Moderators pls intervene

[pankaj agrawal]

I request the moderators that few (3-4) posts of each threads should be posted by moderators and other elite members and non senior members cannot allowed to do the posting. They will set the platform for the fruitful discussion. What is happening is few people completely hijack the thread and turn it into a flaming thread. If moderators initiate and post first few posts, the tone of discussion can be beautifully set.

thanks and regards

 

[mjnaushad]

If some members stop making dual Ids....The problem will be solved....


Mods: Please close the thread.

 

[pankaj agrawal]

If some members stop making dual Ids....The problem will be solved....


Mods: Please close the thread.

how you gonna stop that???

 

[mjnaushad]

how you gonna stop that???

Its ethical matter.....Rules says dont make Multiple Id...so dont make

Why some make multiple ID....Because they get banned because of troll...But they come back with new id and troll again....and again and again...

So stop making multiple ids and let the fruitful discussion happen....

 

[Spring Onion]

I request the moderators that few (3-4) posts of each threads should be posted by moderators and other elite members and non senior members cannot allowed to do the posting. They will set the platform for the fruitful discussion. What is happening is few people completely hijack the thread and turn it into a flaming thread. If moderators initiate and post first few posts, the tone of discussion can be beautifully set.

thanks and regards

Lately we have been having this issue rising rapidly.

I believe Some people are doing it deliberately to drag down the forum.


As Mj said multiple Ids are a headache. These news entries like this mr bond, cholay chawal etc etc are even harming the good Indian posters.


Its time every fresh entry should be allowed to post only in Members' club and social affairs for atleast one month to assess they are serious in taking part in serious discussion and not trolling.

 

[pankaj agrawal]

yes, it is a ethical issue..but this is not a solution. i am talking about the solution. is anything wrong with my suggestion?

 

[Je suis de retour]

Lately we have been having this issue rising rapidly.

I believe Some people are doing it deliberately to drag down the forum.


As Mj said multiple Ids are a headache. These news entries like this mr bond, cholay chawal etc etc are even harming the good Indian posters.


Its time every fresh entry should be allowed to post only in Members' club and social affairs for atleast one month to assess they are serious in taking part in serious discussion and not trolling.

More than multiple IDs, the thing that hurts the forums image most is that in many cases some Elite and Senior members are one to start and carry on troll. I think you would agree most with it.

 

[mjnaushad]

yes, it is a ethical issue..but this is not a solution. i am talking about the solution. is anything wrong with my suggestion?

No matter how mods intervene ....one troll will derail the thread again....And mods are also human...They cant 24/7 stay online and watch each and every post....

 

[JamesBond]

Its ethical matter.....Rules says dont make Multiple Id...so dont make

Why some make multiple ID....Because they get banned because of troll...But they come back with new id and troll again....and again and again...

So stop making multiple ids and let the fruitful discussion happen....

Rule also says do not jump a red light. Don't you tell me you never did.

Rule also says do not bribe or do not take bribe but then we all cry a river about corruption including Pakistanis.

Rule also says do not watch ****. Tell me you never did.

Rule also says do not carry guns without licenses. Tell me no Pakistanis have guns (assault rifles ) without licenses.

Rule also says do not troll. Tell me you never do.

Rule also says do not use foul launguage. Tell me you didn't abuse a guy's grandfather yesterday.

Rule also says....aahhh leave it!

Don't talk about rules because you are in no position to!

Trying to be a saint, hey?

Rules say a lot of things. Cross your heart and tell me you follow each and every one of them...No???? Then why this selective preaching and implementation of rules?

 

[Hyde]

There must be a limit of post counts per section... I mean only members with 300+ posts should be able to post in Pakistan sections... (current affairs, economy, pakistan's war etc)...that will reduce the number of SPAMs in no time

So when a new member joins,

He will post in Introduction threads, Members club (where posts will not be counted) and non-Pakistani sections..... let him come with sanity

Once he got 300 posts (that will take a lot of time) we might know a little about him by now and then he can post in Pakistan's affairs too...that will reduce the trolls 90% as the majority do not last here before 300 posts

 

[pankaj agrawal]

No matter how mods intervene ....one troll will derail the thread again....And mods are also human...They cant 24/7 stay online and watch each and every post....

i am talking about moderators and senior members. as long they donot post, the thread will remain block. not a problem.

another option is to not allow people, who having free email id like gmail, yahoo, rediff etc. because at most you can have 1 or 2 id of your company. you cannot keep on trolling.

 

[SpArK]

There must be a limit of post counts per section... I mean only members with 300+ posts should be able to post in Pakistan sections... (current affairs, economy, pakistan's war etc)...that will reduce the number of SPAMs in no time

So when a new member joins,

He will post in Introduction threads, Members club (where posts will not be counted) and non-Pakistani sections..... let him come with sanity

Once he got 300 posts (that will take a lot of time) we might know a little about him by now and then he can post in Pakistan's affairs too...that will reduce the trolls 90% as the majority do not last here before 300 posts

I say i am also agreeing to this point.
But what about newer members for example from Bangladesh or maybe Nepal posting on Indian sections before 300?

 

[Je suis de retour]

There must be a limit of post counts per section... I mean only members with 300+ posts should be able to post in Pakistan sections... (current affairs, economy, pakistan's war etc)...that will reduce the number of SPAMs in no time

So when a new member joins,

He will post in Introduction threads, Members club (where posts will not be counted) and non-Pakistani sections..... let him come with sanity

Once he got 300 posts (that will take a lot of time) we might know a little about him by now and then he can post in Pakistan's affairs too...that will reduce the trolls 90% as the majority do not last here before 300 posts

I agree to some extent, but this implication would have side effect, ie alot of trolls in Members club section.
I think to improve quality, Mods must make sure that "Senior and Elite members " are like of role models in posting.
What would you expect from new bee when he reads a troll, of a member with 5000+ posts?

 

[Hyde]

I say i am also agreeing to this point.
But what about newer members for example from Bangladesh or maybe Nepal posting on Indian sections before 300?

The restriction should only be placed on Pakistan related sections right? as most of the trolling takes place in these sections....

And 300 is just a figure came in my mind.... management can have 100 posts or even 50 posts before allowing all the members to post in all sections...

Even 50 posts is a misery for some peoples so it would not be a bad idea to place 50 posts restriction to post in any Pakistan related section

 

[Hyde]

I agree to some extent, but this implication would have side effect, ie alot of trolls in Members club section.
I think to improve quality, Mods must make sure that "Senior and Elite members " are like of role models in posting.
What would you expect from new bee when he reads a troll, of a member with 5000+ posts?

posts in members club are not counted so that will not benefit newbies/freshies in any sort.....

Troll with 5000 posts? There is hardly any troll above 1000 posts count otherwise he would have permanently been banned

Yes there are some immature level of members having 1000s of posts but they are not troll in my opinion.... its just like they are still young and learning..... and that they are addicted with PDF so i don't find any reason why they shouldn't be here?