What's new

ML-1 Railways project CPEC to be completed in 3 phases - China & Pakistan agree to Amend Agreement.

Clutch

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
17,023
Reaction score
-3
ML-1 Railways project under CPEC to be completed in 3 phases

Category : Latest News Source : Express Tribune Date : 11-04-2019

Pakistan and China have decided to amend the terms of agreement of the Mainline-1 railway project under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), and is now expected to be completed in three phases.

The project now has been reduced to 1680 km from 1872 km, and will operate under the Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) model through a public private partnership.



ML-1 Railways project under CPEC to be completed in 3 phases


ISLAMABAD: Pakistan and China have agreed to amend a framework agreement on implementation of multibillion dollars mainline-I project of the Pakistan Railways in a bid to reduce the size of the much-delayed strategically important scheme and to complete it in three phases.

The decision to split the project, which was once planned to be completed in three years, suggests that work on the single-largest project of the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) will now take at least six years to complete – from the day of its groundbreaking.

It has been agreed to reduce the length of the project from 1,872km to around 1,680 km, according to the government sources. The government has also decided to exclude the component of building a new 163km long double line between Karachi and Hyderabad from the scope of the framework agreement.

It has been decided that this component will be executed on Public-Private Partnership or Build Operate and Transfer Basis if declared feasible after the commercial and financial feasibility study, said sources in the Ministry of Railways.

Similarly, the Havelian-Textile rail track has also been excluded from the project. The ML-I project will be completed on the Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC) mode under a sovereign deal.

But like the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government, the government of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PT) has also failed to decide whether the Chinese loan for the ML-I project will be taken on the books of the Finance Ministry or that of the Ministry of Railways. In case the loan is taken on the books of the Finance Ministry, its servicing will also be the responsibility of the federal government.

An addendum to framework agreement will be signed to amend the Article-II to implement the ML-I project in three phases. According to sources in the Ministry of Planning and Development, the supplement agreement will be signed during Prime Minister Imran Khan’s upcoming visit to China. Khan will visit China on April 27 on an invitation of Chinese President Xi Jinping.

The original plan was to construct and upgrade the rail infrastructure between Peshawar and Karachi in two phases and to complete it by 2022. However, so far, both the sides are at the stage of finishing the feasibility study.

The sources said the Chinese consortium will submit the report by April 15 on the feasibility design that will provide a base for calculating the cost of the project. Originally, it had been estimated that the project would cost $8.2 billion, making it the single largest scheme under CPEC.

According to the original framework agreement of May 2017, China will provide 85% of the project cost as a concessionary loan. The project has been declared strategically important by both countries.

This month Minister for Planning Khusro Bakhtiar had said the government has decided to split the project into more than two phases and to drop some sections that were part of the original plan of constructing 1,872-kilometer long line of the Pakistan Railways. The cabinet had approved to set up an implementation committee to review cost, scope, and financing of the ML-I project.

Three Phases

Under the phase-I of the project, four sections will be completed in a period of three to four years. Except for one, almost all these section will be built from Rawalpindi to Lahore.

A 52-km-long second line for running 120km per hour high-speed train will be constructed from Kaluwai to Pindora. The other sections include upgrading of Nawabshah-Rohri section of 183km, Lalamusa-Rawalpindi section of 118km, and Lahore-Lalamusa section of 132km. The upgrading of Walton Railway Academy with a reduced scope is also part of phase one.

In the second phase that will also take over three years to complete, Multan-Lahore section and Kaimari-Hyderabad section will be constructed. The dry port at Havelian will also be part of the second phase but its scope has been reduced.

In the third phase, Pakistan and China have agreed to construct a Rawalpindi-Peshawar section and Hyderabad-Multan section. The Taxila-Havelian track has been dropped from the ML-I scope.

The sources said Chinese contractors have the technical capacity and financial muscles to complete the three phases simultaneously but the Pakistan Railways cannot afford to close its commercial traffic and the project has to be implemented in phases that will take more time.

