The case happened in my state. Initially it was actually a simple love marriage issue.But the guy took it to court,
It is false. The guy didn't take it to the court, but it were the parents of the girl who went to the court.
But the guy took it to court, where his case was presented by a high class lawyer (paid @ 1lakh per sitting). Then multiple fake affidavits were signed by the guy. Court took all this into consideration and made the marriage invalid and ordered investigation.
Again false. The guy didn't have to make the fake affidavits. It was the girl who herself came to the Court and she witnessed personally in the court that neither she was forced for conversion, nor for the marriage. Therefore, all these claims by Hindu extremists about false affidavits are purely lies. I don't see any reason that you too deny the direct witness of the girl and present here the lies of the extremists.
As far as costly lawyer is concerned, then the system is to be blamed where money speaks. In an ideal world justice should not need money.
Nevertheless, in my opinion there are Muslim organizations who help the people who convert to Islam. Similarly, there are Hindu organizations who give money and help those who convert back to Hinduism. None of that is illegal in the eyes of present Indian law, which says if people want to take money for changing their religion, then let it be.
I find it unjust on your behalf, when you only mention the Islamic organizations helping with the converts, but neglect the Hindu Organizations who also convert the people by doing same things.
Now forget about the money. You can buy the lawyer through money, but you cannot buy the Justice in the Court, which is based upon the Evidences. And there is only one evidence that girl witnessed herself in the court.
Therefore, the decision of Kerala court is worst example in the history of judiciary. I have no words to mention for this shameful act by the Kerala court.
Kerala court sent her back by saying she is weak in her judgement. This is an abuse to the woman intelligence. She is 24 and court remarks are simply shameful.
Then this guy approached supreme court and court apprehend the decision and handed over the case to NIA (FBI equivalent). This guy was mutual friend with those who joined ISIS from Kerala.
This happened in the Supreme Court.
Very basic question is why the Supreme Court didn't let the girl to come in the court and give her testimony? How a court could decide if it was a forced conversion and the forced marriage without even hearing the girl?
Why the Supreme court is linking her case to the Terrorism? If there is any Terrorist organization, then Indian anti terrorist agency NIA should have taken action against them without even the case of this girl. Nobody is answering why NIA has not taken the action up till now?
And if this boy and one ISIS person are members of same facebook group, then NIA should have arrested him 1 year ago at the time of marriage, or at least at the time when Kerala high court said that he and one person are members of same facebook page.
For sure all this is a political and religious stunt and justice has been killed in this whole process.
I am an Atheist from Pakistan.
In Pakistan, there are many Hindu Families in Sindh. And Hindu girls are abducted, and then forced to convert to Islam and then married. And there is group of Muslim fanatics and Mullahs which support all this, and police could do almost nothing against it.
But still Majority of Pakistanies (even if they are Muslims) are against it and trying to protect the Hindu girls for this forced conversion and marriage. The situation has become little better after so much protest, but still the Mullahs in Pakistan are very strong and very difficult to get rights for the minorities in Islamic Pakistan.
////////
In India, it seems that Hindu girls are not “abducted” as compared to Pakistan. At least there is no report of abduction of Hindu Girl and also no report of Forced conversion. And if there are few cases, then there are already laws against it and these are individual families who forces in these cases, and it has nothing to do with this term of Love Jihad. Such use of force could also be done in the Hindu families by the individuals.
All the reports from India show that girls came in love relationship and then converted to Islam only through verbal pressure. Those girls got the full right to end such relationship and to deny to accept Islam.
Therefore, it is difficult for me to accept this “Love Jihad” thing in India.
If girls are abducted and forced, then it is already a CRIME and it does not need any proof of “Love Jihad” in order to file a case against it in the police.
Obviously, there are problems that:
(1) Girls are not mature enough. They are young and become blind in love.
You may increase the age of marriage in this case. Nevertheless, this will also effect Hindu girls marrying Hindu boys out of love.
It would be wrong to hide the problem of non-maturity of girls under the disguise of “Love Jihad”.
(2) Other argument is this that such girls are afterwards forced to stay in the marriage (even after it becomes clear to her that she made a mistake).
Once again, I would say it is an Evil of Indian society, which should not be hidden behind the “Love Jihad” hoax.
Indian society has to change it’s behaviour. When a girl marries a Muslim boy, then her family and society totally cut ties with her as punishment. This is totally wrong behaviour. In this way, you are cutting her way back to the normal life.
Actually forget about “Love Jihad”. Even a girl marrying a Hindu boy, she is normally forced to stay with him and his family even the girl is unhappy. Why? Because of the wrong standards of the Hindu society at moment which is very unforgiving for the divorced girls.
(3) I see anger here where people are saying: “how come more Hindu girls marry Muslims, as compared to Muslim girls marrying Hindu boys”.
Muslims have very Isolated system. There girls are very afraid of doing rebel against the family and religion, while both religion and the family are very non forgiving.
Hindus have also some what a system of this “force” upon the girls and boys that they should not marry even to the Christians, or out of caste etc.
Thus in the West, once again it is common that Hindu boys easily marry the Western girls, but it is not common that Hindu girls marry a Western boy.
The answer does not lies in becoming the same as Muslims i.e. to create a totally isolated system for Hindu girls and forcing them , and to crush their rebellion and love in name of love Jihad etc.
Just educating the girls is enough, and then to let the path open for them if they want to return. Just come out of this ignorance that a divorced woman is a bad omen.
