What's new

Look: Abu Dhabi Hindu temple rising ‘at great pace’

WOW! you violate those edicts you posted above- by being under the rule of Amerika, with its Judea Christian laws, and where you are forced to live among and PAY TAXES that benefit idol worshippers.

Come again!‽
Don't throw incoherent drivel at me... want to have a conversation? Half baked desultory claptrap... be half way cogent or bug off
 
.
Incorrect on a few accounts, brother.

Shirk was banned from the Ka'bah, by the actual ayat in the Quran. Some who did not convert actually did leave Makkah, most converted. Could you please provide the source of the above three conditions?

Every other non-Muslim region that was conquered thereafter was given the following choices before the assault,

1) Embrace Islam
2) Pay jizya
3) Fight

After Makkah, the Muslims marched towards Ta'if, having learnt of their previous plans to flank the Muslims during the siege of Makkah. They met and defeated Hawazin (Ta'if's allies) at Hunayn. They then went on to besiege Ta'if. The siege failed and the Muslims returned. After a while, being surrounded by Muslim settlements Ta'if decided to negotiate. The negotiations ensued for a while until the people of Ta'if accepted the Prophet's (S.A.W) demands and converted. They were crying and wailing in the streets when their idols were being destroyed even though they had officially "converted". Mentioned this to show that all did not choose to embrace Islam and those who did, not all of them did it for the faith itself. It was after Tabouk that tribes from all across Arabia started sending their delegations to pledge allegiance to the Prophet (S.A.W) and that is how and when most of the peninsula became Muslim. Some still didn't, though.

Plenty of non-Muslims remained in the rest of the peninsula, entire towns even. Banu Taghlib was a Christian tribe who did not convert until long after the advent of Islam (They even had a false prophet). There are native Christians present in Kuwait and Bahrain to this day. Banu al-Harith is a Jewish tribe whose descendants are still present in the peninsula. Many more examples even closer to Medina who were left alone until Hazrat Umar's (RA) Khilafah when they were acted against for different reasons. “No two religions”: Non-Muslims in the early Islamic Ḥijāz by Harry Munt is a good read. This idea about the peninsula was introduced later.

I mean why would Islam forbid non-Muslims from all of the Arab Peninsula anyway? The whole peninsula isn't holy land. What is the significance of the peninsula itself? Nothing, it's just a geographical feature. It had no unified history, politics, identity until the Muslims united it. It is Makkah and Medina, by proxy of being the Prophet's (S.A.W) resting place, that are religiously important. Otherwise, Jerusalem is far more significant to Islam than any other part of the peninsula.



There were 3 false prophets after the Prophet's (S.A.W) death. 1 woman (Sajjah who was a Christian) and 2 men (Musaylamah and Tulayha). Hazrat Abu Bakar (RA) fought wars against them not because they were non-Muslim or because of their false prophethood but because they refused to pay zakat as per their agreements with the Prophet (S.A.W) himself, i.e. treason. There was a massive debate on this amongst the Sahabah in Medina before the wars. Hazrat Umar (RA) advised against the war due to the politically volatile circumstances of the state after the Prophet's (S.A.W) death. This is all very well documented. People deliberately misquote this event to misguide us and further their own agendas against non-Muslims (Not you. Our mullahs).
Unfortunately, we don’t have a clear repository to document these guiding examples since everything is noise in Pakistani religious education.
Islam is the most pragmatic way of life ever available to humans and yet what is pitched as Islamic these days in many countries makes the Mayan’s self destructive culture seem benign.

Ironically, Hejaz is about to get a multinational and multicultural project in Neom which will likely include Churches, Synagogues and Temples.
 
.
الله يبارك فيك أيضا

Like I said, I understand, but we are hurt because most Pakistanis are emotional when it comes to India because India and its people are enemies of muslims and Pakistan's very existence.

Anyways, you people are our muslim brothers. When you bleed, we feel the pain. I dont know of any Pakistani who can even think of hurting the UAE by choice.

However, in light of steps taken by UAE especially vis a vis india, Pakistan has no choice but to cultivate its relations with Iran and Turkey.

I dont know if you know that developing relations with Iran are controversial in Pakistan as its considered an open rejection to GCC. This mentality of Pakistan has to change now.

UAE and Pakistan should become stronger business partners and our business relations should grow, but sadly our security interests are now different.

May be its good for Pakistan as it will now learn to stand on its own feet.

اتمنى لك كل التوفيق
"India and its people are enemies of muslims and Pakistan's very existence."

Of the Pakistani state. Yes. Of Pakistan's existence - No. Of Muslims - of course not.
 
.
Unfortunately, we don’t have a clear repository to document these guiding examples since everything is noise in Pakistani religious education.
Islam is the most pragmatic way of life ever available to humans and yet what is pitched as Islamic these days in many countries makes the Mayan’s self destructive culture seem benign.

Ironically, Hejaz is about to get a multinational and multicultural project in Neom which will likely include Churches, Synagogues and Temples.

The original Islamic scholastic tradition is an academic marvel. Their documentation is mind-bogglingly comprehensive. The repositories still exist and are available for all but are deliberately kept ignored by the mullah and the people because they don't fit our modern "Muslim" agendas.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom