Major General Sanaullah and Lt Colnol has died in IED blast in upper dir

[Amaa'n]

Dont pretend to be dumb , fazlullah of TNSM is independent from waziristan-based taliban, only a nominal alliance with them. You have to approach them separately for ceasefire ,which they dont need as they operate from afghanistan and are quite comfortable.

i said something about approaching fazullah on page 2, you can read that.
btw no one has claimed responsibility yet. its just an assumption that it was them. so lets wait for the formal words

 

[Safriz]

Stick to the topic guys

The topc is terrorism...dont like it? Leave it.

 

[pakdefender]

Pakistan can not declare qabaili as enemy of pakistan. As it would provoke all pashtuns from swat to quetta, as well as those of afghanistan. Pak army can not even defeat few thousands taliban , how can they make 35 million pakhtuns their enemy. Pakhtuns are not baloch that you can easily crush, any kind of misadventure like east pakistan would lead to disintegration of pakistan within months.

wihtout this declaration , the war cannot be won.

Pakistan should not give in to 'another bangladesh' blackmail and use full force against the enemy

 

[Safriz]

i said something about approaching fazullah on page 2, you can read that.
btw no one has claimed responsibility yet. its just an assumption that it was them. so lets wait for the formal words

Yes
An anonymous phone call to an anonymous source and all gets rubbed under the carpet.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

-----------------------------------

Honestly i would have preferred american air strikes and ground operations in FATA, pak army didnt need to involve in this confusing war on order of america.

 

[jaibi]

Ina lillah e wa ina eleh-e-rajeun.

Let this be known to all those who say that our generals do not take the risk of the battlefield. May their sacrifice never go in vain.

 

[Safriz]

Honestly i would have preferred american air strikes and ground operations in FATA, pak army didnt need to involve in this confusing war on order of america.

Yes... Thats another farce...
USA blows them up via drones and they take revenge from Pakistan Army.
And some even love American strikes,such as the commentor above.

 

[EMERCOM]

Yes... Thats another farce...
USA blows them up via drones and they take revenge from Pakistan Army.
And some even love American strikes,such as the commentor above.

Why are you guys killing your own brothers?

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Obviously if all pushtoons decde to take sides with terrorists,that makes all pushtoons terrorists.Its as simple as that.
Although i doubt it will happen.

My logic is simple..Who lives in a land with no laws? Who is trained from childhood to use weapons and to shoot to kill?
Who has plenty of sympathizers on tribal basis,no matter how wrong they are?
Who has ready access to large weapons munitions and explosives?


The answer to all the above is not Punjabi?

How do you explain all those aman lashkars who fought against taliban for pak army? How do you explain FC ,levies and khasadar who are tribals?. I have met atleast two captains in army who were from waziristan, one got recently killed in chilas...how do you explain that? How come these "barbarians" are serving in armed forces?...are they also "ghayor qabaili"...how come lt.general tariq khan is allowed, he is from bhittani tribal agency?

 

[Mine]

RIP

what is SELF PROCLAIMED world best Intelligence(ISI) doing

 

[Safriz]

How do you explain all those aman lashkars who fought against taliban for pak army? How do you explain FC ,levies and khasadar who are tribals?. I have met atleast two captains in army who were from waziristan, one got recently killed in chilas...how do you explain that? How come these "barbarians" are serving in armed forces?...are they also "ghayor qabaili"...how come lt.general tariq khan is allowed, he is from bhittani tribal agency?

There many Arabs and pakistani origin soldiers in USA army and NATO....that doesnt mean these armies dont consider Arabs and Pakistan as a threat...

 

[Kompromat]

Looks like a man in command as men of stature always do. Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un (do not know if it is appropriate for me to write it this way but it seems appropriate for the soldier).

It is appropriate.

 

[pakdefender]

How do you explain all those aman lashkars who fought against taliban for pak army? How do you explain FC ,levies and khasadar who are tribals?. I have met atleast two captains in army who were from waziristan, one got recently killed in chilas...how do you explain that? How come these "barbarians" are serving in armed forces?...are they also "ghayor qabaili"...how come lt.general tariq khan is allowed, he is from bhittani tribal agency?

so after all this , why do people like you still defend the henious acts of those pashtun elements who have declared war on Pakistan and are knowingly ( or unknowingly ) doing the work for Pakistan's enemies ?

Judging from the name Sanaullah Niazi , the shaheed General himself is most probably pashtun.

 

[Kompromat]

Dreamreaper and Pakone have been restricted from this thread for a short while.

 

[janon]

TTP has claimed responsibility, according to Dawn.

Frankly, the assassination of such high ranking officers is rather worrisome. Maybe they simply laid an IED and got lucky. On the other hand, if these officers were the actual intended target, that poses some serious questions, about who is supplying the TTP with the intel about their movements, why there was no recce or sanitization of the route and so on.

It is unlikely that they could have targeted them without inside info about their movements.

BTW, has Pakistan ever lost such a high ranking officer before, to the TTP or other domestic groups?