Lux who started to troll on CPC.

CPC and KMT, do you think which one can protect your country from the Japanese fascists?

It is ok to let those anti-China trolls to insult your protector?
Both. They were in different region during the war. Domestic war was another topic.
No matter what, bringing these two parties in topics, as Japanese right-wing and other anti-China force are doing, could never erase their appalling crime.
 
.
The Japanese would always crave for more resource and territory.
The Unit 731 purpose is obviously to exterminate the local Chinese population, so that the Japanese can acquire the resource and territory like what happen in North and Latin America.
That is why, it is very important for China to make sure that the Japanese has a proper understanding of this history.
To admit that military aggression is wrong so that they would not try again.
 
.
Both. They were in different region during the war. Domestic war was another topic.
No matter what, bringing these two parties in topics, as Japanese right-wing and other anti-China force are doing, could never erase their appalling crime.

It is because the might of the CPC, Japan got fully imitated, and that also prevents them to fully turn into a fascist nation again.

Without the power of the CPC, if the US lets Japan to recover their pre-WWII state, then we would get screwed again.
 
.
Japanese Manchuria must bring itself to unprecedent glory, prosperity and development. Unit 731 is wicked no doubt but compared to CPC, Japanese killed far far fewer civilian and people in Manchuria. Maybe a few hundreds died under Unit 731.

Siege of Changchun - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Large numbers of civilians starved in the siege; estimates range from 150,000[4] to 330,000


Just the Siege of Changchun alone, CPC deliberate fire machine gun and kill civilians.
Many more are starve to death. We must curse CPC than Japanese. CPC is the most wicked to Manchurian.

Set your focus right.

Unit 731 General Facts

Most of us heard about the horrible experiments on humans of the Nazis done by doctor Mengele. But the Nazis weren’t alone in conducting cruel experiments on humans.

One of the lesser known atrocities of the 20th century was committed by the Imperial Japanese Army’s Unit 731. Some of the details of this unit’s activities are still uncovered.

This webpage was set up to collect and organize the information known to date about Unit 731 and present it to anyone interested.

For 40 years, the horrific activities of "Unit 731" remained one the most closely guarded secrets of World War II. It was not until 1984 that Japan acknowledged what it had long denied - vile experiments on humans conducted by the unit in preparation for germ warfare.

Deliberately infected with plague, anthrax, cholera and other pathogens, an estimated 3,000 of enemy soldiers and civilians were used as guinea pigs. Some of the more horrific experiments included vivisection without anesthesia and pressure chambers to see how much a human could take before his eyes popped out.

Unit 731 was set up in 1938 in Japanese-occupied China with the aim of developing biological weapons. It also operated a secret research and experimental school in Shinjuku, central Tokyo. Its head was Lieutenant Shiro Ishii.

The unit was supported by Japanese universities and medical schools which supplied doctors and research staff. The picture now emerging about its activities is horrifying.

According to reports never officially admitted by the Japanese authorities, the unit used thousands of Chinese and other Asian civilians and wartime prisoners as human guinea pigs to breed and develop killer diseases.



Many of the prisoners, who were murdered in the name of research, were used in hideous vivisection and other medical experiments, including barbaric trials to determine the effect of frostbite on the human body.

To ease the conscience of those involved, the prisoners were referred to not as people or patients but as "Maruta", or wooden logs. Before Japan’s surrender, the site of the experiments was completely destroyed, so that no evidence is left.

Then, the remaining 400 prisoners were shot and employees of the unit had to swear secrecy. The mice kept in the laboratory were then released, which could have cost the lives of 30,000 people, since the mice were infected with the bubonic plague, and they spread the disease.

Few of those involved with Unit 731 have admitted their guilt.

Some caught in China at the end of the war were arrested and detained, but only a handful of them were prosecuted for war crimes.

In Japan, not one was brought to justice. In a secret deal, the post-war American administration gave them immunity for prosecution in return for details of their experiments.

Some of the worst criminals, including Hisato Yoshimura, who was in charge of the frostbite experiments, went on to occupy key medical and other posts in public and private sectors.




