Many Afghans See Their Future with India, Not Pakistan

[barbarosa]

The leader ship of northern Afghanistan does not like Pakistan because they have Indian language in their mouths.

 

[TMA]

Why only Afganistan,after all they are not the only neighbour Pakistan has,stop feeling insecure.
If Pakistanies belive you can take on India which is much bigger in every sence,but scared of Afganistan which is strugling to stand on its feet.

On one hand you want the Afgans to talk to taliban but at the same time Pakistan wont talk to Pakistan taliban.
And Afgans see that.

The Pakistani Taliban are not a political reality in Pakistan even with foreign support. If foreign help to them was curtailed they would fade away. However the Afghan Taliban ARE a political reality and even if foreign support was curtailed they would still be a political reality in Afghanistan. There is a difference.
Also the Afghan Taliban are OVERWHELMINGLY Afghans. The TTP are more of a mixture; Pakistanis, Pakistani citizens who are from Afghan background, Uzbeks from Uzbekistan, Tajiks from Tajikistan even Chechens.
Even many Pakistanis do not realize the number of foreigners in the Pakistani Taliban.

 

[Rahil khan]

They never liked Pakistan since 1947. Their dislike predates Pakistani interference into Afghanistan during the Soviet times and after.
It was Afghanistan who drew first blood by attempting destabilisation in the early years of Pakistan.

You need to learn a lot kidoo before drawing your assumptions here. We deal with Afghanis on daily basis even in our capital city. Those who managed to get a nationality here in love being part of Pakistani community. Due to historical reasons Afghanistan has never acknowledged Durand line till date...that's simply the core reason...a new born nation since 1947 was never in a position for decades to challenge Afghanistan...These Afghanis even malign Pakistan for Russian invasion, since that's their trademark impotency to accept their own responsibility...!! We faced consequences already...now it's your turn fellows.

 

[Dalit]

It's funny and ironic at the same time. These Afghans see their future with India, yet keep opting for Pakistan as their favorite mass refugee destination. Something is very wrong here.

The way I see it, repatriate them all and close the border. Don't allow them any space in our territory. The TAPI project is a waste of time.

As for the Afghans who think their future lies with India, stop coming to our country and instead fly over to India.

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

They should all be sent to their favourite country.
We have suffered enough.

 

[Samandri]

Most of these ungrateful afghans would be speaking russian and would have russian fathers if it weren't for us and at that time afghans supported CIA and pakistan in gettign rid of soviets

Its the sacrifices and exceptional bravery of Afghans, which defeated Soviets and in a way , unintentionally protected Pakistan of warm water from having Russian fathers

 

[CHD]

Its the sacrifices and exceptional bravery of Afghans, which defeated Soviets and in a way , unintentionally protected Pakistan of warm water from having Russian fathers

So with that bravery why cant you protect yourself now?

 

[TMA]

You need to learn a lot kidoo before drawing your assumptions here. We deal with Afghanis on daily basis even in our capital city. Those who managed to get a nationality here in love being part of Pakistani community....

I am sorry. I do not understand. Did I write something incorrect?

It's funny and ironic at the same time. These Afghans see their future with India, yet keep opting for Pakistan as their favorite mass refugee destination. Something is very wrong here.

The way I see it, repatriate them all and close the border. Don't allow them any space in our territory. The TAPI project is a waste of time.

As for the Afghans who think their future lies with India, stop coming to our country and instead fly over to India.

I also have written the same about closing the border. however I have been informed on defence.pk that in FATA the people have kinship links across the border and it would be very difficult to close the border, at least there. Also the Afghan government does not want to do this from their side as that would make it difficult for Afghan based "useful idiot" terrorists to attack Pakistan.

 

[Rahil khan]

I am sorry. I do not understand. Did I write something incorrect?
.

As i have mentioned before, you have to dig deep down before brushing ever thing with a single paint here..hope you get my point. .

 

[my2cents]

Afghanistan never even share a single border with India. India influence will be very limited. It is very easy for Pakistan to cut off India support of Afghanistan.

Afghanistan is at the bottom of HDI ladder. They are making baby steps in rebuilding their institutions and their country.
By isolating Afghanistan you will only draw more bad blood. Instead Pakistan should allow Afghanistan to grow into an equal nation. You can only do that by respecting their sovereignty.

 

[Dalit]

I am sorry. I do not understand. Did I write something incorrect?



I also have written the same about closing the border. however I have been informed on defence.pk that in FATA the people have kinship links across the border and it would be very difficult to close the border, at least there. Also the Afghan government does not want to do this from their side as that would make it difficult for Afghan based "useful idiot" terrorists to attack Pakistan.

Screw the kinship. I want a stable and prosperous Pakistan. Not one where Afghan based terrorists have the freedom to move around the border and kill our children in schools or our army officers protecting our land from harms way. We don't have anything in common with Afghans and frankly we don't want them on our soil.

There is no other solution than closing the border and expelling Afghans from Pakistan. Let the Afghans go to India since they love them that much. Why even bother coming to a place that the Afghans despise so much in the first place. These people are hypocrites of the first order.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Afghanistan is at the bottom of HDI ladder. They are making baby steps in rebuilding their institutions and their country.
By isolating Afghanistan you will only draw more bad blood. Instead Pakistan should allow Afghanistan to grow into an equal nation. You can only do that by respecting their sovereignty.

Why don't you start from Nepal,Maldives,Sri Lanka etc?

 

[Pulsar]

Pakistan has done more than enough its afghanistan which has now to do more, better to do it before some one else that enough is enough.Afghan taliban is not a terrorist group like TTP or ISIS they are political reality of afghanistan

The Taliban aren't a terrorist group? Are you for real? For God's sake, they have been responsible for the killing of over 3000 NATO soldiers - by suicide bombers, roadside IEDs, ambushes, the murder of civil liberties and so on!

The Afghans hate and detest them and they know that without the active support of Pakistan, the Taliban would have been destroyed long ago. And that's why they hate anything to do with Pakistan as they see them supporting Taliban terrorism resulting in the murder of thousands of Afghans including innocent men women and children and buggering up their way of life.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Screw the kinship. I want a stable and prosperous Pakistan. Not one where Afghan based terrorists have the freedom to move around the border and kill our children in schools or our army officers. There is no other solution than closing the border and expelling Afghans from Pakistan. Let the Afghans go to India since they love them that much. Why even bother coming to a place that the Afghans despise so much in the first place.

indian afghan historic ties... BC how ironic is that... It was always Pashtuns who (according to Indians) slaughtered and committed attrocities on Indians..

The Taliban aren't a terrorist group? Are you for real? For God's sake, they have been responsible for the killing of over 3000 NATO soldiers - by suicide bombers, roadside IEDs, ambushes, the murder of civil liberties and so on!

Taliban Are Not Terrorists, or So Says the White House - ABC News

The Afghans hate and detest them and they know that without the active support of Pakistan, the Taliban would have been destroyed long ago. And that's why they hate anything to do with Pakistan as they see them responsible for the murder of thousands of Afghans including innocent men women and children and buggering up their way of life.

Pakistan is so awesome ... IT supported Taliban against NATO,ANA etc with their trillion dollar weapons and funds... Damn nigga we badass!

Although no fukin insurgency can survive for decades without local support!

 

[Swastika]

sabka saahth sabka vikaas