Mother donate Eggs to her daughter

[Raja.Pakistani]

I came across many news where a mother freezes her eggs so that her daughter can give birth or she donating eggs to her daughter for invitro fertilization. Is it ethical or unthical for mothers to donate her eggs to her daughter?

Share your views without bringing religious debate

Mother to freeze eggs so her infertile daughter can one day give birth to HER OWN brother or sister | Mail Online

 

[MM_Haider]

un-ethical.. but verdict depends on case to case basis..

 

[graphican]

In Islam there is no concept of donating body-parts, eyes or anything which may harm the donor. However blood can be given to a limit that the donor would remain healthy. As far as this condition goes.. there is no problem in giving eggs to somebody but considering what relationship its going to produce is serious. I don't think it will be allowed. Vis-a-viz, can father give sperms to his infertile son? Answer is simple - NO!

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

^ Sure i know Islamic opinion on this matter but i wanted to know the opinions of all Islamic, non Islamic, atheists , agnostic peoples on this forum

Thats why i used word ethical

 

[FreekiN]

Umm... sure... I guess...

If the couple have a true understanding about how genes and hormones work and whatnot.

---------- Post added at 04:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:54 AM ----------

Umm... sure... I guess...

If the couple have a true understanding about how genes and hormones work and whatnot.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Wont this be haram>? I mean the baby wouldnt it be frm the egg of his grand mother??? its so wierd........

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

^ Yes haram for muslims but not for many non muslims. I actually wanted to know the opinions of secular indians and Chinese peoples

 

[Luftwaffe]

In Islam there is a concept to save one's life...If someone needs a matched Kidney its permissible in Islam. It is highly doubtful if Islam would stop a family from donating Kidney or one's dear one who is dead to donate his/her eye to a living one who could be cured while he/she is blind.

Coming down to donating eggs/sperm that is unethical in almost all religions, I've seen videos on youtube Christianity forbids such things.

Why don't see adopt child or children who've no parents. Does she has to give birth? uh huh..