Letter from an Indian Woman

[fitpOsitive]

I don't think so. Are you suggesting Indian women are asking for rape? Or they are also raping men? What about dowry? What about infanticide? Blaming women is not going to solve it. Letting them out of India will.

What about my first statement.

 

[Mamluk]

What about my first statement.

That can't be one of the main reasons. There's liberty and ignorance in the West too. But India's rape epidemic is unique.

 

[Shamsher1990]

So basically Everthing negative about india is just a conspiracy?

Nope. That is not true.

 

[Shamsher1990]

None of the two are written by Robert Lindsay himself, the first from an Indian woman and the second from some other guy who did the social experiment with Indians.

First is from an Indian woman, if you believe Robert Lindsay to be speaking truth. He has shown tendencies to post false narratives and false stories about non-white folks. How do you know it is not something he has written himself and claiming it to be coming from an anonymous Indian woman? The only proof that it is indeed from an Indian woman is from his own blog and his own word.

If you don't trust him, then it makes anything on his blog doubtful. Even the ones he is claiming to be from someone else, unless he gives evidence to contrary.

 

[Shamsher1990]

second from some other guy who did the social experiment with Indians.

Second 'expriment', if you call it one, has basic experiment design problem. It does not consider other possibilities for the observation.

The cliche usually given is if you see more people eating ice cram and more incidences of shark attacks on people that does not necessarily mean that ice cream makes people more tasty to sharks. There can be a simple explanation that its summer and people are eating more ice-cream and more people are going for a swim in ocean. Hence the observation: more ice-cream sale and more shark attacks.

 

[fitpOsitive]

That can't be one of the main reasons. There's liberty and ignorance in the West too. But India's rape epidemic is unique.

Law-less freedom, actually what I meant.