Secondly, Pakistan does not have enough fiscal space to allocate the rupee component in the development budget in one go. At present, the Pakistan Railways is picking up less than 4% of the traffic volume of the country, which the government intends to increase to at least 20% by 2025.
 
Last edited:
That's regressive :mad:

I think it is more realistic. It is a scale down of the scope and expedite of the timelines. It is what Pakistan needs. Faster completions and smaller burdens .

It shifts the project to Build Operate and Transfer... Without the risk of taking on more loans.
 
I think it is more realistic. It is a scale down of the scope and expedite of the timelines. It is what Pakistan needs. Faster completions and smaller burdens .

It shifts the project to Build Operate and Transfer... Without the risk of taking on more loans.
Reduced length -> Regressive
increased construction time -> Regressive
Build Operate Transfer -> Good

I think if Chinese are given the contract to build, they can build it in two years.
 
Last edited:
Reduced length -> Regressive
increased duration -> Regressive
Build Operate Transfer -> Good

I think if Chinese are given the contract to build, they can build it in two years.

I agree. Besides I view CPEC projects portfolio an ever evolving thing. I am sure as Pakistan economy stabilizes and our financial crunch is in a better situation... Pakistan will pursue much bigger projects.

You can't lease out a Mercedes when you only have funds for a corolla.
 
I agree. Besides I view CPEC projects portfolio an ever evolving thing. I am sure as Pakistan economy stabilizes and our financial crunch is in a better situation... Pakistan will pursue much bigger projects.

You can't lease out a Mercedes when you only have funds for a corolla.
Yeah but now it is on BOT so the leasing analogy becomes meaningless. I prefer BOT approach over loans on interest. I think govt should go for more BOT projects.
 
The project now has been reduced to 1680 km from 1872 km, and will operate under the Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) model through a public private partnership

Wonderfull.

It has been agreed to reduce the length of the project from 1,872km to around 1,680 km, according to the government sources. The government has also decided to exclude the component of building a new 163km long double line between Karachi and Hyderabad from the scope of the framework agreement.

It has been decided that this component will be executed on Public-Private Partnership or Build Operate and Transfer Basis if declared feasible after the commercial and financial feasibility study

The ML-I project will be completed on the Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC) mode under a sovereign deal

So a D&C contract. Good. It will save us time. Otherwise it would take even more time for separating both.
 
ML-1 Railways project under CPEC to be completed in 3 phases

Category : Latest News Source : Express Tribune Date : 11-04-2019

Pakistan and China have decided to amend the terms of agreement of the Mainline-1 railway project under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), and is now expected to be completed in three phases.

The project now has been reduced to 1680 km from 1872 km, and will operate under the Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) model through a public private partnership.



ML-1 Railways project under CPEC to be completed in 3 phases


ISLAMABAD: Pakistan and China have agreed to amend a framework agreement on implementation of multibillion dollars mainline-I project of the Pakistan Railways in a bid to reduce the size of the much-delayed strategically important scheme and to complete it in three phases.

The decision to split the project, which was once planned to be completed in three years, suggests that work on the single-largest project of the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) will now take at least six years to complete – from the day of its groundbreaking.

It has been agreed to reduce the length of the project from 1,872km to around 1,680 km, according to the government sources. The government has also decided to exclude the component of building a new 163km long double line between Karachi and Hyderabad from the scope of the framework agreement.

It has been decided that this component will be executed on Public-Private Partnership or Build Operate and Transfer Basis if declared feasible after the commercial and financial feasibility study, said sources in the Ministry of Railways.

Similarly, the Havelian-Textile rail track has also been excluded from the project. The ML-I project will be completed on the Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC) mode under a sovereign deal.

But like the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government, the government of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PT) has also failed to decide whether the Chinese loan for the ML-I project will be taken on the books of the Finance Ministry or that of the Ministry of Railways. In case the loan is taken on the books of the Finance Ministry, its servicing will also be the responsibility of the federal government.

An addendum to framework agreement will be signed to amend the Article-II to implement the ML-I project in three phases. According to sources in the Ministry of Planning and Development, the supplement agreement will be signed during Prime Minister Imran Khan’s upcoming visit to China. Khan will visit China on April 27 on an invitation of Chinese President Xi Jinping.

The original plan was to construct and upgrade the rail infrastructure between Peshawar and Karachi in two phases and to complete it by 2022. However, so far, both the sides are at the stage of finishing the feasibility study.

The sources said the Chinese consortium will submit the report by April 15 on the feasibility design that will provide a base for calculating the cost of the project. Originally, it had been estimated that the project would cost $8.2 billion, making it the single largest scheme under CPEC.

According to the original framework agreement of May 2017, China will provide 85% of the project cost as a concessionary loan. The project has been declared strategically important by both countries.

This month Minister for Planning Khusro Bakhtiar had said the government has decided to split the project into more than two phases and to drop some sections that were part of the original plan of constructing 1,872-kilometer long line of the Pakistan Railways. The cabinet had approved to set up an implementation committee to review cost, scope, and financing of the ML-I project.

Three Phases

Under the phase-I of the project, four sections will be completed in a period of three to four years. Except for one, almost all these section will be built from Rawalpindi to Lahore.

A 52-km-long second line for running 120km per hour high-speed train will be constructed from Kaluwai to Pindora. The other sections include upgrading of Nawabshah-Rohri section of 183km, Lalamusa-Rawalpindi section of 118km, and Lahore-Lalamusa section of 132km. The upgrading of Walton Railway Academy with a reduced scope is also part of phase one.

In the second phase that will also take over three years to complete, Multan-Lahore section and Kaimari-Hyderabad section will be constructed. The dry port at Havelian will also be part of the second phase but its scope has been reduced.

In the third phase, Pakistan and China have agreed to construct a Rawalpindi-Peshawar section and Hyderabad-Multan section. The Taxila-Havelian track has been dropped from the ML-I scope.

The sources said Chinese contractors have the technical capacity and financial muscles to complete the three phases simultaneously but the Pakistan Railways cannot afford to close its commercial traffic and the project has to be implemented in phases that will take more time.

Secondly, Pakistan does not have enough fiscal space to allocate the rupee component in the development budget in one go. At present, the Pakistan Railways is picking up less than 4% of the traffic volume of the country, which the government intends to increase to at least 20% by 2025.
Most busiest line KHI to HYD is not upgrading. This is not good. If they put good line in this area it will cover whole cost and also reduce fuel consumption. KHI to HYD intercity buses will be stop due to this
 
It says both countries agree that it has strategic value more than commercial. I presume by it they mean it ll be easier to mobilise the troops within the country in case of any emergency but it only takes one strike to render it useless. How do we intend to address that?
 
Reduced length -> Regressive
increased construction time -> Regressive
Build Operate Transfer -> Good

I think if Chinese are given the contract to build, they can build it in two years.

I agree that reduced length is regressive, but increased construction time - thats a good thing in my book. Far too often projects are rushed through to help clinch deals and then end up falling apart, because they've been done to poor standard to hit a deadline that was never possible. The political pressures on infrastructure projects are usually what cause them to fail.

Exhibit A - Road between Mirpur (AJK) and Kotli. Near the dam just ourside of Mirpur (near Khaliqabad) it was built by the Chinese. Half of one side slid into the dam a few years later.

Mind you that entire project is full of corruption. There is a bridge between Mirpur and Islamgarh that crosses the dam (reduces travel time for us pendus big time), but the last few km in the middle have been unfinished for years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rathoa_Haryam_Bridge
 
It says both countries agree that it has strategic value more than commercial. I presume by it they mean it ll be easier to mobilise the troops within the country in case of any emergency but it only takes one strike to render it useless. How do we intend to address that?

Strategic is not only used in military terms.
 
Most busiest line KHI to HYD is not upgrading. This is not good. If they put good line in this area it will cover whole cost and also reduce fuel consumption. KHI to HYD intercity buses will be stop due to this
No, as per OP, it will be built separately from ML-1 but on the same BOT principle after doing the feasibility study.. so it will be built InshaAllah.
 
So timeline has gone from 3 years to around 10 years, maybe more. This is pathetic.
 
Back
Top Bottom