May be you need to set your facts straight first before you start to use it trying to convince people with your arguments. Wiki also says "Between 3,000 and 12,000 men, women, and children[1][2]".

Japanese soldiers whom confessed their crimes:

These were in Chinese so I took the time to translate just for you :).

汤浅谦〔八十四岁〕
“我在一九四二年在山西长治陆军医院做了第一次人体解剖。三月中旬的一天,我被叫去做手术练习,在手术室我们把两个中国人放在手术台上,进行全身麻醉后,进行盲肠切除。由于我紧张,切了三次才切断,然后,用刀切开那人的皮肉,在止血后用锯给他截肢。我做的是胸部枪伤手术练习,用切开器插入血管,再插入管子,为了提高医术,我们就做了这样残忍的事情。”

Ken Yuasa (84 years old)
"In 1942, I conducted my first human anatomy at Shanxi Changzhi Army Hospital. In a mid- March day, I was called to there for surgery practice, in the operating room we put two Chinese people on the operating table, after general anesthesia, started the appendectomy. Because I was nervous, it took me three times to cut it off, and then, cut out the man's flesh with a knife, after stopped the bleeding, amputated him with a saw. I did a practice for gunshot wound to the chest surgery, inserted a vascular incision device into the blood vessel, then insert a tube, to improve medical skill, we did such a cruel thing."

筱冢良雄〔七十七岁〕
“我在加入‘七三一’时只有十六岁,我所在的班工作是培养细菌,观察细菌杀伤能力。我在一九四二年十二月开始进行人体实验。我的工作是用平板刷清洗被细菌折磨得奄奄一息的中国人。我一边用水管冲,一边刷,洗到脸时,我有点犹豫,但军医一直催我。在我清洗完后,一个军医进行检查,另一个军医进行解剖,取出带有病毒的内脏,把上面的鼠疫病菌涂到培养板上,我们这样做是因为人的内脏是最好的细菌培养基。”

Yoshio Shinozuka (77 years old)
"I joined '731' when I was 16, the job of the my squad was to cultivate bacteria, and to observe bacterial killing ability. I started human experiment in December 1942. My job was to clean bacteria tortured dying Chinese with a flat brush. I was brushing while hosing, while brushing the face, I was a little hesitant, but the military doctor kept urging me. A military doctor performed the examine while another one performed the autopsy and took out the organs infected with virus (should be bacteria) after I finished cleaning, wiped the plague bacteria from it onto the culture plates, we did so because the human gut was the best culture medium for bacteria."

松本博〔七十四岁〕
“我在南京‘一六四四’部队做过对人体的采血实验。我们先把人关在高一米、宽一点二米的铁笼子里,进行细菌注射。几个月后,把人从笼子带到处置室,对人的腹股沟进行消毒,然后把腹股沟的动脉切开,用钳子夹住两边血管,往心脏方向插管子,然后放开钳子,血一下就流出来了,当血流得缓慢时,就有一个士兵按住那个人的胸膛。当血流完时,那人就开始剧烈地痉挛抽动,在流完最后一滴血后,就把人扔进焚尸炉烧掉。”

Hiroshi Matsumoto (74 years old) (Less known since he was from another Unit, there were more than 1 Unit active in China at the time)

"I was in Nanjing Unit '1644', had done experiments on human blood collecting. First we locked a person in a 1 meter high, 1.2 meters wide iron cage, injected him with bacteria. A few months later, took the man from the cage to the disposal room, disinfected his groin (seems to be unnecessary since they were gonna kill him, work habit maybe), and then cut the groin artery open, clamped the blood vessels on both sides with pliers, stuck a tube in towards the direction of the heart, then release the pliers, blood instantly flew out, when blood flow was slow, there was a soldier to hold down the man's chest. When the blood was drained completely, the man began to violently twitching, after the last drop of blood, throw the body into the incinerator."

It is because the might of the CPC, Japan got fully imitated, and that also prevents them to fully turn into a fascist nation again.

Without the power of the CPC, if the US lets Japan to recover their pre-WWII state, then we would get screwed again.

A bit too radical for my view, CPC was not as great they claimed themselves to be, nor is Japan evil now.
 
Last edited:
.
. .

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom