Modi's Article 370 remark: Is it time to end special status for J&K?

[he-man]

Even if modi becomes PM there is no way BJP can gain 2/3 rd majority in the parliament,so this is a pipe dream.

exactly what i said earlier

 

[kaykay]

Even if modi becomes PM there is no way BJP can gain 2/3 rd majority in the parliament,so this is a pipe dream.

There's always a way. If not possible legally, implement it Illegally. Although I believe that on right time, things will change for sure but time has not come yet.

 

[rockstarIN]

Hari

I am in Jammu for Past Seven Years............People here are for Article 370..............

Reason behind?

 

[he-man]

There's always a way. If not possible legally, implement it Illegally. Although I believe that on right time, things will change for sure but time has not come yet.

its just impossible in all scenarios.
as already told this requires2/3 nod of the parliament and 1/2 of state assembly where barring bjp 2-3 mla's from jammu,others are outrightly against it??
impossible dude

 

[kaykay]

its just impossible in all scenarios.
as already told this requires2/3 nod of the parliament and 1/2 of state assembly where barring bjp 2-3 mla's from jammu,others are outrightly against it??
impossible dude

I said 'Illegally' with the help of army. No need to pass any bill at all just create job opportunities there and relocate people even if its illigal.
PS: hint- 'BD migrants'. If they can come and live in India without any bill passed in parliament, then why can't Indians in Kashmir? Though it can take some time.

 

[WAR-rior]

Why debate on 370 is eqated to scrapping it?

Why cant 370 be amended. Its hightime we modernize the laws. All development laws passed in Parliament dont reach Kashmir. We just nee dto include this in 370 keeping other rights same. why cant this be done? For that to happen, u atleast need it to debate on table. Opportunist Congress dont even care for Kashmiri welfare. India is developing. Hell with Kashmir.

 

[kaykay]

Politically, BJP has support of I say 90% Indians on this Issue. Congress will only lose further support if they try to defend article 370.

 

[he-man]

I said 'Illegally' with the help of army. No need to pass any bill at all just create job opportunities there and relocate people even if its illigal.
PS: hint- 'BD migrants'. If they can come and live in India without any bill passed in parliament, then why can't Indians in Kashmir? Though it can take some time.

i agree completely.its shameful.
they even refuse land to build shelters for the pilgrims going to amarnath shrine,this is humiliating imho
they perceive themselves as diff race when the fact is all are converted kashmiri pandits and there lies the problem.

but army cannot be moved and this article cannot be struck down.thats the reality

At least they can make Govt of J&k Accountable they are wasting Indian taxpayers Money in Kashmir Article 370 Also Erupt gender inequality eg omar abdullah Sister dont have any rights in her father,s properties. Also for the people who are migrated too Kashmir from Pakistan. at least we can give people of Kashmir Rights like Right information,RTI, education rights,food security etc like other parts of the country

read the law properly
she has the right to property if she marries someone from the state.
but,yes if she marries someone from outside the state then she looses the right to property

rest of ur points are valid though

 

[kaykay]

i agree completely.its shameful.
they even refuse land to build shelters for the pilgrims going to amarnath shrine,this is humiliating imho
they perceive themselves as diff race when the fact is all are converted kashmiri pandits and there lies the problem.

but army cannot be moved and this article cannot be struck down.thats the reality

I am all for scrapping/heavy amendments in Article 370, but not now. Scrapping Article 370 will be of no use atm. Atleast not till next round of Jihad is over. If you know what i Mean.

 

[adwityagrata]

That is NOT true.

Article 370 can be removed by an Act of Parliament. Article 370 is a part of Indian constitution and not of J&K constitution, which puts it very well under the scope of amendment by the parliament.

Article 370 clause (3) makes the recommendations of J&K assembly binding on president before changes to Art 370. However, this clause itself can be amended if the parliament wants to. Even the Preamble and Fundamental rights can be amended or repealed by the parliament (e.g. right to property Art 31 was repealed) as long as the basic structure of the constitution is intact.

Even article 368 that deals with amendment can be amended. It goes without saying that if 370 is passed with 2/3rd majority as any amendment requires, it will be challenged in SC. It also goes without saying that even SC cannot declare it void and null since it does go against the basic structure of the Indian constitution.

 

[he-man]

I am all for scrapping/heavy amendments in Article 370, but not now. Scrapping Article 370 will be of no use atm. Atleast not till next round of Jihad is over. If you know what i Mean.

yes,it will only push ppl towards separatists right now.we must tread with caution at the moment

I Know that Fact this But Point Itself is Very Bias against women In this case comparing too rest of India Its 21 century Brother and we are talking about women empowerment how can it be possible if these kinds of law existed Even Nehru thought the Article 370 will dilute with the time but its not happens So there is something wrong .

sure there is something wrong but what can we do??
nothing untill ppl themselves feel that this is wrong which won't happen anytime soon

 

[adwityagrata]

sure there is something wrong but what can we do??
nothing untill ppl themselves feel that this is wrong which won't happen anytime soon

This can only happen when we spread awareness and ask people to support parties which talk about removing article 370. No prize for guessing which party that is.

 

[he-man]

This can only happen when we spread awareness and ask people to support parties which talk about removing article 370. No prize for guessing which party that is.

the society bound on the basis of religion is immune to all the logic in this world,,,we have tried all these years but nothing has really happened.
let them suffer,if they can't think right of themselves then who cares really

 

[adwityagrata]

the society bound on the basis of religion is immune to all the logic in this world,,,we have tried all these years but nothing has really happened.
let them suffer,if they can't think right of themselves then who cares really

I am not talking about kashmir, but about the rest of India.

The rest of India needs to wake up and vote for BJP that has a solid stand against repealing article 370 as well as implementing a Uniform Civil code.

Unless we repeat this foolish act, kashmir will continue to be a problem area. Time to integrate in irreversible into India and support any nationalist party that has a stated position on this.

 

[he-man]

I am not talking about kashmir, but about the rest of India.

The rest of India needs to wake up and vote for BJP that has a solid stand against repealing article 370 as well as implementing a Uniform Civil code.

Unless we repeat this foolish act, kashmir will continue to be a problem area. Time to integrate in irreversible into India and support any nationalist party that has a stated position on this.

i am gonna vote for bjp this time as i am sick of the socialist policies of govt,but don't expect too much from the bjp.the govt will be a coalition so they cannot flex their muscles due to poitical considerations.