What's new

"Much rhetoric" in Pakistan, India talks

daring dude

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 22, 2013
Messages
836
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Australia
ISLAMABAD: So far there seems to be "much rhetoric and little substance" following the talks between Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi, said a Pakistani daily on Wednesday.

An editorial in the News International "A taste of old wine" said that the need is to "plan strategy carefully and with genuine commitment if there is to be any real success in building the harmony that the region needs".

"So far there seems to be much rhetoric and little substance," it added.

Prime Minister's Adviser on Foreign Affairs and National Security Sartaj Aziz has given a briefing on the interaction between the prime ministers of India and Pakistan on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization in Ufa, Russia.

"There was nothing said that we have not heard before," said the daily.

Aziz stressed that Track-II diplomatic contact between the two sides would be stepped up, with a host of issues to be discussed.

"Though he did not say so in so many words, it seems Kashmir may also be an issue taken up initially at least at Track II level," the editorial said.

It added: "Much has been made about the face-to-face meeting between PM Nawaz Sharif and PM Narendra Modi in Russia. It is hard to say if anything solid will emerge from it."

The daily went on to say that Track-II diplomacy has been tried many times before.

"In fact it has figured during the tenure of nearly every government over the past many years. The process generally involves a discussion on a range of issues between retired diplomats or others who are not directly in government as a means to build confidence and trust."
Aziz mentioned that the Track-II process would include discussion on border tensions and also other issues that had come up over the past months. He said Pakistan had asked "India for more evidence regarding the charges it had made over the November 2008 siege of Mumbai".

The editorial noted that there has been continued "expression of anxiety in New Delhi over what it sees as lack of movement in Pakistan in this matter and it has alleged that the key figures have not been detained or brought to trial".

"The fact is that Track-II efforts almost never do any harm. They can indeed help lead towards some desirable objectives such as enhancing contacts between people."

"Much rhetoric" in Pakistan, India talks: Daily - The Economic Times
 
Last edited:
.
"Much rhetoric" in Pakistan, India talks: Daily
By IANS | 15 Jul, 2015, 11.19AM IST
1 comments |Post a Comment

ISLAMABAD: So far there seems to be "much rhetoric and little substance" following the talks between Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi, said a Pakistani daily on Wednesday.

An editorial in the News International "A taste of old wine" said that the need is to "plan strategy carefully and with genuine commitment if there is to be any real success in building the harmony that the region needs ..
"So far there seems to be much rhetoric and little substance," it added.

Prime Minister's Adviser on Foreign Affairs and National Security Sartaj Aziz has given a briefing on the interaction between the prime ministers of India and Pakistan on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization in Ufa, Russia.
"There was nothing said that we have not heard before," said the daily.

Aziz stressed that Track-II diplomatic contact between the two sides would be stepped up, with a host of issues to be discussed.

"Though he did not say so in so many words, it seems Kashmir may also be an issue taken up initially at least at Track II level," the editorial said.

It added: "Much has been made about the face-to-face meeting between PM Nawaz Sharif and PM Narendra Modi in Russia. It is hard to say if anything solid will emerge from it."

The daily went on to say that Track-II diplomacy has been tried many times before.

"In fact it has figured during the tenure of nearly every government over the past many years. The process generally involves a discussion on a range of issues between retired diplomats or others who are not directly in government as a means to build confidence and trust."

Aziz mentioned that the Track-II process would include discussion on border tensions and also other issues that had come up over the past months. He said Pakistan had asked "India for more evidence regarding the charges it had made over the November 2008 siege of Mumbai".
The editorial noted that there has been continued "expression of anxiety in New Delhi over what it sees as lack of movement in Pakistan in this matter and it has alleged that the key figures have not been detained or brought to trial".

"The fact is that Track-II efforts almost never do any harm. They can indeed help lead towards some desirable objectives such as enhancing contacts between people."

"Much rhetoric" in Pakistan, India talks: Daily - The Economic Times

Wrong title. Alternatively wrong news. Fix.
 
. .
PM Nawaz shareef proved futile in getting Pakistan anything in those talks. Just see which of our concerns were included in the agenda anyway?
  • Kashmir - not included
  • Water crisis - not included
  • Indian water terrorism by releasing water - not included
  • Indian terrorism in Pakistan - not included
  • Indian support of MQM terrorists - not included
  • Murder of Pakistanis in India - Samjhota Express - not Induced
  • Indian attempts to sabotage Economic Corridor - not included
What was included in the meeting was mostly or entirely Indian stories. If I was PM of Pakistan, I would refuse to meet an Indian who admitted and celebrated role of Indian forces in breaking our country in two pieces. Shame on Mian Nawaz Shareef for committing to discuss Mumbai Terrorism but forgetting every other type, form and incident of terrorism in which Pakistanis were killed - both in India and in Pakistan.
 
.
As both the countries are bargaining for #SCO Membership, and they are doing what their master wants them to do, to be neutral .. and once they will get the Membership(any 1 of them) then that one will show other their might & Power of their Immunity by SCO...
 
.
As both the countries are bargaining for #SCO Membership, and they are doing what their master wants them to do, to be neutral .. and once they will get the Membership(any 1 of them) then that one will show other their might & Power of their Immunity by SCO...

SCO won't change the balance of power between the two countries.

And yes, no expectation from talks.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom